Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 22;28(1):369–390. doi: 10.1038/s41380-022-01770-w

Table 2.

Efficacy of interventions to improve physical health in subjects with mood disorders, compared to Placebo/TAU/Wait list/No treatment.

Age group Population Intervention Control ES type ES (95% CI) p-value k n R C Q
Cardiovascular and respiratory outcomes
CHD readmission
Adults CHD, Depression SSRI Placebo/no intervention RR 0.63 (0.460.86) 0.003 5 2461 1 4 M
Diastolic blood pressure
Youth, Adults Depression SSRI Placebo SMD −0.11 (−0.17 to −0.05) <0.0001 17 4662 1 7 H
Fluoxetine Placebo SMD −0.11 (−0.20 to −0.01) 0.04 6 1594 1 6 M
Paroxetine Placebo SMD −0.10 (−0.20 to 0.001) 0.053 6 1547 1 7 H
Escitalopram Placebo SMD −0.13 (−0.30 to 0.03) 0.11 2 628 1 5 M
Sertraline Placebo SMD −0.10 (−0.26 to 0.06) 0.21 2 609 1 6 M
Exercise tolerance
Elderly COPD, Depression SSRI Placebo SMD 1.27 (−0.87 to 3.41) 0.25 2 148 0 4 M
FEV1
Elderly COPD, Depression SSRI Placebo SMD 0.08 (−0.25 to 0.04) 0.65 2 148 0 4 M
Hypertension
Adults Depression Levomilnacipran Placebo NNH 75 (44274) <0.05 5 2623 0 5 L
Major adverse cardiac event + physical functioning
Adults ACS, Depression Collaborative care TAU OR 0.76 (0.600.98) 0.032 5 866 2 2 L
Orthostatic hypotension
Youth Depression SSRI Placebo RRa 0.91 (0.05–14.5) >0.05 na 2097 1 2 L
Adults Depression Levomilnacipran Placebo NNH 53 (na) >0.05 5 2623 0 5 L
Palpitations
Adults, Elderly Depression Imipramine Placebo OR 3.04 (1.565.94) <0.05 2 422 0 3 L
Respiratory disorder
Youth Depression SSRI Placebo RR 0.86 (0.48–1.57) >0.05 na 2097 1 2 L
Tricyclic antidepressants Placebo RR 0.58 (0.23–1.45) >0.05 na 2097 1 2 L
Systolic blood pressure
Youth, Adults Depression Paroxetine Placebo SMD −0.11 (−0.21 to −0.01) 0.03 6 1547 1 7 M
SSRI Placebo SMD −0.09 (−0.15 to −0.03) 0.003 17 4662 1 8 H
Sertraline Placebo SMD −0.12 (−0.29 to 0.05) 0.17 2 609 1 5 M
Fluoxetine Placebo SMD −0.09 (−0.19 to 0.01) 0.08 6 1594 1 7 M
Escitalopram Placebo SMD −0.01 (−0.17 to 0.15) 0.92 2 628 1 6 M
Tachycardia
Adults Depression Amitriptyline Placebo OR 3.88 (1.71 to 8.80) 0.001 5 384 1 2 L
Levomilnacipran Placebo NNH 25 (19 to 40) < 0.05 5 2623 0 5 L
VO2 max or peak
Adults Depression Physical exercise No exercise g −0.64 (−0.96 to −0.32) <0.001 8 498 2 2 L
Metabolic outcomes
BMI
Youth, Adults Bipolar disorder Aripiprazole Placebo g 0.17 (−0.02 to 0.36) 0.07 2 438 2 1 L
Cortisol
Adults Depression Physical exercise No exercise SMD 0.65 (−0.01 to 1.30) >0.05 5 209 1 0 L
Fasting glucose
Youth Bipolar disorder (depression) Lurasidone Placebo MDa 2.10 (−0.52 to 4.73) >0.05 4 (1) na (347) 2 4 M
Olanzapine+fluoxetine Placebo MDa 0.00 (−2.57 to 2.55) >0.05 4 (1) na (225) 1 4 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo MDa −1.09 (−4.57 to 2.37) >0.05 4 (2) na (225) 0 3 L
Youth, Adults Bipolar disorder Aripiprazole Placebo g −0.45 (−0.85 to −0.05) 0.03 2 715 2 2 L
Adults Bipolar disorder Asenapine Placebo NNH 38 (na) >0.05 7 473 0 3 L
Olanzapine Placebo NNH −177 (na) >0.05 7 473 0 3 L
Bipolar disorder (mania) Asenapine Placebo MD a 0.2 (0.030.37) 0.02 2 581 2 5 M
Bipolar disorder (depression) Aripiprazole Placebo MDa 0.90 (−2.17 to 4.12) >0.05 18 (2) na (749) 1 5 M
Cariprazine Placebo MDa 0.07 (−1.31 to 1.70) >0.05 18 (4) na (1765) 1 7 H
