Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 19;95:278–293. doi: 10.1016/j.jrurstud.2022.09.007

Table 6.

Summary of the four frames used in Italian print media reporting on MHL policy responses. Source: Table adapted from Morris et al. (2016) with authors' inputs.

Frame: Food security Worker exploitation Immigration
Problem diagnosis Lack of labour supply poses a risk to Italian domestic food supply. Covid-19 amplifies pre-existing labour exploitation and risks worsening the suffering of workers. Covid-19's impact on migrant labour opens up the longstanding political battle over immigration in Italy.
Motivation/impetus for action Saving the agricultural sector from the risks that labour shortages and unharvested crops pose to farmers' livelihoods. End worker suffering and the associated illegal caporalato practices. Motivation varies depending on position on legalisation, different sides use different motivations to justify their stance.
Proposed solution Green corridors and employment measures to hire Italian workers Legalisation of undocumented migrant workers Depends on legalisation stance
Key actors quoted in articles Farmer bodies & farmers Unions, regional politicians & workers National & regional politicians, industry
Outlets associated with frame Corriere della Sera, La Stampa, La Repubblica La Stampa, Avvenire and La Repubblica All
Percentage use across sample 30% 32% 38%