Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 29;24(5):549–557. doi: 10.4103/aja202252

Supplementary Table 3.

The data of the included studies in semen parameters

Study Treat Control


Size Mean s.d. Size Mean s.d.
Sperm concentration (millions ml−1)
 Gaskins et al.32 2012 47 51.20 68.63 47 44.30 58.92
 Cutillas-Tolín et al.17 2015 52 44.20 46.51 53 35.70 36.46
 Karayiannis et al.33 2017 66 37.90 26.43 76 30.50 27.14
 Salas-Huetos et al.35 2019 27 25.63 15.26 30 30.13 34.72
 Ricci et al.34 2019 35 37.67 36.15 31 34.30 44.56
 Danielewicz et al.31 2019 70 41.13 51.09 62 24.10 24.21
Total sperm count (millions)
 Cutillas-Tolín et al.17 2015 52 138.00 134.7 53 91.90 84.71
 Karayiannis et al.33 2017 66 82.10 70.75 76 63.80 72.67
 Salas-Huetos et al.35 2019 27 74.50 45.00 30 82.30 84.61
 Ricci et al.34 2019 35 85.77 75.62 31 81.43 107.29
 Danielewicz et al.31 2019 70 154.27 188.78 62 90.53 102.02
Normal sperm morphology (%)
 Gaskins et al.32 2012 47 7.80 6.30 47 8.70 6.30
 Cutillas-Tolín et al.17 2015 52 8.17 5.57 53 9.25 6.15
 Karayiannis et al.33 2017 66 4.60 2.44 76 4.30 2.63
 Salas-Huetos et al.35 2019 27 6.43 2.35 30 6.27 2.80
 Danielewicz et al.31 2019 70 8.33 6.81 62 6.33 3.79
Total sperm motility (%)
 Cutillas-Tolín et al.17 2015 52 56.10 11.31 53 56.20 10.70
 Karayiannis et al.33 2017 66 42.60 20.33 76 32.10 20.57
 Salas-Huetos et al.35 2019 27 73.37 13.70 30 55.23 26.15
 Danielewicz et al.31 2019 70 53.90 20.59 62 50.90 17.30
Progressive sperm motility (%)
 Gaskins et al.32 2012 47 63.70 20.26 47 57.10 19.58
 Karayiannis et al.33 2017 66 26.00 16.26 76 20.00 16.63
 Salas-Huetos et al.35 2019 27 52.60 14.87 30 40.17 20.50
 Danielewicz et al.31 2019 70 33.80 17.49 62 30.80 14.88
Semen volume (ml)
 Cutillas-Tolín et al.17 2015 52 2.97 1.99 53 2.50 1.61
 Karayiannis et al.33 2017 66 2.10 0.81 76 2.00 1.31
 Salas-Huetos et al.35 2019 27 3.27 1.80 30 3.07 2.02
 Ricci et al.34 2019 35 2.73 1.88 31 2.77 1.58
 Danielewicz et al.31 2019 70 3.77 1.89 62 4.17 1.59

s.d.: standard deviation