Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Sep 1.
Published in final edited form as: IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 2022 Aug 19;69(9):2982–2993. doi: 10.1109/TBME.2022.3158582

TABLE V:

Performance of the quality assessment methods for Clinical/AF-Trial independent subjects’ test set

Method PPG Type No. of Segments TP TN FP FN Sens Spec PPV NPV G_mean Acc F_meas
Our approach Total 4874 2547 2022 53 252 91.00 97.45 97.96 88.92 94.17 93.74 94.35
AF 1674 864 707 36 67 92.80 95.15 96.00 91.34 93.97 93.85 94.37
Non-AF 3180 1683 1295 17 185 90.10 98.70 99.00 87.50 94.30 93.65 94.34

Method II Total 4874 2738 742 1333 61 97.82 35.76 67.26 92.40 59.14 71.40 79.71
AF 1674 931 33 710 0 100.00 4.44 56.73 100.00 21.07 57.59 72.40
Non-AF 3180 1807 701 611 61 96.73 53.43 74.73 91.99 71.89 78.87 84.32

Method I Total 4874 2707 955 1120 92 96.71 46.02 70.73 91.21 66.72 75.13 81.71
AF 1674 918 308 435 13 98.60 41.45 67.85 95.95 63.93 73.24 80.39
Non-AF 3180 1789 646 666 79 95.77 49.24 72.87 89.10 68.67 76.57 82.77