Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 14;24(9):1293. doi: 10.3390/e24091293

Table 3.

Experimental results of Shannon PSO against its native version.

ID Zopt Native PSO Shannon PSO
Zmax RPDmax Zmed RPDmed Zavg RPDavg Zsd Zmax RPDmax Zmed RPDmed Zavg RPDavg Zsd
MKP01 6120 6120 0.00 6120 0.00 6120 0.00 0.00 6120 0.00 6120 0.00 6120 0.00 0.00
MKP02 12,400 12,240 0.00 12,400 0.00 12,396.45 0.00 4.86 12,240 0.00 12,400 0.00 12,399.03 0.00 3.01
MKP03 10,618 10,618 0.00 10,572 0.00 10,562.70 0.00 31.92 10,618 0.00 10,561 0.00 10,565.51 0.00 31.29
MKP04 16,537 16,516 0.13 16,408 0.00 16,407.2 0.00 55.97 16,517 0.12 16,403 0.00 16,410.58 0.00 47.90
MKP05 8722 8674 0.55 8612 0.01 8609.90 0.01 27.63 8705 0.19 8608 0.01 8607.45 0.01 34.73
MKP06 98,796 98,796 0.00 98,796 0.00 97,473.16 0.01 1735.06 98,796 0.00 98,796 0.00 97,998.61 0.00 1503.18
MKP07 130,623 130,623 0.00 130,623 0.00 130,459.45 0.00 273.16 130,623 0.00 130,233 0.00 130,360.41 0.00 345.60
MKP08 1,095,445 1,074,459 1.92 1,063,435 0.02 1,063,110.38 0.02 5623.42 1,080,226 1.39 1,060,724 0.03 1061215.71 0.03 6497.72
MKP09 4115 4115 0.00 4115 0.00 4104.83 0.00 23.55 4115 0.00 4115 0.00 4105.74 0.00 21.94
MKP10 5567 5567 0.00 5567 0.00 5561.70 0.00 9.30 5567 0.00 5567 0.00 5561.67 0.00 9.34
MKP11 5605 5605 0.00 5603 0.00 5600.64 0.00 5.68 5605 0.00 5605 0.00 5601.45 0.00 5.43
MKP12 8633 8592 0.47 8523 0.01 8513.03 0.01 42.43 8595 0.44 8508 0.01 8507.32 0.01 42.17
MKP13 3090 3090 0.00 3060 0.00 3055.51 0.01 13.00 3090 0.00 3076 0.00 3063.06 0.00 22.04
MKP14 2139 2139 0.00 2122 0.00 2118.03 0.00 20.81 2139 0.00 2122 0.00 2118.70 0.00 17.56
MKP15 3418 3418 0.00 3388 0.00 3385.41 0.00 27.38 3418 0.00 3404 0.00 3382 0.01 26.40
MKP16 3186 3186 0.00 3173 0.00 3154.83 0.00 22.95 3186 0.00 3173 0.00 3165.03 0.00 25.08
MKP17 unknown 57,415 - 57,261 - 56,711.51 - 288.09 57,821 - 57,165 - 57,167.87 - 276.97
MKP18 unknown 60,421 - 59,544 - 59,505.48 - 342.39 60,423 - 59,743 - 59,766.22 - 268.25
MKP19 unknown 58,481 - 57,477 - 57,442.41 - 290.47 58,550 - 57,982 - 57,991.45 - 262.92
MKP20 unknown 58,880 - 58,325 - 58,321.22 - 338.59 59,021 - 58,363 - 58,336.61 - 318.37