Lurasidone Placebo MDa −1.45 (−5.50 to 2.64) >0.05 18 (1) na (485) 2 6 M
Olanzapine Placebo MDa −0.34 (−3.18 to 2.17) >0.05 18 (2) na (na) 1 4 M
Quetiapine IR Placebo MDa 1.54 (−0.76 to 3.95) >0.05 7 (4) 3267 (1461) 1 4 M
Quetiapine XR Placebo MDa 0.001 (−1.21 to 2.03) >0.05 7 (3) 3267 (871) 1 4 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo MDa 1.15 (−0.82 to 3.12) >0.05 18 (6) na (2756) 1 7 H
T1&2DM, Depression CBT TAU SMD −0.63 (−0.94 to −0.33) <0.0001 3 175 2 1 L
SSRI Placebo SMD −0.31 (−0.57 to −0.06) <0.05 5 247 2 3 L
Paroxetine Placebo SMD −0.19 (−0.58 to 0.19) >0.05 3 104 2 3 L
T2DM, Depression Mixed psychological interventions TAU SMD −0.93 (−1.15 to −0.71) <0.00001 22 2000 1 3 L
2 - hour postprandial plasma glucose
Adults T2DM, Depression Mixed psychological interventions TAU SMD −0.84 (−1.13 to −0.56) <0.00001 17 1585 1 3 L
HbA1c
Adults Bipolar disorder Olanzapine Placebo NNH 69 (37525) <0.05 7 473 0 3 L
Asenapine Placebo NNH 107 (na) >0.05 7 473 0 3 L
Bipolar disorder (depression) Lurasidone Placebo SMD 0.14 (−0.07 to 0.35) >0.05 3 (1) 1223 (253) 1 6 M
Olanzapine Placebo SMD 0.05 (−0.15 to 0.24) >0.05 3 (1) 1223 (514) 1 6 M
Quetiapine IR Placebo MDa 0.05 (−0.02 to 0.13) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (766) 1 4 M
Quetiapine XR Placebo MDa 0.02 (−0.04 to 0.08) >0.05 7 (3) 3267 (875) 1 6 M
T1&2DM, Depression Mixed pharmacological TAU/WL/Placebo SMD −0.99 (−1.85 to −0.13) 0.024 6 432 1 1 L
Psychotherapy TAU/WL/Placebo SMD −0.61 (−1.07 to −0.15) 0.01 9 958 1 2 L
SSRI Placebo SMD −0.29 (−0.52 to −0.05) 0.02 7 428 1 3 L
Any treatment for depression (psychotherapy, pharmacological, collaborative care) TAU SMD −0.27 (−0.40 to −0.15) <0.001 12 1666 2 5 M
Collaborative care TAU SMD −0.23 (−0.39 to −0.08) 0.003 7 1556 1 5 M
Any intervention (collaborative care, psychotherapy, pharmacological, online-based, phone-based, exercise, group-based) TAU/WL/Placebo SMD −0.21 (−0.33 to −0.09) 0.001 24 3415 1 4 M
Collaborative care TAU/WL/Placebo SMD −0.21 (−0.36 to −0.05) 0.01 5 1470 1 3 L
CBT TAU SMD −0.22 (−0.53 to 0.08) 0.15 7 759 2 2 L
T2DM, Depression Mixed psychological interventions TAU SMD −0.81 (−1.10 to −0.53) <0.00001 22 1765 1 2 L
Collaborative care TAU OR 1.31 (0.85–2.01) 0.228 3 774 2 2 L
Insulin
Adults Bipolar disorder (depression) Quetiapine IR Placebo MDa 12.9 (−19.4 to 46.3) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (766) 1 4 M
Quetiapine XR Placebo MDa 2.70 (−19.4 to 35.4) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (510) 1 4 M
HDL cholesterol
Youth Bipolar disorder (depression) Lurasidone Placebo MDa 2.30 (−0.07 to 4.67) >0.05 4 (1) na (347) 2 4 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo MDa −0.39 (−2.75 to 1.96) >0.05 4 (2) na (225) 0 3 L
Youth, Adults Bipolar disorder Aripiprazole Placebo g −0.23 (−0.49 to 0.02) 0.07 2 715 2 2 L
Adults Bipolar disorder (mania) Asenapine Placebo MDa 0.88 (−0.85 to 2.61) >0.05 2 581 2 5 M
Bipolar disorder (depression) Lurasidone Placebo SMD −0.16 (−0.37 to 0.06) >0.05 3 (1) 1223 (253) 1 6 M
Olanzapine Placebo SMD 0.12 (−0.07 to 0.31) >0.05 3 (1) 1223 (514) 1 6 M
Quetiapine IR Placebo MDa −1.05 (−3.01 to 0.94) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (766) 1 4 M
Quetiapine XR Placebo MDa −0.04 (−1.59 to 1.27) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (580) 1 4 M
LDL cholesterol
