Table 3.
Summary of studies on the use of diazepam for status epilepticus
Delivery route | Study design | N | Age (years) | SE types | Dosage (mg) | Seizure control (%) | TEAE rate (%) | Frequent TEAE (%) | References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Intravenous | |||||||||
DZP | SC | 15 | 16–73 | RS, SE | 5–40 | 82 | – | – | [114] |
DZP | RCT, MC | 21 | 0–2 | RS | – | 87 | – | Respiratory arrest | [111] |
DZP infusion | ReS, SC | 62 | 1–12 | RSE | 0.017 mg/kg/min | 86 | Hypotension, respiratory depression | [113] | |
DZP vs. i.v. VPA | RCT, SC | 20 | 0–12 | RSE | 10 | 85 | – | Respiratory depression | [117] |
DZP vs. i.v. VPA | PS | 66 | 41d | SE | 2 × 0.2b in 10 min | 56 | – | – | [116] |
DZPvs. i.v. LZP | RCT, DB, SC | 78 | – | S | 5 | 76 | – | Respiratory depression | [46] |
DZP vs. i.v. LZP | RCT, DB, MC | 140 | 3–18 | SE | 0.2b | 72 | – | Respiratory depression | [50] |
DZP vs. i.v. LZP | RCT, MC | 273 | 0–17 | SE | – | Not superior | – | Respiratory depression | [139] |
DZP vs. i.v. LZP vs. i.v. placebo | RCT, DB, SC | 205 | ≥ 18 | SE | 5 | Superior to placebo | – | Respiratory complications, circulatory complications | [22] |
DZP vs. i.v. LZP and rectal DZP vs. rectal LZP | RCT, SC | 53 | 3.3–6.6c | SE | 0.3–0.4b | 85 (i.v.) 37 (rectal) | 15 | Respiratory depression | [51] |
DZP + PHT vs. i.v. LZP vs. i.v. PH | RCT, DB, MC | 570 | 58.6c | SE | 0.15b | 56 | – | Hypoventilation, cardiac arrhythmia | [47] |
DZP + PHT vs. i.v. LZP | RCT, SC | 88 | 1–12 | SE | 0.2b (+ 18b PHT) | 100 | – | Respiratory depression | [121] |
DZP vs. i.v. MDZ | RCT, SC | 19 | 2–12 | RSE | 0.5a | 90 | – | Respiratory depression | [118] |
DZP vs. i.v. MDZ | RCT | 120 | Children | S | 0.3–0.5b | 100 | – | – | [119] |
DZP vs. i.v. MDZ vs. i.v. LZP | RCT, SC | 120 | 0–14 | S | 0.3b | 73 | – | Somnolence, sedation | [198] |
DZP + PHT vs. PB + PHT | RCT, SC | 36 | 43.8c | SE | 2/min | Inferior to PB | – | Respiratory failure | [122] |
DZP vs. i.n. MDZ | RCT, SB, SC | 35 | 0–15 | S | 0.2b | Superior to MDZ | – | – | [81] |
DZP vs. i.n. MDZ | RCT, SC | 60 | 0–15 | S | 0.3b | Inferior to MDZ | – | – | [127] |
DZP vs. i.n. MDZ | RCT, SC | 50 | 1–12 | S | 0.3b | 65 | – | – | [15] |
DZP vs. i.n. MDZ | RCT, SC | 125 | – | S | 0.3b | Inferior to MDZ | – | – | [130] |
DZP vs. i.m. MDZ | RCT, SC | 115 | 0–12 | S | 0.2b | – | 11 | Thrombophlebitis | [123] |
DZP vs. i.m. MDZ | RCT, SC | 32 | 0–14 | S | 0.5b | 88 | – | Vomiting, hyperactivity | [124] |
DZP vs. i.m. MDZ | RCT, SC | 11 | 0–10 | SE | 0.3b | 91 | 9 | Respiratory depression | [72] |
DZP vs. buccal MDZ | RCT, SC | 120 | 0–12 | S | 0.3b | 93.3 | – | – | [128] |
DZP vs. buccal MDZ | RCT, SC | 92 | 0–14 | S | 0.3b | 70 | 42 | Respiratory failure | [129] |
Intramuscular | |||||||||
DZP | RCT, DB, MC | 234 | ≥ 2 | RS | 5, 10, 15, 20a | Reduction of time to next seizure | 42 | Injection site pain (17), injection site hemorrhage (5) | [103] |
DZP | RCT, MC | 234 | 2–83 | RS | 5, 10, 15a | 78 | 75 | Injections site pain (11), injections site hemorrhage(6) | [104] |
DZP vs. i.m. rectal gel | SC, OLS | 24 | 18–55 | HV | 10 | i.m. superior to rectal | – | Pain, discomfort, drowsiness | [100] |
