Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 26;9:851172. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2022.851172

TABLE 2.

The machine learning models and traditional polynomial models.

References Parameters Detail methods Number of subjects MAE (mmHg)
Standard deviation (mmHg)
Dataset Subject description
DBP SBP DBP SBP
Machine learning related models Chowdhury et al. (84) PPG features Gaussian process regression 219 3.02 1.74 5.54 9.29 Public data (87) 657 PPG signal samples from 219 subjects.
Aguirre et al. (86) PPG wave Deep learning with attention mechanism 1100 6.57 14.39 8.43 17.87 MIMIC-III 10,696 segments corresponding to 1131 subjects.
Xing et al. (83) PPG features, BMI Random forest algorithm 1249 2.3 (Young, Fitting error) 2.1 (Young, Fitting error) 9.5 (Young) 13.6 (Young) Specific data A total of 2358 measurements were recorded, including young, old populations. Normal, pre-hypertension and stage I, II, III hypertension.
Watanabe et al. (85) PPG features Specific algorithm based on second derivative of photeplethysmogram wave. 887 NA NA NA NA Specific data A total of 887 participants were enrolled. Various feature parameters of pulse wave participants at rest an under exercise, mental stress are collected.
Zhang et al. (30) PTT (HRV, ECG, PPG, other PPG features) LR: linear regression
SVR: support vector regression
RF: random forest regression
Adaboost: adaptive boosting
3337 5.35 10.03 4.5 7.96 MIMIC I and VitalDB Hybrid dataset (including 3,337 subjects) combining MIMIC and VitalDB databases.
Traditional polynomial models Ghosh et al. (79) PTT (R peak of ECG and peak of PPG) BP=aPTT+b 14 6.64 (Recumbent) 4.6 (Recumbent) 5.2 (Recumbent) 9.6 (Recumbent) Specific data 14 subjects performed activities including: recumbent, seated, standing, walking, cycling, need calibration.
Huynh et al. (80) PTT DBP=DBP0+ρD2PTT21n[1+K(Zmax0-Zmin)](A.2a)
SBP=DBP0+ρD2PTT21n[1+K(Zmax0-Zmin)](A.2b)
15 5.02 ± 0.73 (RMSE) 8.47 ± 0.91 (RMSE) NA NA Specific data 15 young, healthy human subjects leveraging handgrip exercises.
Esmaili et al. (81) PTT BP=a0+a2+a21PTT2 32 3.97 6.22 5.15 9.44 Specific data 32 healthy subjects in the age range of 21–50 years performed physical exercise.
Lin et al. (82) PTT (PPG features) Linear regression and four previously reported models (8891). 22 3.16 (DS) 3.19 (DS) 5.04 (DS) 7.8 (DS) Specific data 22 subjects when they performed mental arithmetic stress and Valsalva’s manoeuvre tasks that could induce BP fluctuations.