Youth Bipolar disorder (depression) Lurasidone Placebo MDa −5.90 (−10.51 to −1.30) <0.05 4 (1) na (347) 2 4 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo MDa −0.69(−6.21 to 4.82) >0.05 4 (2) na (225) 0 3 L
Adults Bipolar disorder Asenapine Placebo NNH −171 (na) >0.05 7 473 0 3 L
Olanzapine Placebo NNH −148 (na) >0.05 7 473 0 3 L
Bipolar disorder (mania) Asenapine Placebo MDa 0.06 (−0.11 to 0.23) >0.05 2 581 2 5 M
Bipolar disorder (depression) Aripiprazole Placebo MDa −0.50 (−4.09 to 3.14) >0.05 18 (2) na (749) 1 5 M
Cariprazine Placebo MDa −0.67 (−3.23 to 0.42) >0.05 18 (4) na (1765) 1 7 H
Lurasidone Placebo MDa 1.18 (−3.86 to 6.23) >0.05 18 (1) na (485) 2 6 M
Olanzapine Placebo MDa 0.42 (−1.23 to 2.16) >0.05 18 (2) na (na) 1 5 M
Quetiapine IR Placebo MDa 0.49 (−5.93 to 7.04) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (766) 1 4 M
Quetiapine XR Placebo MDa 1.77 (−2.71 to 7.67) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (567) 1 4 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo MDa −0.59 (−4.23 to 3.00) >0.05 18 (3) na (na) 1 5 M
Total cholesterol
Youth Bipolar disorder (depression) Olanzapine + fluoxetine Placebo MDa 20.47 (13.97 to 26.94) <0.05 4 (1) na (225) 1 4 M
Lurasidone Placebo MDa −4.89 (−10.29 to 0.55) >0.05 4 (1) na (347) 2 4 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo MDa 5.40 (−0.72 to 11.48) >0.05 4 (2) na (225) 0 3 L
Youth, Adults Bipolar disorder Aripiprazole Placebo OR 0.59 (0.360.97) 0.04 2 715 2 2 L
Adults Bipolar disorder Asenapine Placebo NNH 1000 (na) >0.05 7 473 0 3 L
Olanzapine Placebo NNH −108 (na) >0.05 7 473 0 3 L
Bipolar disorder (mania) Asenapine Placebo MDa 0.08 (−0.09 to 0.25) >0.05 2 581 2 5 M
Bipolar disorder (depression) Olanzapine Placebo MDa 7.06 (2.4712.0) <0.05 18 (3) na (1329) 1 6 M
Aripiprazole Placebo MDa 0.50 (−5.64 to 6.60) >0.05 18 (2) na (749) 1 5 M
Cariprazine Placebo MDa −2.05 (−5.90 to 1.67) >0.05 18 (4) na (1765) 1 7 H
Lurasidone Placebo MDa 1.72 (−6.56 to 9.94) >0.05 18 (1) na (485) 2 6 M
Quetiapine IR Placebo MDa 1.97 (−7.77 to 11.8) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (766) 1 4 M
Quetiapine XR Placebo MDa 3.65 (−4.68 to 13.1) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (580) 1 4 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo MDa 0.50 (−4.86 to 5.88) >0.05 18 (3) na (na) 1 5 M
Triglycerides
Youth Bipolar disorder (depression) Olanzapine + fluoxetine Placebo MDa 38.57 (21.4155.77) <0.05 4 (1) na (225) 1 4 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo MDa 34.87 (20.0849.67) <0.05 4 (2) na (225) 0 3 L
Lurasidone Placebo MDa −13.43 (−26.63 to −0.25) <0.05 4 (1) na (347) 2 4 M
Youth, Adults Bipolar disorder Aripiprazole Placebo g 0.08 (−0.06 to 0.23) 0.27 2 715 2 2 L
Adults Bipolar disorder Asenapine Placebo NNH 27 (na) >0.05 7 473 0 3 L
Bipolar disorder (mania) Asenapine Placebo MDa 0.14 (−0.03 to 0.31) >0.05 2 581 2 5 M
Bipolar disorder (depression) Aripiprazole Placebo MDa 0.98 (−10.48 to 12.47) >0.05 18 (2) na (749) 1 5 M
Cariprazine Placebo MDa 1.35 (−1.27 to 6.50) >0.05 18 (4) na (1765) 1 7 H
Lurasidone Placebo MDa −3.05 (−15.37 to 9.55) >0.05 18 (1) na (485) 2 6 M
Olanzapine Placebo MDa 1.85 (−1.88 to 8.64) >0.05 18 (2) na (na) 1 4 M
Quetiapine IR Placebo MDa 11.3 (−20.6 to 44.6) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (766) 1 4 M