DZP vs. DZP rectal gel | RCT, DB, SC, CO | 48 | 18–40 | RS | 5, 10, 15a | – | 22 | Injection site discomfort | [101] |
Rectal (gel or solution) | |||||||||
DZP | ReS, SC | 50 | 34.7c | RS | 0.2b | 90 | Somnolence | [107] | |
DZP | SC | 39 | 16–65 | RS | 20, 30 | 29–72 | Drowsiness | [108] | |
DZP | SC | 17 | – | RS | 0.5b | 66 | Respiratory difficulties, dizziness | [115] | |
DZP | OLS | 149 | 2–76 | RS | 0.2–0.5b | 77 | – | Sedation | [109] |
DZP vs. placebo | RCT, DB, MC | 96 | ≥ 18 | RS | 0.2b | – | – | – | [105] |
DZP vs. placebo | RCT, DB | 125 | 2–60 | RS | 0.2–0.5b | Superior to placebo | – | – | [28] |
DZP (rectal or p.o.) vs. placebo | RCT, DB, SC | 40 | 18–60 | RS | 20 | Superior to placebo | – | – | [110] |
DZP vs. placebo | RCT, DB, MC | 158 | > 2 | RS | 0.2–0.5b | 55 | – | Somnolence | [29] |
DZP vs. placebo | PS, DB | 133 | 2–17 | RS | 5 | Superior to placebo | – | Somnolence | [112] |
DZP vs. i.m. MDZ | RCT, SC | 100 | 0–16 | SE | 0.5b | 94 | – | – | [74] |
DZP vs. buccal MDZ | RCT, MC | 110 | 0–15 | S | 2.5–10 | 45 | 6 | Respiratory depression | [12] |
DZP vs. buccal MDZ | RCT, SB, SC | 165 | 0–12 | S | 2.5–10 | 57 | – | Respiratory depression | [131] |
DZP vs. buccal MDZ | RCT, SC | 39 | 5–22 | S | 10 | 59 | – | – | [75] |
DZP vs. buccal MDZ | RCT, MC | 98 | 0–12 | S | 0.5b | 82 | – | – | [132] |
DZP vs. buccal MDZ | RCT, SC | 43 | 0–12 | S | 0.3–0.5b | 85 | – | – | [133] |
DZP vs. buccal MDZ | RCT, SC | 22 | 25–82 | S | 5 | 83 | – | Tiredness, ataxia | [77] |
DZP vs. buccal MDZ | RCT, SC | 34 | 0–18 | S | 0.5b | 100 | – | – | [136] |
DZP vs. sublingual LZP | RCT, MC | 436 | 0–10 | S | 0.5b | 79 | – | – | [137] |
DZP vs. i.n. MDZ | RCT, SC | 45 | 0–13 | S | 0.3b | 60 | – | – | [134] |
DZP vs. i.n. MDZ | RCT, SC | 46 | 0–12 | S | 0.3b | 89 | – | Vomiting, drowsiness, hypoxia | [135] |
DZP vs. i.n. MDZ | PS, SC | 21 | 25–69 | S | 10 | 89 | – | Drowsiness | [83] |
DZP vs. i.n. MDZ | RCT, SB, MC | 358 | 3–11 | S | 0.3–0.5b | Not superior | – | Respiratory failure (1) | [14] |
DZP vs. i.n. MDZ | RCT, MC | 358 | – | RS | 0.3–0.5b | – | – | – | [138] |
Intranasal | |||||||||
DZP | Pilot study | 24 | 18–45 | HV | 10 | – | – | – | [96] |
DZP | Pilot study | 8 | 28.3c | HV | 5, 10 | – | – | – | [98] |
DZP | MC | 78 | 18–65 | S | 0.2b | – | Nasopharyngeal signs | [92] | |
DZP vs. i.v. MZD | Pilot study | 4 | 20–24 | HV | 5 | – | – | – | [99] |
DZP vs. rectal gel DZP | OLS, CO | 24 | 18–50 | RS | 5, 20 a | – | 32–48 | Nasal redness, nasal discomfort | [102] |
DZP vs. i.v. DZP | Pilot study | 9 | 20–30 | HV | 20 (i.n.) 2 (i.v.) | – | – | – | [97] |
RCT randomized controlled trial, OLS open-label study, SC single-centre, MC multicentre, DB double-blind, PS prospective study, ReS retrospective study, CO cross-over, HV healthy volunteer, S seizure, RS repetitive seizure, SE status epilepticus, RSE refractory status epilepticus, TEAE treatment-emergent adverse event, i.v. intravenous, i.n. intranasal, i.m. intramuscular, p.o. oral, MDZ midazolam, LZP lorazepam, DZP diazepam, VPA valproate, PHT phenytoin, PB phenobarbital
a Absolute
b Milligram per kilogram body weight (mg/kg BW)
c Average