Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 20;30(5):13048–13066. doi: 10.1007/s11356-022-23044-2

Table 6.

Panel ARDL estimation results (1,1,1,1,1)

Variables PMG MG DFE
Coefficients z-statistic Coefficients z-statistic Coefficients z-statistic
Long-run results
lnEPU −0.0792331 −5.20*** −0.0641288 −2.93*** −0.0754501 −2.13**
lnW 0.4531534 5.96*** 0.631202 2.30** 0.5379684 6.18***
lnTO −0.5215974 −8.04*** −0.4741248 −3.04*** −0.3304449 −3.21***
lnNR 0.0982784 8.88*** 0.093378 2.80*** 0.0259528 1.05
lnLE −4.42931 −6.31*** −2.682202 −0.91 −2.785417 −2.86***
Short-run results
ECT(-1) −0.3744295 −4.87*** −0.8947111 −9.16*** −0.3941237 −8.84***
 Δ(lnEPU) 0.0181691 1.21 0.0616388 2.20** 0.0173634 1.09
Δ(lnW) 0.5103846 3.23*** 0.1286102 0.42 0.2648649 2.41**
Δ(lnTO) 0.137651 1.31 0.2283546 1.68* −0.0579973 −0.84
Δ(lnNR) −0.0077148 −0.74 −0.0331151 −1.80* 0.016159 1.37
Δ(lnLE) −6.361601 −1.19 −5.222865 −0.49 −0.2006225 −0.14
C 13.4671 1.38 3.973503 2.66***
Hausman test
PMG vs. MG PMG vs. DFE MG vs. DFE
p-value 0.8966 p-value 1.0000 p-value 1.0000

*, **, and *** denote statistically significant at the 10%, 5%, and 1% levels, respectively. Source: Current Research