Quetiapine XR Placebo MDa 13.5 (−14.7 to 45.8) >0.05 7 (2) 3267 (580) 1 4 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo MDa 11.1 (−2.75 to 24.9) >0.05 18 (3) na (na) 1 5 M
Elevation of metabolic blood parameters (lipids and glucose-related)
Adults Depression Olanzapine Placebo OR 4.46 (2.079.58) <0.05 4 na 1 2 L
Quetiapine Placebo OR 2.45 (1.803.34) <0.05 2 na 1 2 L
Liver enzymes elevation
Adults Bipolar disorder (mania or mixed) Olanzapine Placebo RR 10.3 (2.8537.4) 0.0001 2 254 1 4 M
Waist circumference
Adults Bipolar disorder (mania) Asenapine Placebo MDa 0.16 (−0.01 to 0.33) >0.05 2 581 2 5 M
Weight gain
Youth Bipolar disorder (depression) Olanzapine + fluoxetine Placebo OR 44.8 (11.2148) <0.05 4 (1) na (225) 1 4 M
Lurasidone Placebo OR 0.82 (0.22–2.13) >0.05 4 (1) na (347) 2 3 L
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo OR 2.59 (0.79–6.74) >0.05 4 (2) na (225) 0 4 M
Youth, Adults Bipolar disorder Aripiprazole Placebo g 0.05 (−0.11 to 0.21) 0.54 4 1,005 2 3 L
Lithium Placebo SMD 0.11 (−0.08 to 0.30) >0.05 3 437 2 3 L
Bipolar disorder (depression) Quetiapine Placebo RR 2.33 (1.344.03) <0.05 7 2780 1 4 M
Adults Bipolar disorder SGA Placebo RRa 6.40 (3.9011.0) <0.05 4 1954 1 5 M
Antipsychotics LAI Placebo RR 2.32 (1.334.06) 0.003 4 960 1 4 M
Asenapine Placebo NNH 19 (1337) <0.05 7 473 0 3 L
Aripiprazole Placebo RR 4.07 (0.22–74.9) >0.05 13 (1) 3558 (na) 1 5 M
Aripiprazole LAI Placebo RR 1.35 (0.09–20.3) >0.05 13 (1) 3558 (na) 1 5 M
Asenapine Placebo RR 1.11 (0.07–18.0) >0.05 13 (1) 3558 (na) 1 5 M
Lithium Placebo RR 1.29 (0.16–10.5) >0.05 13 (1) 3558 (na) 1 5 M
Olanzapine Placebo RR 1.23 (0.21–7.09) >0.05 13 (1) 3558 (na) 1 5 M
Paliperidone Placebo RR 1.18 (0.07–18.9) >0.05 13 (1) 3558 (na) 1 5 M
Quetiapine Placebo RR 1.94 (0.13–29.8) >0.05 13 (1) 3558 (na) 1 5 M
Risperidone LAI Placebo RR 2.30 (0.35–15.1) >0.05 13 (1) 3558 (na) 1 5 M
Valproate Placebo RR 2.11 (0.19–23.7) >0.05 13 (1) 3558 (na) 1 5 M
Bipolar disorder (mania) Olanzapine Placebo NNH 9 (712) <0.05 6 1100 0 5 M
Asenapine Placebo NNH 19 (1432) <0.05 3 949 0 4 M
Ziprasidone Placebo NNH 21 (11933) <0.05 3 450 0 3 L
Risperidone Placebo NNH 27 (121454) <0.05 3 259 0 3 L
Divalproex Placebo NNH 30 (16662) <0.05 4 665 0 4 M
Aripiprazole Placebo NNH 78 (− 30 to 191) >0.05 5 1373 0 5 M
Cariprazine Placebo NNH 240 (−72 to 500) >0.05 3 1039 0 5 M
Haloperidol Placebo NNH −127 (−210 to 37) >0.05 2 550 0 4 M
Lithium Placebo OR 1.55 (0.29–8.29) 0.61 3 735 2 2 L
Paliperidone Placebo NNH 34 (−92 to 180) >0.05 2 467 0 3 L
Haloperidol + lithium or valproate Placebo SMD −0.14 (−0.32 to 0.04) 0.11 3 484 1 4 M
Bipolar disorder (mania or mixed) Olanzapine Placebo OR 5.08 (3.297.85) 0.0001 3 581 1 6 M
Risperidone Placebo OR 2.51 (1.304.85) 0.006 4 806 2 5 M
SGA Placebo SMD 0.33 (0.120.55) 0.002 9 1990 2 3 L
Aripiprazole Placebo SMD 0.16 (−0.02 to 0.33) 0.06 2 514 2 2 L
Bipolar disorder (depression) Olanzapine Placebo OR 68.5 (15.6231) <0.05 18 (2) na (na) 1 3 L
Quetiapine XR Placebo RR 3.50 (1.677.95) <0.05 7 (3) 3267 (920) 1 4 M
Cariprazine Placebo OR 3.50 (1.268.65) <0.05 18 (4) na (1765) 1 6 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo OR 3.46 (1.915.92) <0.05 18 (6) na (2756) 1 6 M
SGA Placebo RR 2.77 (1.724.45) <0.001 12 4599 1 6 M
Quetiapine IR Placebo RR 2.60 (1.494.87) <0.05 7 (4) 3267 (1349) 1 4 M
