TABLE 2.
Summary of the studies included in systematic review and meta-analysis
First author [ref.] | Country/region | Study period | Study design | Radon detection technique | Sex | Population source | Outcome: LC diagnosis/death | Never-smokers | Ever-smokers | ||
Cases | Controls | Cases | Controls | ||||||||
Darby[48]#¶
Darby[51]#¶ |
Europe | 1960–99 | Pooled study | M/F | General+hospital | Diagnosis | 884 | 5418 | 6040 | 8252 | |
Oberaigner[25] | Austria | 1970–92 | C-C | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 22 | 41 | 159 | 127 | |
Tomasek[26] | Czechia | 1960–99 | Cohort | Kodak LR115 | M/F | General | Death | 28 | 295 | 143 | 417 |
Auvinen [27] | Finland | 1986–92 | C-C | Alpha track | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 44 | 229 | 772 | 752 |
Ruosteenoja[28] | Finland | 1979–85 | C-C | Radon dosimeter | M | General | Diagnosis | 3 | 33 | 155 | 291 |
Baysson[29] | France | 1990–99 | C-C | Kodalpha LR115 | M/F | Hospital | Diagnosis | 44 | 344 | 521 | 797 |
Kreuzer[30] | Germany: eastern | 1991–97 | C-C | Alpha track | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 96 | 544 | 850 | 994 |
Kreienbrock[31] | Germany: western | 1990–95 | C-C | Solid-state nuclear track | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 89 | 653 | 1225 | 1433 |
Bochicchio[32] | Italy | 1993–96 | C-C | Radon dosimeter | M/F | Hospital | Diagnosis | 28 | 102 | 355 | 291 |
Barros-Dios [33] | Spain | 1992–94 | C-C | Alpha track | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 12 | 94 | 144 | 133 |
Pershagen[34] | Sweden | 1980–84 | C-C | Solid-state alpha track | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 175 | 1156 | 682 | 761 |
Lagarde[35] | Sweden | 1978–95 | C-C | Radon dosimeter | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 258 | 487 | ||
Pershagen[44] | Sweden: Stockholm | 1983–87 | C-C | Alpha track | F | General+hospital | Diagnosis | 36 | 181 | 160 | 194 |
Darby[36] | England | 1988–95 | C-C | Small passive radon | M/F | General+hospital | Diagnosis | 26 | 896 | 874 | 2062 |
Krewski[49]#¶
Krewski[50]#¶ |
North America | 1982–97 | Pooled study | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 659 | 2185 | 2930 | 2681 | |
Schoenberg[37] | USA: New Jersey | 1982–84 | C-C | Alpha track | F | General | Diagnosis | 61 | 213 | 372 | 189 |
Letourneau[38] | Canada: Winnipeg | 1983–90 | C-C | CR-39 alpha track | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 24 | 224 | 509 | 498 |
Alavanja[39] | USA: Missouri | 1986–92 | C-C | Alpha track | F | General | Diagnosis | 377 | 983 | 161 | 200 |
Alavanja[45] | USA: Missouri | 1993–94 | C-C | CR-39 alpha-particle | F | General | Diagnosis | 31 | 62 | 471 | 480 |
Field[40] | USA: Iowa | 1993–97 | C-C | Alpha track | F | General | Diagnosis | 56 | 414 | 357 | 200 |
Sandler[65] | USA: Connecticut | 1989–92 | C-C | Alpha track etch | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 54 | 78 | 718 | 735 |
Sandler[65] | USA: Utah | 1989–92 | C-C | Alpha track etch | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 56 | 211 | 342 | 379 |
Lubin[46]#¶
Lubin[47]#¶ |
China | 1985–98 | Pooled study | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 322+ | 708+ | 706 | 1266 | |
Blot[42] | China: Shenyang | 1985–87 | C-C | Radon dosimeter | F | General | Diagnosis | 113 | 213 | 162 | 120 |
Wang[43] | China: Gansu | 1994–98 | C-C | Alpha track | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 209 | 495 | 544 | 1146 |
Lorenzo-Gonzalez [52]#§ | Spain: northwest | 2003–13 | Pooled study | Alpha track | M/F | Hospital | Diagnosis | 476+ | 656+ | 261f | 264f |
Barros-Dios [66]¶ | Spain: Galicia | 2004–08 | C-C | Alpha track | M/F | Hospital | Diagnosis | 47 | 220 | 261 | 264 |
Torres-Duran [64]## | Spain: Galicia | 2011–13 | C-C | Alpha track | M/F | Hospital | Diagnosis | 192 | 329 | ||
Wilcox[68]¶¶ | USA: New Jersey | 1989–92 | C-C | Alpha track | M/F | General | Diagnosis | 40 | 116 | 521 | 513 |
Turner[67]¶¶ | USA | 1982–88 | Cohort | Mean county-level of radon | M/F | General | Death | 271 | 375 087 | 2733 | 355 286 |
Data are presented as n. LC: lung cancer; C-C: case–control study; M: male; F: female. #: these studies are included in the meta-analysis for never-smokers; ¶: these studies are included in the meta-analysis for ever-smokers; +: unpublished data provided by original investigators; §: this study has been revised by its lead investigator to exclude the results of Barros-Dios [33] which was included in the Darby [48] pooled study; ƒ: data for ever-smokers extracted from Barros-Dios [66] which was not analysed in the pooled study; ##: this study has been updated from July 2013 by its lead investigator to include more cases and controls in the Lorenzo-Gonzalez [52] pooling study; ¶¶: these studies are not included in the meta-analysis due to different measures of effect (cohort study) or standard errors or confidence intervals (case–control study) not reported for their risk estimates.