TABLE 1.
Studies | Anaesthesia | Principle | Indication | Advantages | Drawbacks |
Mechanical debulking | General | Resection with the rigid tubes and forceps | Proximal, slightly haemorrhagic, and intraluminal lesions | Rapidity Cost |
Severe complications in 20% (bleeding, perforation) |
Laser | General anaesthesia and rigid bronchoscopy highly recommended, except for limited degree of stenosis with short procedure time | Short pulsations in the bronchial axis at 30–50 W Flexible or rigid bronchoscope |
Intraluminal or mixed critical proximal obstructions | Immediate and prolonged debulking Few complications if trained operator |
Cost Risk of perforation and bronchovascular fistula |
Thermo-coagulation/argon plasma coagulation (APC) | General anaesthesia and rigid bronchoscopy highly recommended, except for limited degree of stenosis with short procedure time | High-frequency electric current ± argon as a carrier gas (APC) | Intraluminal or mixed proximal obstructions | Immediate efficacy Cost Low risk of perforation APC: treatment of extended and haemorrhagic lesions |
Risk of scarring stenosis if circumferential treatment |
Cryotherapy | General anaesthesia and rigid bronchoscopy highly recommended, except for limited degree of stenosis with short procedure time | Expansion of a cryogenic gas Cycles of rapid freezing and slow thawing |
Non-critical exophytic malignant obstructions | Low cost Easy procedure No perforation Prolonged efficacy Synergistic action with chemotherapy |
Delayed effect (except cryoextraction and spray cryotherapy) Need for a second cleaning bronchoscopy |
Photodynamic therapy | General anaesthesia and rigid bronchoscopy highly recommended, except for limited degree of stenosis with short procedure time | Activation of a photosensitiser by light | Non-critical exophytic malignant obstructions | Good symptom control (haemoptysis) Prolonged efficacy |
Delayed effect Retention of tumour material Cleaning bronchoscopy Phototoxicity Constraining technique Haemorrhagic complications |
Silicone stent | General | Placed using a prosthesis pusher inserted in the rigid tube | Extrinsic or mixed compressions | Good tolerance Few local granulomatous and ischaemic reactions Easily removable |
Altered ciliary clearance Risk of migration (rare, except in cases of purely extrinsic compression) |
Metallic stent | General anaesthesia and rigid bronchoscopy highly recommended | Self-expandable Placed using a guide wire under radiographic or bronchoscopic control Flexible or rigid bronchoscopy |
Second line; not to be considered as a first choice, except in cases of highly necrotic lesions or large distortion | Easy placement Possible with flexible bronchoscope (but should be avoided if rigid tube is unavailable) Preserved clearance |
Frequent complications (granuloma, perforation, rupture) Hardly removable |