Skip to main content
. 2017 Feb 1;26(143):160092. doi: 10.1183/16000617.0092-2016

TABLE 4.

Risk of bias summary: author's judgement for each risk of bias domain and included study

First author [ref.] Sequence generation Allocation concealment Blinding of participants and personnel Blinding of outcome assessment Incomplete outcome data Selective reporting Other bias
Abidi [11] + ? + + +
Castro [33] + ? + ? + + +
Emelyanov [12] + ? + ? + + +
Fogarty [24] + ? + ? + + +
Govindan [13] ? ? ? + +
Gvozdjakova [14] ? ? ? ? +
Hasselmark [15] + ? + ? + +
Hill [25] + ? + ? + +
Honma [16] ? ? + ? + +
Kaslow [17] ? ? + ? + + +
Kelly-Pieper [29] ? ? + ?
Khayyal [18] ? ? ? ? + + +
Martineau [31] + ? + ? + + +
Moreira [27] + + + ? + +
Nadi [26] ? ? + ? ? + +
Nanzer [32] + + + + + + +
Okamoto [28] ? ? ? ? ? +
Pearson [19] + ? + + + + +
Thomas [20] ? ? + ? + +
Thoren [21] ? ? + ? + + +
Urata [22] ? ? + ? + +
Wen [30] ? ? + ? + +
Zhang [23] + ? ? ? + +

+: low risk; ?: unclear risk; −: high risk.