Modafinil Placebo RR 0.34 (0.150.76) 0.009 3 1040 0 3 L
Lurasidone Placebo OR 19.1 (0.66–108) >0.05 18 (1) na (485) 2 5 M
Aripiprazole Placebo OR 1.67 (0.56–3.92) > 0.05 18 (2) na (749) 1 4 M
Anti-ADHD medications Placebo RR 0.40 (0.200.70) 0.02 3 1056 1 7 M
Depression Olanzapine Placebo OR 16.3 (7.0237.8) <0.05 4 na 1 2 L
Aripiprazole Placebo OR 5.91 (2.1416.3) <0.05 3 na 1 2 L
Brexpiprazole Placebo RR 4.36 (2.457.77) <0.0001 4 1673 2 6 M
Quetiapine Placebo OR 2.86 (1.117.37) <0.05 3 na 1 2 L
Unipolar/bipolar depression Lurasidone Placebo RR 4.11 (1.0216.6) <0.05 3 897 1 6 M
Adults, Elderly Depression Brexpiprazole + antidepressant Placebo + antidepressant RR 2.88 (1.874.42) <0.0001 8 3370 1 5 M
Miscellaneous
Combined physical outcomes (HbA1c, number of epileptic seizures, HIV-symptom severity, pain and physical functioning)
Adults Chronic medical conditions, Depression Collaborative care TAU OR 0.68 (0.600.78) <0.001 19 4692 2 5 M
Combined physical outcomes (HbA1c; physical functioning; systolic blood pressure)
Adults Chronic medical conditions, Depression Collaborative care TAU OR 0.60 (0.460.79) <0.001 2 598 2 2 L
Somatic diagnostic or treatment procedures
Adults Chronic medical conditions, Depression Collaborative care TAU OR 0.44 (0.330.60) <0.05 4 638 2 3 L
Stroke recurrence
Elderly Post-stroke depression Antidepressants Placebo ORa 1.14 (0.15–8.60) >0.05 2 105 1 1 L
Pain
Pain
Adults Depression SNRI Placebo d −0.27 (−0.33 to −0.21) <0.05 14 4993 1 7 M
Duloxetine Placebo SMD −0.26 (−0.51 to −0.01) <0.05 11 4980 1 5 M
SSRI Placebo d −0.24 (−0.36 to −0.13) <0.05 6 1325 1 6 M
Paroxetine Placebo WMDa −5.8 (−9.4 to −2.2) <0.05 4 na 0 2 L
Pain + physical functioning
Adults Arthritis, Depression Collaborative care TAU OR 0.66 (0.540.79) <0.001 2 1251 2 3 L
Cancer, Depression Collaborative care TAU OR 0.75 (0.610.90) 0.002 3 727 2 2 L
Quality of life
Diabetes-related distress
Adults T1&2DM, Depression CBT TAU SMD −0.25 (−0.50 to 0.01) 0.06 2 236 2 1 L
Physical health-related quality of life
Adults Depression Mixed psychological TAU/placebo/no treatment g −0.27 (−0.46 to −0.07) <0.01 14 na 2 0 L
ACS, Depression Mixed psychological/pharmacological TAU SMD −0.14 (−0.24 to −0.04) 0.009 5 2105 2 5 M
Chronic medical conditions, Depression SSRI Placebo SMD 0.02 (−0.19 to 0.23) >0.05 5 338 1 3 L
Adults, Elderly Depression Physical exercise TAU/WL/Placebo SMD −0.53 (−0.84 to −0.22) 0.001 5 175 2 1 L
Elderly COPD and depression SSRI Placebo SMD 1.17 (−0.80 to 3.15) 0.25 2 148 0 3 L
Any adverse event, discontinuation due to adverse events
Any adverse event
Youth Depression Paroxetine Placebo OR 1.82 (1.063.11) <0.05 24 (4) 3408 (681) 0 3 L
SSRI Placebo OR 1.47 (1.161.87) <0.05 24 (11) 4859 (2464) 0 4 M
Antidepressants Placebo RR 1.04 (0.97–1.11) >0.05 7 1911 1 4 M
Citalopram Placebo OR 1.68 (0.80–3.54) >0.05 24 (2) 3231 (407) 0 2 L
Desvenlafaxine Placebo OR 0.98 (0.52–1.86) >0.05 24 (1) 3594 (227) 0 3 L
Escitalopram Placebo OR 1.13 (0.57–2.25) >0.05 24 (2) 3304 (572) 0 3 L
Fluoxetine Placebo OR 1.16 (0.78–1.72) >0.05 24 (2) 3794 (1627) 0 4 M
SNRI Placebo OR 1.16 (0.77–1.73) >0.05 24 (2) 3880 (561) 0 4 M
SSRI/SNRI Placebo RR 1.06 (0.98–1.15) 0.13 15 na 1 6 M
Adolescents Depression Antidepressants Placebo RR 1.11 (1.041.19) 0.002 6 1327 0 5 M
