Table 3.
Factors To Consider | Pros | Reference |
---|---|---|
Accessibility for research | Greater acceptability to animal ethics committees cf. companion animals | [26,53] |
Easily available, reasonably outbreed, less expensive to buy cf. other large species | [10,29,53,70] | |
Long living mammal (10–20 years) with body size, weight and brain comparable to the human | [19,29,57,58,70,71,72,73] | |
Easy management, Surgical manipulation |
[14,29,70,74,75] | |
Body system specific advantages | Brain: higher degree of white matter and gyrencephalic structure, strong cerebellar tentorium cortical organization | [19,57,58,70,72,73] |
Excellent animal model to study HD due to HTT gene | [69] | |
Long bones with dimensions suitable for the deployment of implant systems | [14,29,58] | |
Excellent animal model to study osteoporosis due to long bones, early brain development | [14,29,70] | |
Suitable to study the main physiological systems: cardiovascular, orthopedic, endocrine, respiratory, renal, nervous and reproductive systems, host organisms for virus infection | [10,14,29,58,70] | |
Others | Environmental enrichment not required as they live in their natural pasture | [58] |
Increased clinical translation and more accurate indication (as the dosage, drug distribution, and safety of potential therapies trialed) | [66] | |
Ability to use clinically relevant technology to provide clinically translational measures, such as MRI, CT, and PET; ability to use clinical equipment such as anesthesia, physiological monitoring, surgical equipment | [53,76] | |
Strong, can carry a backpack with transmitting devices | [58] | |
Natural model for human infections such as parainfluenza, E.Coli. | [77] | |
Cons | ||
Accessibility for research | Higher ethical considerations than small animals | [29,53] |
Higher costs for maintenance and larger facilities required to perform procedures than small animals | [10,29,53,70] | |
Body system-specific advantages | Longer gestation time compared with small animals; Uniparous in breeding, difficulty scaling up the number of offspring | [19,29,57,58,70,71,72,73] |
Not suitable for studying neurobiology of fine motor control and binocular eye movements | [14,29,70,74,75] | |
Transgenic selection and production of transgenic strains limited | [69] | |
Poor availability of physiological databases for mapping to humans including atlases | [14,20,70] | |
Others | Vital sign monitoring needed by a veterinary practitioner during all surgical procedures | [19,57,58,70,72,73] |
Unlike, rodents, no standard behavioral testing protocol | [14,29,58] | |
Limited access to antibodies | [10,14,29,58,70] |