TABLE 2.
The machine learning models and traditional polynomial models.
References | Parameters | Detail methods | Number of subjects | MAE (mmHg) |
Standard deviation (mmHg) |
Dataset | Subject description | |||
DBP | SBP | DBP | SBP | |||||||
Machine learning related models | Chowdhury et al. (84) | PPG features | Gaussian process regression | 219 | 3.02 | 1.74 | 5.54 | 9.29 | Public data (87) | 657 PPG signal samples from 219 subjects. |
Aguirre et al. (86) | PPG wave | Deep learning with attention mechanism | 1100 | 6.57 | 14.39 | 8.43 | 17.87 | MIMIC-III | 10,696 segments corresponding to 1131 subjects. | |
Xing et al. (83) | PPG features, BMI | Random forest algorithm | 1249 | 2.3 (Young, Fitting error) | 2.1 (Young, Fitting error) | 9.5 (Young) | 13.6 (Young) | Specific data | A total of 2358 measurements were recorded, including young, old populations. Normal, pre-hypertension and stage I, II, III hypertension. | |
Watanabe et al. (85) | PPG features | Specific algorithm based on second derivative of photeplethysmogram wave. | 887 | NA | NA | NA | NA | Specific data | A total of 887 participants were enrolled. Various feature parameters of pulse wave participants at rest an under exercise, mental stress are collected. | |
Zhang et al. (30) | PTT (HRV, ECG, PPG, other PPG features) | LR: linear regression SVR: support vector regression RF: random forest regression Adaboost: adaptive boosting |
3337 | 5.35 | 10.03 | 4.5 | 7.96 | MIMIC I and VitalDB | Hybrid dataset (including 3,337 subjects) combining MIMIC and VitalDB databases. | |
Traditional polynomial models | Ghosh et al. (79) | PTT (R peak of ECG and peak of PPG) | 14 | 6.64 (Recumbent) | 4.6 (Recumbent) | 5.2 (Recumbent) | 9.6 (Recumbent) | Specific data | 14 subjects performed activities including: recumbent, seated, standing, walking, cycling, need calibration. | |
Huynh et al. (80) | PTT |
(A.2a) (A.2b) |
15 | 5.02 ± 0.73 (RMSE) | 8.47 ± 0.91 (RMSE) | NA | NA | Specific data | 15 young, healthy human subjects leveraging handgrip exercises. | |
Esmaili et al. (81) | PTT | 32 | 3.97 | 6.22 | 5.15 | 9.44 | Specific data | 32 healthy subjects in the age range of 21–50 years performed physical exercise. | ||
Lin et al. (82) | PTT (PPG features) | Linear regression and four previously reported models (88–91). | 22 | 3.16 (DS) | 3.19 (DS) | 5.04 (DS) | 7.8 (DS) | Specific data | 22 subjects when they performed mental arithmetic stress and Valsalva’s manoeuvre tasks that could induce BP fluctuations. |