Youth, Adults Bipolar disorder (depression) Quetiapine Placebo RR 1.18 (1.12 to 1.25) <0.05 7 2780 1 4 M
Adults Bipolar disorder Risperidone LAI Placebo RR 1.10 (0.94–1.28) 0.23 2 570 1 3 L
Bipolar disorder (mania or mixed) Valproate Placebo OR 1.63 (1.132.36) 0.01 3 745 2 4 M
Cariprazine Placebo OR 1.75 (0.74–4.15) 0.11 3 1045 2 8 M
Risperidone Placebo RR 1.04 (0.88–1.23) 0.66 2 253 2 4 M
Bipolar disorder (depression) Lurasidone Placebo RR 1.12 (1.00–1.26) 0.05 2 704 2 5 M
Depression Dextroamphetamine Placebo RR 5.05 (1.6415.6) <0.05 17 (7) 3473 (408) 0 4 M
Amitriptyline Placebo OR 4.64 (2.458.78) <0.0001 7 802 1 2 L
Bupropion Placebo OR 3.08 (2.004.74) <0.05 32 (na) 5245 (na) 0 3 L
Fluoxetine Placebo OR 2.68 (1.893.81) <0.05 32 (na) 5245 (na) 0 3 L
Venlafaxine Placebo OR 2.63 (1.933.57) <0.05 32 (na) 5245 (na) 1 3 L
Aripiprazole Placebo OR 1.95 (1.522.51) <0.05 8 2796 1 7 H
Vortioxetine Placebo OR 1.54 (1.281.85) <0.05 32 (na) 5245 (na) 1 3 L
Brexpiprazole Placebo OR 1.37 (1.211.56) <0.05 10 3998 1 7 H
Lisdexamphetamine Placebo RR 1.17 (1.071.28) <0.05 17 (4) 3473 (1212) 0 5 M
Paroxetine Placebo RR 1.15 (1.111.19) <0.05 35 5709 2 5 M
Mirtazapine Placebo OR 1.37 (0.46–4.05) >0.05 32 (na) 5245 (na) 2 3 L
Methylphenidate Placebo RR 1.09 (0.86–1.37) >0.05 17 (12) 3471 (703) 0 4 M
Modafinil Placebo RR 1.03 (0.85–1.26) >0.05 17 (6) 3471 (647) 0 5 M
Pemoline Placebo RR 2.98 (0.93–9.58) >0.05 17 (2) 3473 (140) 0 4 M
Seasonal depression Bupropion Placebo RR 1.02 (0.97–1.08) 0.4 3 1048 1 7 H
Unipolar/bipolar depression Lamotrigine Placebo RR 1.04 (0.92–1.18) 0.54 3 166 1 3 L
Adults, Elderly Depression SNRI Placebo OR 3.30 (1.447.59) <0.05 28 (1) 4276 (na) 1 6 M
TCA Placebo OR 2.67 (1.823.92) <0.05 28 (3) 4276 (na) 0 6 M
Antipsychotics Placebo OR 1.34 (0.93–1.91) >0.05 28 (2) 4276 (na) 1 6 M
MAO-I Placebo OR 1.42 (0.74–2.69) >0.05 28 (1) 4276 (na) 1 6 M
SSRI Placebo OR 1.35 (0.94–1.96) >0.05 28 (4) 4276 (na) 1 6 M
Elderly Depression SNRI Placebo RR 1.14 (1.031.25) <0.05 3 805 0 5 M
SSRI Placebo RR 1.07 (0.98–1.16) >0.05 2 713 1 5 M
Discontinuation due to adverse events
Youth Bipolar disorder (depression) Olanzapine + fluoxetine Placebo ORa 3.31 (1.088.75) <0.05 4 (1) na (225) 1 4 M
Quetiapine IR/XR Placebo ORa 0.32 (0.070.83) <0.05 4 (2) na (225) 0 3 L
Lurasidone Placebo ORa 1.49 (0.17–5.84) >0.05 4 (1) na (347) 2 4 M
Depression SNRI Placebo RR 2.95 (1.615.40) <0.001 3 na 1 6 M
Duloxetine Placebo OR 2.80 (1.209.42) <0.05 34 (2) 5260 0 8 H
SSRI/SNRI Placebo RR 1.66 (1.202.28) 0.002 17 na 1 6 M
Citalopram Placebo OR 1.13 (0.45–3.66) >0.05 34 (2) 5260 0 8 H
Desipramine Placebo OR 2.85 (0.83–21.8) >0.05 34 (2) 5260 0 8 H
Escitalopram Placebo OR 1.64 (0.46–13.5) >0.05 34 (2) 5260 0 8 H
Fluoxetine Placebo OR 1.03 (0.50–2.70) >0.05 34 (5) 5260 2 8 H
Mirtazapine Placebo OR 1.36 (0.41–11.0) >0.05 34 (2) 5260 0 8 H
Paroxetine Placebo OR 1.59 (0.77–3.95) >0.05 34 (4) 5260 0 8 H
SSRI Placebo RR 1.40 (0.99–1.98) 0.06 14 na 1 6 M
Youth, Adults Bipolar disorder Aripiprazole Placebo OR 1.55 (1.162.08) 0.004 8 na 2 4 M
Bipolar disorder (mania or mixed) Valproate Placebo RR 2.42 (1.284.56) <0.05 7 1012 1 4 M
Olanzapine Placebo RR 1.93 (0.48–7.72) >0.05 8 730 1 2 L
Bipolar disorder (depression) Quetiapine Placebo RR 1.88 (1.202.96) <0.05 7 2780 1 4 M
Adults Bipolar disorder Antipsychotics LAI Placebo RR 2.89 (1.038.09) 0.04 4 929 1 4 M
