Appendix 6—table 1. Investigating the relation between the date of ‘lockdown’ and the date that the estimated dropped below 1.
The first three columns contain the same information as the first four columns of the main text Table 1. The last two columns are analogous to the third (‘ based on confirmed cases’) but are based on estimates for hospitalisations and deaths respectively. For each of these observation types, we used our method to determine when the estimate first dropped below 1, and for which dates the corresponding 95% confidence interval contained 1. Further, we used news reports to determine when a country implemented stay-at-home orders (a ‘lockdown’). Based on our estimates for confirmed cases, Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands, and Slovenia had 95% confidence intervals that included or were below one before a nationwide lockdown was implemented. For estimates based on COVID-19 deaths, there are also four: Denmark, the Netherlands, Poland, and the United Kingdom. See Appendix 2 for smoothing related caveats.
Country | Lockdown | based on Confirmed cases | based on Deaths | based on Hospitalisations |
---|---|---|---|---|
Austria | 16–03 | 20–03 [20-03, 20-03] | ||
Belgium | 18–03 | 30–03 [25-03, 03-04] | 26–03 [24-03, 26-03] | 25–03 [24-03, 25-03] |
Denmark | 18–03 | 10–03 [10-03, 20-06] | 22–03 [18-03, 07-01] | |
Finland | 16–03 | 02–04 [29-03, 30-04] | 07–04 [25-03, 11-04] | |
France | 17–03 | 27–03 [23-03, 07-04] | 24–03 [22-03, 26-03] | 27–03 [25-03, 26-03] |
Germany | 22–03 | 18–03 [17-03, 19-03] | 31–03 [23-03, 04-04] | |
Ireland | 27–03 | 08–04 [04–04, 15–04] | 05–04 [31-03, 09-04] | 06–04 [06–04, 26–04] |
Italy | 10–03 | 18–03 [17-03, 19-03] | 14–03 [01–03, 29–05] | |
Netherlands | 23–03 | 05–04 [22-03, 10-04] | 22–03 [19-03, 02-04] | 26–03 [24-03, 26-03] |
Norway | 14–03 | 21–03 [17-03, 24-03] | 25–03 [18-03, 08-04] | |
Poland | 25–03 | 02–04 [31-03, 17-04] | 09–04 [24-03, 01-12] | |
Portugal | 16–03 | 28–03 [23-03, 15-04] | 28–03 [21-03, 12-04] | |
Romania | 24–03 | 06–04 [31-03, 29-04] | 17–04 [25-03, 28-04] | |
Russian Federation | 30–03 | 04–05 [01–05, 08–05] | 18–05 [14-05, 12-12] | |
Slovenia | 20–03 | 23–03 [13-03, 26-03] | 26–03 [20–03, ≥03-05-2021] | |
Spain | 14–03 | 26–03 [25-03, 26-03] | ||
Sweden | 01–04 [06–03,≥03-05-2021] | 05–04 [13–03,≥03-05-2021] | ||
Switzerland | 17–03 | 22–03 [20-03, 22-03] | 21–03 [18-03, 23-03] | 18–03 [16-03, 18-03] |
Turkey | 21–03 | 08–04 [01–04, 13–04] | 04–04 [31-03, 06-04] | |
United Kingdom | 24–03 | 30–03 [28-03, 20-04] | 25–03 [24-03, 25-03] | 29–03 [27-03, 29-03] |