Table 3:
Pathological findings in autopsy specimens submitted to the CDC for the evaluation of suspected EVALI
| Weeks from illness onset to death* | Pathological diagnosis in lung tissue | Intra-alveolar macrophages in lung tissue | Other pathological findings in lung tissue | CDC tissue-based infectious disease testing | Major findings in other organs | Findings from initial chest or abdomen CT or x-ray† | Age group, years | E-cigarette or vaping product use | Medical comorbidities at autopsy‡ and smoking history | Surveillance case definition classification § | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Autopsies with evidence of acute lung injury and no alternative cause | |||||||||||
| Case 11 | 2 weeks | Diffuse alveolar damage (exudative and proliferative), diffuse | Pigmented macrophages (pigment not otherwise specified) and non-pigmented macrophages, multifocal | Multifocal moderate anthracosis; mild haemorrhage; mild oedema | PCR for influenza A, B, RSV, and PIV1–4 negative; Gram stain negative; Streptococcus spp IHC negative, Streptococcus pyogenes, select Gram-negative bacteria:¶ IHC negative in the lung, liver, and kidney | Extensive glomerular fibrin thrombi in the kidney; multifocal arteriolosclerosis; mild oedema in the brain | Not done | <35 | THC, nicotine | Conventional cigarette smoking | Confirmed |
| Case 12 | 2 weeks | Acute fibrinous and organising pneumonia, diffuse | Abundant pigmented macrophages (pigment not otherwise specified) and non-pigmented macrophages | Multifocal moderate anthracosis; bronchoaspiration; haemorrhage | PCR for PIV1–4; positive for PIV1 in trachea, negative in the bronchus and lung; PCR for influenza A, B, and RSV negative in the trachea, bronchus, and lung | Diffuse small droplet steatosis in the liver; subcapsular cortical atrophy with chronic interstitial nephritis and glomerulosclerosis in the kidney; multifocal contraction band necrosis and interstitial haemorrhage (attributed to resuscitation) in the heart; mild multifocal perivascular haemorrhage in the brain; mild tracheobronchitis in the upper airway | Diffuse patchy ground glass opacities and consolidation, more prominent on the right lung and in the lung bases | <35 | THC, nicotine | Conventional cigarette smoking | Probable |
| Case 13 | 4 weeks | Diffuse alveolar damage (proliferative) | Multifocal abundant foamy macrophages, non-pigmented macrophages, and pigmented macrophages (pigment not otherwise specified) | Multifocal moderate anthracosis; intravascular leukocytosis; neutrophilic inflammation, focal | Not done | Glomerulosclerosis, mononuclear interstitial nephritis in the kidney | Diffuse ground glass opacities superimposed on paraseptal and centrilobular emphysema | ≥35 | THC | Immunosuppression; chronic kidney disease; hypertension; conventional cigarette smoking | Confirmed |
| Case 14 | 4 weeks | Diffuse alveolar damage (proliferative) | Multifocal non-pigmented macrophages; occasional pigmented macrophages (pigment not otherwise specified) | Anthracosis, rare; haemorrhage, focal; extensive intravascular leukocytosis | Gram stain and GMS non-contributory in the lung | Haemophagocytosis, sinus histiocytosis in the lymph node; fibrin thrombi, acute tubular necrosis in the kidney; central venous congestion in the liver | Moderate extensive patchy bilateral lower lobe consolidation, mediastinal and hilar lymphadenopathy | <35 | THC | Conventional cigarette smoking | Confirmed |
| Case 15 | 6–8 weeks | Patchy diffuse alveolar damage (exudative); and geographic (proliferative) | Abundant foamy macrophages and pigmented macrophages (haemosiderin-laden and subset of pigmented macrophages not otherwise specified) | Abundant anthracosis; squamous metaplasia; mild haemorrhage; emphysema; septal oedema | Gram stain, GMS, and AFB negative; Streptococcus spp and select Gram-negative bacteria: IHC negative in the lung | Glomerulosclerosis in the kidney; central venous congestion in the liver | Multifocal extensive bilateral patchy airspace disease | ≥35 | THC, nicotine | Chronic respiratory disease; chronic pain; conventional cigarette smoking | Confirmed |
| Case 16 | 6–8 weeks | Diffuse alveolar damage (organising), diffuse | Moderate foamy macrophages and pigmented macrophages (predominantly haemosiderin-laden macrophages, also pigment not otherwise specified) | Anthracosis, rare; bronchiolitis, neutrophilic and mononuclear; squamous metaplasia; necrosis in airways; inspissated mucus; pulmonary haemorrhage; alveolar oedema and necrosis; honeycomb cyst formation | Gram and GMS negative; PCR for influenza A, B, RSV, PIV1–4 negative in the lung | Neutrophils and mononuclear cells in the trachea; immunoblasts and neutrophils in red pulp in the spleen | Diffuse bilateral ground glass opacities, mediastinal and hilar lymphadenopathy | <35 | THC, nicotine | Not reported | Confirmed |
| Case 17 | 9–11 weeks | Diffuse alveolar damage (organising) | Foamy macrophages, rare; multifocal pigmented macrophages (haemosiderin-laden and pigment not otherwise specified) | Anthracosis, rare; squamous metaplasia; smooth muscle hyperplasia; bronchopneumonia; bronchiectasis or restructuring | Not done | Central venous necrosis in the liver; acute tubular kidney necrosis; heart congestion; tracheitis, neutrophilic | Ground glass opacities and right-sided pneumonia | ≥35 | THC, nicotine | Diabetes; obesity; chronic respiratory disease; chronic pain; hypertension; chronic liver disease; conventional cigarette smoking | Confirmed |