Asenapine Placebo RR 0.36 (0.160.81) <0.05 21 (1) 6107 (na) 1 6 M
Lithium Placebo RR 2.24 (1.433.50) <0.05 21 (5) 6107 (na) 1 6 M
Aripiprazole Placebo RR 6.39 (0.76–53.5) >0.05 21 (1) 6107 (na) 1 6 M
Aripiprazole LAI Placebo RR 7.00 (0.85–57.9) >0.05 21 (1) 6107 (na) 1 6 M
Lamotrigine Placebo RR 0.55 (0.18–1.73) >0.05 21 (2) 6107 (na) 1 6 M
Olanzapine Placebo RR 1.81 (0.98–3.36) >0.05 21 (2) 6107 (na) 1 6 M
Paliperidone Placebo RR 1.22 (0.32–4.67) >0.05 21 (1) 6107 (na) 1 6 M
Quetiapine Placebo RR 1.16 (0.70–1.94) >0.05 21 (2) 6107 (na) 1 6 M
Risperidone LAI Placebo RR 1.79 (0.57–5.61) >0.05 21 (2) 6107 (na) 1 6 M
Bipolar disorder (mania) Cariprazine Placebo NNH 22 (12105) <0.05 3 1045 1 5 M
Divalproex Placebo NNH 25 (14134) <0.05 4 683 1 4 M
Aripiprazole Placebo NNH 44 (−144 to 19) >0.05 5 1575 1 5 M
Asenapine Placebo NNH 28 (−546 to 14) >0.05 3 948 1 4 M
Atypical antipsychotics Placebo RRa 1.10 (0.80–1.50) >0.05 13 2857 1 5 M
Carbamazepine Placebo RR 2.00 (1.03–3.90) >0.05 2 427 1 4 M
Haloperidol Placebo NNH 21 (−204 to 100) >0.05 2 578 1 4 M
Haloperidol + lithium or valproate Placebo RR 1.39 (0.58–3.34) 0.5 2 304 1 4 M
Lithium Placebo RR 2.14 (0.80–5.75) >0.05 2 305 1 3 L
Olanzapine Placebo NNH 113 (−66 to 330) >0.05 6 1375 1 5 M
Paliperidone Placebo NNH 70 (−29 to 220) >0.05 2 769 1 4 M
Quetiapine Placebo OR 0.92 (0.50–1.69) 0.80 6 1158 2 5 M
Risperidone Placebo NNH 144 (−45 to 280) >0.05 3 844 1 4 M
Ziprasidone Placebo NNH 26 (−1870 to 140) >0.05 3 782 1 4 M
Bipolar disorder (mania or mixed) Ziprasidone Placebo RR 2.40 (1.015.68) <0.05 3 665 1 3 L
Cariprazine Placebo OR 2.10 (1.373.21) 0.02 3 1045 2 8 M
Carbamazepine Placebo RR 1.97 (1.043.74) <0.05 2 439 1 2 L
Aripiprazole Placebo RR 1.21 (0.84–1.75) >0.05 5 1155 1 4 M
Haloperidol Placebo RR 1.10 (0.40–3.53) >0.05 7 1060 1 3 L
Lithium Placebo RR 1.74 (1.00–3.02) >0.05 6 630 1 2 L
Olanzapine Placebo RR 0.79 (0.08–8.27) 0.84 2 254 2 0 L
Quetiapine Placebo RR 1.13 (0.49–2.60) 0.77 2 407 2 1 L
Risperidone Placebo RR 1.18 (0.62–2.27) >0.05 3 843 1 3 L
SGA Placebo RR 1.19 (0.84–1.69) 0.32 11 2455 2 3 L
Valproate Placebo RR 1.91 (0.66–5.51) 0.23 3 321 1 3 L
Bipolar disorder (depression) SGA Placebo RR 2.03 (1.532.69) <0.001 12 4716 1 6 M
Quetiapine Placebo OR 2.46 (1.573.75) <0.05 18 (6) na (2756) 1 7 H
Aripiprazole Placebo OR 2.47 (1.104.90) <0.05 18 (2) na (749) 1 5 M
Quetiapine IR Placebo RR 2.25 (1.324.01) <0.05 7 (4) 3267 (1472) 1 4 M
Lamotrigine Placebo NNH 27 (14514) <0.05 2 1138 1 5 M
Quetiapine XR Placebo RR 1.89 (1.00–3.88) 0.05 7 (3) 3267 (929) 1 4 M
Cariprazine Placebo OR 1.50 (0.82–2.64) >0.05 18 (4) na (1765) 1 7 H
Lurasidone Placebo OR 1.12 (0.36–2.76) >0.05 18 (1) na (485) 2 6 M
Olanzapine Placebo OR 1.43 (0.68–2.58) >0.05 18 (3) na (1329) 1 6 M
Anti-ADHD medications Placebo RR 1.30 (0.81–2.10) 0.20 5 1543 1 7 M
Valproate Placebo RR 1.40 (0.18–10.6) 0.75 4 142 1 4 M
Ziprasidone Placebo OR 1.54 (0.76–2.80) >0.05 18 (2) na (885) 0 7 H
Depression Amitriptyline Placebo OR 4.15 (2.716.35) <0.0001 19 2174 1 5 M
Brexpiprazole Placebo RR 3.44 (1.527.80) 0.003 4 1673 2 6 M
Quetiapine XR Placebo RR 2.90 (1.874.48) <0.05 3 1460 1 5 M
Aripiprazole Placebo OR 2.12 (1.233.67) 0.007 6 2073 1 5 M
Desvenlafaxine Placebo RR 1.98 (1.452.69) <0.001 12 na 0 5 M
Fluoxetine Placebo OR 1.96 (1.422.72) <0.01 7 2450 2 6 L
