Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 7;12(9):738. doi: 10.3390/bios12090738

Table 2.

Advantages and disadvantages of the biomarker detection ECL systems.

Sensing System Advantages Limitations
Systems based on the chemical reactions of the luminophore and co-reactant
  • Simple design and operation;

  • Rapid detection;

  • Multiplexing capability using dual or multiple ECL emitters.

  • Limited sensitivity;

  • Possibility of cross-interference between the luminophore and co-reactant;

  • Possibility of a low stability and reproducibility of the electrode immobilised co-reactant.

Systems that incorporate co-reaction accelerator-involved reactions
  • High sensitivity by using dual or multiple co-reaction accelerators;

  • Easy selection of luminophore regardless of the luminescent intensity.

  • Need for an additional synthesis and conjugation process of the co-reaction accelerator.

Systems that incorporate resonance energy transfer reactions
  • High sensitivity,

  • Extension of the dynamic range of the modulation in the ECL intensity by introducing a quencher.

  • Potential of varying the energy transfer efficiency depending on the position and distance of the acceptor and donor;

  • Complex operation;

  • Additional costs for materials and processing.

Systems that incorporate an enzyme reaction-based signal amplification
  • Superior sensitivity.

  • Complex operation;

  • Additional costs for materials and processing;

  • Potential variations in assay time depending on the catalytic ability of enzymes and nanozymes;

  • Potential cross-reactivity in the hybridisation-based method.