Table 6.
Summary of the four frames used in Italian print media reporting on MHL policy responses. Source: Table adapted from Morris et al. (2016) with authors' inputs.
| Frame: | Food security | Worker exploitation | Immigration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Problem diagnosis | Lack of labour supply poses a risk to Italian domestic food supply. | Covid-19 amplifies pre-existing labour exploitation and risks worsening the suffering of workers. | Covid-19's impact on migrant labour opens up the longstanding political battle over immigration in Italy. |
| Motivation/impetus for action | Saving the agricultural sector from the risks that labour shortages and unharvested crops pose to farmers' livelihoods. | End worker suffering and the associated illegal caporalato practices. | Motivation varies depending on position on legalisation, different sides use different motivations to justify their stance. |
| Proposed solution | Green corridors and employment measures to hire Italian workers | Legalisation of undocumented migrant workers | Depends on legalisation stance |
| Key actors quoted in articles | Farmer bodies & farmers | Unions, regional politicians & workers | National & regional politicians, industry |
| Outlets associated with frame | Corriere della Sera, La Stampa, La Repubblica | La Stampa, Avvenire and La Repubblica | All |
| Percentage use across sample | 30% | 32% | 38% |