Paroxetine Placebo RR 1.77 (1.442.18) <0.05 38 6165 2 5 M
Brexpiprazole + antidepressant Placebo + antidepressant NNH 54 (32190) <0.05 3 1485 0 5 L
Dextroamphetamine Placebo RR 0.36 (0.02–8.03) >0.05 17 (7) 3473 (408) 0 4 M
Lisdexamphetamine Placebo RR 1.54 (0.69–3.42) >0.05 17 (4) 3473 (1212) 0 5 M
Methylphenidate Placebo RR 2.22 (0.94–5.24) >0.05 17 (12) 3471 (703) 0 4 M
Modafinil Placebo RR 1.42 (0.66–3.06) > 0.05 17 (6) 3471 (647) 0 5 M
Seasonal depression Bupropion Placebo RR 1.68 (0.74–3.79) 0.21 3 1048 1 6 M
Unipolar/bipolar depression Lamotrigine Placebo RR 0.93 (0.45–1.92) 0.84 12 na 1 3 L
Chronic medical conditions, depression SSRI Placebo RR 1.80 (1.162.78) <0.05 13 1661 1 5 M
TCA Placebo RR 1.88 (0.99–3.57) >0.05 5 239 1 4 M
CHD, Depression SSRI Placebo OR 1.30 (0.75–2.25) 0.35 2 653 2 4 M
Adults, Elderly Depression TCA Placebo OR 3.98 (2.546.21) <0.05 28 (6) 4276 (na) 0 6 M
MAO-I Placebo OR 2.84 (1.186.83) <0.05 28 (1) 4276 (na) 1 6 M
Antipsychotics Placebo OR 2.42 (1.444.06) <0.05 28 (2) 4276 (na) 1 6 M
Brexpiprazole + antidepressant Placebo + antidepressant RR 2.36 (1.463.82) 0.0004 8 3373 1 5 M
SSRI Placebo OR 1.99 (1.283.08) <0.05 28 (8) 4276 (na) 1 6 M
Post-stroke depression Doxepine Placebo OR 100 (2.001000) <0.05 14 (1) 949 (48) 0 2 L
Citalopram Placebo OR 8.33 (0.41–50.0) >0.05 14 (1) 949 (48) 0 2 L
Fluoxetine Placebo OR 4.17 (0.65–14.3) > 0.05 14 (4) 949 (215) 0 2 L
Nortriptyline Placebo OR 3.57 (0.55–12.5) >0.05 14 (2) 949 (72) 0 2 L
Paroxetine Placebo OR 0.74 (0.23–4.00) >0.05 14 (2) 949 (277) 1 2 L
Trazodone Placebo OR 2.63 (0.05–14.3) >0.05 14 (2) 949 (39) 0 2 L
Elderly Depression SSRI Placebo RR 2.90 (1.165.06) <0.05 3 887 1 5 M
SNRI Placebo RR 1.85 (1.053.27) <0.05 3 812 0 5 M

aEffect size could not be recalculated as standardized measure, ACS Acute coronary syndrome, BMI Body mass index, C Quality as per AMSTAR-Content score 0–9, youth, children and adolescents, CBT Cognitive behavioural therapy, CHD Coronary heart disease, CI Confidence interval, d Cohen’s d, ES Effect size, g Hedges’ g, HbA1c Glycated hemoglobin, HDL High density lipoprotein, HIV Human immunodeficiency virus, IR Immediate release, k Number of studies (in brackets number of direct comparisons in NMAs results), LDL Low density lipoprotein, MD Mean difference, n Number of subjects (in brackets number of subjects in direct comparisons in NMAs results), na Not assessed, NNH Number needed to harm, NNT Number needed to treat, OR Odds ratio, Q Overall quality rating (L Low, M Medium, H High, see methods section), R Recommendation as stated by authors (see methods section), RD Risk difference, RR Risk ratio, SGA Second-generation antipsychotics, SMD Standardized mean difference, SNRI Serotonin noradrenaline reuptake inhibitors, SSRI Selective serotonine reuptake inhibitors, T1&2DM Type 1 and 2 diabetes mellitus, TAU Treatment as usual, TCA Tricyclic antidepressants, WL wait list, WMD Weighted mean difference, XR extended release. Results are presented for age group and diagnosis, first all significant ESs in bold in order of ES magnitude, then all other results in alphabetical order for intervention and comparison. Negative values of SMD and OR/RR values < 1 indicate clinical benefit of intervention over control (e.g., glucose decrease, weight loss, cardiorespiratory fitness increase, better tolerated).