Table 1.
Association direction | Evidence of consistency across studies and dose-response | Bias potential (epidemiologic studies) | |
---|---|---|---|
Ionizing radiation | ↑ Childhood exposure only | Consistent findings; evidence of dose-response | Some; exposure, if known, may be associated with thyroid screening |
Benign thyroid conditions | ↑ Thyroid nodules ↑ Goiter ↑ Hyperthyroidism − Hypothyroidism |
Consistent findings; some evidence of dose-response for thyroid function parameters | Substantial; conditions likely associated with thyroid screening |
Dietary factors | ↑ Iodine (papillary thyroid cancer) ↓ Iodine (follicular thyroid cancer) − Vegetables or fruits − Meat − Coffee or tea |
Inconsistent findings; no clear evidence of dose-response (except iodine and follicular thyroid cancer) | Moderate (iodine); confounding likely in ecological studies |
Metabolic factors | ↑ Obesity/excess adiposity − Metabolic syndrome − Diabetes Type II − Hypertension − Dyslipidemia |
Consistent findings; evidence of dose-response (obesity/excess adiposity) | Some; conditions may be associated with thyroid screening |
Reproductive factors/sex steroid hormones | − Parity, age at menarche, age at menopause, use of exogenous hormones ↑ Hysterectomy ↑ Infertility |
Inconsistent findings; no clear evidence of dose-response with hormonal exposures | Moderate; reproductive events or hormone use may be associated with thyroid screening |
Perinatal and in utero exposures | ↑ Birth weight − Maternal or paternal age − Pregnancy characteristics and complications − Maternal smoking ↑ Maternal thyroid conditions ↑ Congenital hypothyroidism |
Consistent findings and evidence of dose-response (birth weight); evidence on maternal and congenital thyroid conditions based on only one study | Moderate; maternal/paternal characteristics and medical conditions may be associated with thyroid screening |
Cigarette smoking and alcohol consumption | ↓ | Consistent findings; evidence of dose-response | Some; behavior may be associated with thyroid screening |
Environmental contaminants | − Flame retardants − Pesticides − Volcanic environment/heavy metals |
Inconsistent findings; no clear evidence of dose-response | Some; exposure, if known, may be associated with thyroid screening |
Association with thyroid cancer risk, based on overall evidence: ↑ = positive; ↓ = inverse; − = null