Table 4.
First author and year | Country | Data source (and target population) | Sample size | Outcome measure | Main findings | aNOS score (max 7) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | (Altın et al., 2020) | Turkey | Web-based survey among gynecologic oncologists affiliated to the Turkish Society of Gynecologic Oncology | 70 | Number of standard surgeries, delay, referral to other hospitals, radiotherapy. Stratification for cancer stage | Overall, 97.1% of surveyees responded that cancer management changed during the pandemic (for all gynecological cancers). 58% of surgeons continued to operate microinvasive cervical cancer, while 33.3% delayed surgery. Standard surgery (67.1%) and delay (20%) were the two leading responses for early-stage cervical cancer. Primary RT or chemo-RT was applied without delay to most of the locally advanced cervical cancer patients, but hypo-fractional dose (57.1%) was preferred to standard dose (27.1%), in order to reduce the number of hospital visits. 67.1% of surgeons continued to perform surgery or administered CT/RT to metastatic or recurrent cervical cancer patients. | 4 |
2 | (Desta et al., 2021) | Ethiopia | Population-level healthcare administrative data | NR | Number of women with cervical lesions who received treatment | During the second quarter of 2020, there was a decrease in number of women aged 30–49 years with cervical lesion and received treatment (−85.0%; 20 vs. 3), compared to the same period of 2019. | 6 |
3 | (Hathout et al., 2021) | United States | Medical records from four cancer centers | 15 | Days of treatment delays | All patients with cervical cancer received their treatments as planned; however, four of 15 patients (26.7%) had a treatment interruption during their course. Two patients experienced significant delays (>20 days) owing to COVID-19 infection and the other two patients had treatment interruptions due to non-COVID medical problems. | 4 |
4 | (Istrate-Ofițeru et al., 2021) | Romania | Medical records from Obstetrics and Gynecology Clinics patients with pathological Pap smears | 396 | Number of patients with high-grade dysplasia treated and type of surgical intervention performed | Of the total patients who had been diagnosed with high-grade dysplasia, 21.4% were treated surgically in the pandemic year (15.03.2020–14-03.2021) and 78.6% in non-pandemic period (15.03.2019–14-03.2020). Before COVID-19, excisional biopsies were performed in 31.3% and LEETZ in 47.3% of the total surgical procedures. During the pandemic, excisional biopsy was performed in 6.2% and LEETZ in 15.2% of the total procedures. | 5 |
5 | (Ivanuš et al., 2021) | Slovenia | Population-based cervical cancer screening registry (from the National Cervical Cancer Screening Registry – ZORA registry), including women aged 20–64 years | NA | Number of women who underwent invasive procedures 120 days after high-grade screening diagnosis. | Compared to the average of a three-year period (2017–2019), a significantly higher deficit in cold-knife conizations (−91, −39%) compared to LLETZ (−4, −1%) was observed. | 7 |
6 | (Koczkodaj et al., 2021) | 2021 | Population-level data from the National Health Fund | Number of issued oncology diagnosis and treatment cards (ODaTCs) from January to September in the years 2019 and 2020 | Absolute number of issued ODaTCs: 651 (2019) vs. 705 (2020). | 5 | |
7 | (Medenwald et al., 2022) | Germany | Patient-level claims data from fourteen university hospitals | 9365 inpatient hospital admissions | Number of radiotherapy fractions (primary outcome) and inpatient hospital admissions (secondary outcome) |
The lockdown period (from March 16 to April 28, 2020), radiotherapeutic fractions decreased by 20.0% (1232 to 1539.5, p-value <0.001) in the study cohort compared to the control cohort (2018 and 2019). Megavoltage radiation therapy decreased by 29.5% (660 to 936.5, p-value <0.001), whereas no change was observed for brachytherapy-related fractions (164 to 163, p-value ≥0.05). Within the return-to-normal period (from May 4 to August 2, 2020), the reduction in overall radiotherapeutic fractions was 28.6% (829 to 1160.5, p-value <0.001), whereas megavoltage radiation therapy fractions decreased by 43.7% (411 to 730.5, p-value <0.001) and brachytherapy fractions even increased by 15.0% (123 to 107, p-value ≥0.05;) in 2020 in comparison with the control cohort. Within the lockdown period, overall hospital admissions for cervical cancer fell by 10.2% (352 to 392, p-value >0.05;) in the study cohort compared to the control cohort, whereas a reduction of 22.1% (218 to 280, p-value <0.01) was observed in the return-to-normal period. Radiotherapy admissions without brachytherapy were reduced by 23.9% (167 to 219.5, p-value <0.05), whereas admissions with chemotherapy procedures were reduced by 12.5% (126 to 144, p-value ≥ 0.05), and brachytherapy-related admissions were reduced by 5.0% (85 to 89.5, p-value ≥ 0.05) within the lockdown period in 2020 compared with the control cohort. In contrast, admissions with surgery-related procedures increased non-significantly by 20.5% (100 to 83, p-value ≥ 0.05) in the same period. For the return-to-normal period, radiotherapy admissions without brachytherapy decreased by 44.9% (92 to 167, p-value <0.001;), which was also true for admission with radio- and chemotherapy (37.1%; 66 to 105, p-value <0.01;). In contrast, radiotherapeutic admissions with brachytherapy increased by 14.8% (70 to 61;) and admissions with surgical procedures increased by 7.7% (56 to 52, p-value ≥0.05) in the same period compared with the control cohort. | 6 |
8 | (Meggetto et al., 2021) | Canada | Multiple population-based administrative databases | NR | Monthly cervical treatment volumes | The average monthly decrease in cervical treatment volumes was 31.1% or 288 cervical treatments, compared with the same months in 2019. | 7 |
Abbreviations: aNOS, adapted version of the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale checklist for assessing the quality of non-randomized studies; NR, not reported; NA, not applicable; 95% CI 95% confidence interval; CT, chemotherapy; RT, radiotherapy; LEETZ, Large Loop Excision of the Transformation Zone.