Skip to main content
. 2015 Sep;24(137):378–391. doi: 10.1183/16000617.00010014

TABLE 1.

Summary of interventional bronchoscopy techniques available for the management of malignant central airway obstruction

Studies Anaesthesia Principle Indication Advantages Drawbacks
Mechanical debulking General Resection with the rigid tubes and forceps Proximal, slightly haemorrhagic, and intraluminal lesions Rapidity
Cost
Severe complications in 20% (bleeding, perforation)
Laser General anaesthesia and rigid bronchoscopy highly recommended, except for limited degree of stenosis with short procedure time Short pulsations in the bronchial axis at 30–50 W
Flexible or rigid bronchoscope
Intraluminal or mixed critical proximal obstructions Immediate and prolonged debulking
Few complications if trained operator
Cost
Risk of perforation and bronchovascular fistula
Thermo-coagulation/argon plasma coagulation (APC) General anaesthesia and rigid bronchoscopy highly recommended, except for limited degree of stenosis with short procedure time High-frequency electric current ± argon as a carrier gas (APC) Intraluminal or mixed proximal obstructions Immediate efficacy
Cost
Low risk of perforation
APC: treatment of extended and haemorrhagic lesions
Risk of scarring stenosis if circumferential treatment
Cryotherapy General anaesthesia and rigid bronchoscopy highly recommended, except for limited degree of stenosis with short procedure time Expansion of a cryogenic gas
Cycles of rapid freezing and slow thawing
Non-critical exophytic malignant obstructions Low cost
Easy procedure
No perforation
Prolonged efficacy
Synergistic action with chemotherapy
Delayed effect (except cryoextraction and spray cryotherapy)
Need for a second cleaning bronchoscopy
Photodynamic therapy General anaesthesia and rigid bronchoscopy highly recommended, except for limited degree of stenosis with short procedure time Activation of a photosensitiser by light Non-critical exophytic malignant obstructions Good symptom control (haemoptysis)
Prolonged efficacy
Delayed effect
Retention of tumour material
Cleaning bronchoscopy
Phototoxicity
Constraining technique
Haemorrhagic complications
Silicone stent General Placed using a prosthesis pusher inserted in the rigid tube Extrinsic or mixed compressions Good tolerance
Few local granulomatous and ischaemic reactions
Easily removable
Altered ciliary clearance
Risk of migration (rare, except in cases of purely extrinsic compression)
Metallic stent General anaesthesia and rigid bronchoscopy highly recommended Self-expandable
Placed using a guide wire under radiographic or bronchoscopic control
Flexible or rigid bronchoscopy
Second line; not to be considered as a first choice, except in cases of highly necrotic lesions or large distortion Easy placement
Possible with flexible bronchoscope (but should be avoided if rigid tube is unavailable)
Preserved clearance
Frequent complications (granuloma, perforation, rupture)
Hardly removable