Table 1. Summary of the major trials of disease-targeted therapy in congenital heart disease (CHD)-associated pulmonary arterial hypertension.
First author [Ref.] | Year | Drug | Study design | Patients n | Patients with CHD % | NYHA class | Mean age yrs | Outcome# | Change in 6MWT m | Follow-up period |
Christensen [28] | 2004 | Bosentan | Retrospective | 9 | 100 | III/IV | 47 | NA | Not reported | 9.5 months |
Schulze-Neick [29] | 2005 | Bosentan | Open label, prospective | 33 | 100 | II-IV | 43 | Functional class 6MWT Haemodynamics | 77 | 2.1 yrs |
Gatzoulis [30] | 2005 | Bosentan | Open label, prospective | 10¶ | 100 | III | 42 | O2 saturation 6MWT | 99 | 3 months |
Galie [27] | 2006 | Bosentan | Randomised, double-blind, placebo controlled | 54 | 100 | III | 37 (treatment arm) | PVR | 43 | 16 weeks |
Kotlyar [31] | 2006 | Bosentan | Retrospective | 23¶ | 100 | II-IV | 37 | NA | 0 | 15 months |
Benza [32] | 2006 | Bosentan | Retrospective | 24 | 100 | II-IV | 50 | NA | 31 | 1 yr |
Sitbon [33] | 2006 | Bosentan | Retrospective | 27 | 100 | III/IV | 35 | NA | 66 | 15 months |
D'Alto [34] | 2007 | Bosentan | Open label, prospective | 22 | 100 | II-IV | 38 | Functional class Haemodynamics 6MWT O2 saturation | 67 | 1 yr |
Apostolopoulou [35] | 2007 | Bosentan | Open label, prospective | 18 | 100 | II-IV | 22 | O2 saturation 6MWT Functional class Peak exercise capacity | 0 | 2 yrs |
Diller [36] | 2007 | Bosentan | Retrospective | 18 | 100 | III | 41 | NA | 124 | 29 months |
Van Loon [37] | 2007 | Bosentan | Retrospective | 20 | 100 | II-IV | 39 | NA | 0 | 2.1 yrs (median) |
Gatzoulis [38] | 2008 | Bosentan | Open label extension of BREATHE-5 | 37¶ | 100% | III | 40 | 6MWT Functional class | 61 | 40 weeks |
Barst [39] | 2004 | Sitaxsentan 100 mg and 300 mg | Randomised, double-blind, placebo controlled | 178 | 24 | II-III | 46 | Peak V′O2 | 35 (100 mg) 33 (300 mg) | 12 weeks |
Barst [40] | 2006 | Sitaxsentan 50 mg and 100 mg | Randomised, double-blind, placebo controlled | 245 | 11 | II-IV | 54 | 6MWT | 24 (50 mg) 31 (100 mg) | 18 weeks |
Singh [41] | 2006 | Sildenafil 300 mg | Randomised, double-blind crossover, placebo controlled | 10¶ | 100 | II-IV | Median 15 (4–35) | 6MWT | 97 | 12 weeks |
Chau [42] | 2007 | Sildenafil 150 mg | Prospective open label | 7¶ | 100 | Mean 3.3 | 37 | Functional class O2 saturation Haemodynamics 6MWT | NS 28† | 6 months |
Garg [43] | 2007 | Sildenafil 300 mg | Prospective, open label | 44 | 48 | II/III | 26 | Functional class O2 saturation Haemodynamics 6MWT | 119 | 19 months |
Tay [44] | 2010 | Sildenafil 60 mg·day−1 | Prospective open label | 12 | 100 | III | 34 | Quality of life O2 saturation 6MWT | 45 | 3 months |
Mukhopadhyay [45] | 2006 | Tadalafil | Observational, prospective | 16¶ | 100 | II/III | 25 | Functional class O2 saturation Haemodynamics 6MWT | 43 | 12 weeks |
Galie [46] | 2009 | Tadalafil | Randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled | 405 | 12 | II-IV | 53 | 6MWT | 33 | 16 weeks |
Rosenzweig [47] | 1999 | Epoprostenol i.v. | Retrospective | 20 | 100 | II-IV | 15 | NA | 52 | 1 yr |
Fernandes [48] | 2003 | Epoprostenol i.v. | Retrospective | 8 | 100 | III/IV | Median 37 (15–57) | NA | 299 | 3 months |
Simonneau [49] | 2002 | Treprostinil s.c. max dose 22.5 ng·kg−1·min−1 | Randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled | 470 | 23 | II-IV | 44 | 6MWT | 16 | 12 weeks |
Tapson [50] | 2006 | Treprostinil i.v. mean dose 41 ng·kg−1·min−1 | Prospective, open label | 16 | 13 | III/IV | 45 | 6MWT Functional class Haemodynamics | 82 | 12 weeks |
Lang [51] | 2006 | Treprostinil s.c. mean dose 40 ng·kg−1·min−1 | Retrospective | 99 | 23 | II-IV | 47 | NA | 139 | 26 months |
Drugs were administered orally unless otherwise stated. If trials differed in drug doses, these are specified. Studies that were not entirely comprised of patients with CHD are those by Barst [39, 40], Garg [43], Galie [46], Simonneau [49], Tapson [50] and Lang [52]. BREATHE-5: Bosentan Randomised trial of Endothelin Antagonist THErapy-5; NYHA: New York Heart Association; NA: not applicable; 6MWT: 6-min walk test; PVR: pulmonary vascular resistance; V′O2: oxygen uptake; NS: not statistically significant. #: primary outcome only in randomised controlled trials; ¶: all Eisenmenger; †: actual class not specified.