| Case 18 | 9–11 weeks | Diffuse alveolar damage (organising) | Multifocal moderate foamy macrophages; multifocal moderate pigmented macrophages (haemosiderin-laden) | Multifocal rare anthracosis; squamous metaplasia; mononuclear interstitial inflammation; bronchiectasis or restructuring; extensive haemorrhage | Not done | Liver steatosis and cirrhosis; myocyte loss and fibrosis in the heart | Extensive bilateral ground glass opacities | ≥35 | THC | Conventional cigarette smoking; chronic liver disease | Confirmed |
| Autopsies with no evidence of acute lung injury or with acute lung injury due to an alternative cause | |||||||||||
| Case 19 | 3 weeks | Multifocal bronchopneumonia | Rare foamy macrophages and pigmented macrophages (haemosiderin-laden); moderate non-pigmented macrophages | Anthracosis, rare; erythrophagocytosis; eosinophilic bronchiolitis; intravascular leukocytosis | Gram-variable cocci in pairs in the lung; Streptococcus spp IHC: positive in the lung, negative in the kidney; PCR for Streptococcus pneumoniae: positive in the lung | None seen | Multiple opacified bronchi in both lungs (greatest in lower lobe), patchy consolidation, nodular and ground glass opacities throughout the lungs (greatest in lower lobes) | <35 | Nicotine | Conventional cigarette smoking | Probable |
| Case 20 | 4 weeks | Increased alveolar macrophages, fibrin, haemorrhage, and bronchoaspiration | Multifocal rare foamy macrophages; locally extensive pigmented macrophages (haemosiderin-laden) | Multifocal rare anthracosis; multifocal bronchoaspiration; haemorrhage locally extensive and multifocal; intravascular leukocytosis | Streptococcus spp, select Gram-negative bacteria: IHC negative in the lung, liver, and kidney; PCR for influenza A, B, RSV, PIV1–4 negative in the trachea | Liver cirrhosis; myocardial fibrosis; necrotising tracheitis in the trachea | Extensive bilateral lung opacities on chest x-ray (no CT done) | ≥35 | THC, nicotine, CBD | Chronic respiratory disease; obesity; cardiac disease; chronic liver disease; conventional cigarette smoking | Probable |
| Case 21 | 12 weeks or more | Chronic interstitial lung disease (non-specific interstitial pneumonia), diffuse; mild bronchiolitis | Rare foamy macrophages; extensive pigmented macrophages (haemosiderin-laden) | Multifocal mild anthracosis; inspissated mucus, macrophages, and neutrophils in airways; squamous metaplasia; haemorrhage; honeycomb cysts | Gram stain and GMS: negative in the lung | Not submitted | Diffuse interstitial thickening with ground glass opacities | ≥35 | THC | Obesity; obstructive sleep apnoea; diabetes; chronic pain; conventional cigarette smoking | Confirmed |
| Case 22 | 2 weeks | Multifocal diffuse alveolar damage (exudative); mild focal bronchopneumonia | Rare foamy macrophages; abundant pigmented macrophages (haemosiderin-laden) | Multifocal moderate anthracosis; mild haemorrhage; septal oedema; intravascular leukocytosis; fibrin thrombi | Gram-negative rods in the kidney; Escherichia coli IHC positive in the kidney, negative in the liver, lung, heart, spleen | Severe kidney pyelonephritis; passive congestion and small droplet steatosis in the liver | Bilateral ground glass opacities and consolidative opacities with areas of peripheral clearing, air bronchograms, areas of superimposed interlobular septal thickening; abdominal ascites with mesenteric oedema and body wall anasarca | <35 | Unknown | Obesity; hypertension; conventional cigarette smoking | Not a case |
| Case 23 | 5 weeks | Pulmonary oedema and intra-alveolar haemorrhage | Extensive pigmented macrophages (haemosiderin-laden) | None noted | Not done | Myocardial fibrosis with myocyte injury | Not done | <35 | THC | Not reported | Not a case |
AFB=acid-fast bacilli. CBD=cannabidiol. CDC=Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. EVALI=e-cigarette, or vaping, product use-associated lung injury. GMS=Grocott methenamine silver stain. IHC=immunohistochemistry. PIV=parainfluenza virus. RSV=respiratory syncytial virus. THC=tetrahydrocannabinol.
Weeks from illness onset to autopsy are defined as 1 week meaning less than 7 days, 2 weeks meaning 7–13 days, etc.
Based on imaging findings reported to the CDC.
Includes reported history of one or more of the following: obesity, chronic pain, chronic respiratory disease, obstructive sleep apnoea, chronic kidney disease, immune suppression, chronic liver disease, diabetes, or hypertension; or autopsy findings consistent with chronic respiratory disease, chronic kidney disease, or cirrhosis. Nine (69%) of 13 individuals had a reported mental health diagnosis and six had a reported history of use or abuse of other substances, excluding marijuana; these data are not included at an individual level in this table.
The CDC 2019 lung injury primary or out-of-hospital death surveillance case definition (appendix p 3).2
Details to clarify cross-reactivity of the select Gram-negative IHC assay are in the appendix p 2.