TABLE 6.
Differences of C/N ratios in vegetative organs of maize at different stages.
Cultivar | Nitrogen rate | Root |
Stem + sheath |
Leaf |
|||||||||
Jointing stage | Silking Stage | Maturity stage | Mean | Jointing stage | Silking Stage | Maturity stage | Mean | Jointing stage | Silking Stage | Maturity stage | Mean | ||
2019 | |||||||||||||
N 0 | 29.87 b | 50.82 b | 41.67 a | 40.79 b | 16.68 a | 52.98 b | 81.09 b | 50.25 b | 13.29 a | 15.08 a | 29.25 b | 19.20 b | |
N 120 | 18.63 d | 42.65 c | 29.93 c | 30.40 c | 8.47 c | 49.61 c | 66.38 d | 41.48 d | 9.94 b | 12.50 bc | 27.99 c | 16.81 | |
ZH 311 | N 240 | 16.21 e | 28.02 e | 23.92 d | 22.72 e | 8.03 c | 30.86 e | 62.31 e | 33.73 f | 10.16 b | 10.68 d | 22.99 e | 14.61 f |
N 360 | 15.96 e | 28.17 e | 21.95 d | 22.03 e | 8.20 c | 34.34 d | 57.54 f | 33.36 f | 10.20 b | 10.92 d | 23.24 e | 14.78 f | |
Mean | 20.17 B | 37.41 B | 29.37 A | 28.98 B | 10.35 A | 41.95 B | 66.83 B | 39.71 B | 10.90 A | 12.29 B | 25.87 B | 16.35 B | |
N 0 | 35.40 a | 61.05 a | 37.34 b | 44.60 a | 14.58 b | 65.14 a | 90.73 a | 56.82 a | 13.72 a | 15.22 a | 37.72 a | 22.22 a | |
N 120 | 21.14 c | 42.18 c | 27.83 c | 30.38 c | 8.76 c | 50.20 c | 74.51 c | 44.49 c | 8.90 c | 13.04 b | 29.07 b | 17.00 c | |
XY 508 | N 240 | 20.52 cd | 31.48 d | 24.33 d | 25.44 d | 8.14 c | 33.33 de | 67.70 d | 36.39 e | 8.73 c | 12.32 bc | 26.08 d | 15.71 d |
N 360 | 19.72 cd | 30.79 de | 23.08 d | 24.53 d | 7.27 d | 33.71 d | 65.39 d | 35.46 e | 8.06 c | 11.93 c | 25.79 d | 15.26 e | |
Mean | 24.20 A | 41.38 A | 28.14 A | 31.24 A | 9.68 B | 45.60 A | 74.58 A | 43.29 A | 9.85 B | 13.13 A | 29.67 A | 17.55 A | |
2020 | |||||||||||||
N 0 | 23.27 b | 34.03 b | 47.09 a | 34.80 b | 16.20 a | 69.68 b | 91.65 b | 59.18 b | 14.70 a | 22.84 b | 43.30 b | 26.95 b | |
N 120 | 15.97 c | 33.98 b | 32.39 b | 27.44 c | 10.86 c | 53.83 c | 84.40 c | 49.70 d | 11.88 v | 14.96 d | 37.88 c | 21.58 d | |
ZH 311 | N 240 | 14.67 d | 27.05 ef | 26.33 c | 22.69 ef | 9.79 ef | 38.64 d | 63.45 d | 37.29 e | 11.09 de | 12.62 f | 31.26 e | 18.33 fg |
N 360 | 15.73 c | 26.57 f | 22.55 d | 21.62 f | 9.75 f | 34.77 e | 46.97 f | 30.50 g | 10.15 f | 12.81 f | 33.44 d | 18.80 g | |
Mean | 17.41 B | 30.41 B | 32.09 B | 26.64 B | 11.65 A | 49.23 B | 71.62 B | 44.17 B | 11.96 A | 15.81 B | 36.47 B | 21.41 B | |
N 0 | 29.33 a | 38.63 a | 48.41 a | 38.79 a | 13.51 b | 82.79 a | 97.75 a | 64.74 a | 13.61 b | 24.26 a | 47.35 a | 28.41 a | |
N 120 | 15.84 c | 28.98 d | 34.34 b | 26.39 c | 11.15 c | 55.46 c | 92.56 b | 53.06 c | 11.34 d | 15.78 c | 43.54 b | 23.55 c | |
XY 508 | N 240 | 13.63 e | 31.00 c | 27.41 c | 24.01 d | 10.68 cd | 38.46 d | 60.82 d | 36.65 e | 10.60 ef | 13.71 e | 38.32 c | 20.88 e |
N 360 | 15.79 c | 28.53 de | 24.99 cd | 23.10 de | 10.31 de | 37.12 de | 51.53 e | 32.99 f | 10.78 e | 12.79 f | 34.34 d | 19.30 f | |
Mean | 18.64 A | 31.78 A | 33.79 A | 28.07 A | 11.41 A | 53.50 A | 75.66 A | 46.86 A | 11.58 B | 16.64 A | 40.89 A | 23.04 A | |
F value | Years (Y) | 247.65** | 438.92** | 87.42** | 128.23** | 178.45** | 241.42** | 20.99** | 161.18** | 115.33** | 801.69** | 2711.59** | 3759.48** |
Cultivar (C) | 99.22** | 45.44** | 0.28ns | 57.46** | 15.78** | 65.71** | 84.83** | 98.39** | 29.91** | 45.08** | 383.86** | 268.58** | |
Nitrogen (N) | 565.39** | 427.27** | 418.22** | 1019.53** | 701.75** | 1026.62** | 599.73** | 1269.64** | 205.82** | 739.73** | 524.01** | 1470.09** | |
Y × C | 27.92** | 10.64** | 10.68** | 2.82ns | 3.37ns | 0.40ns | 8.39** | 1.98ns | 6.59* | 0.00ns | 2.14ns | 6.08* | |
Y × N | 10.85** | 123.71** | 11.29** | 25.12** | 45.42** | 47.11** | 106.66** | 73.00** | 5.94** | 177.66** | 9.97** | 59.27** | |
C × N | 16.28** | 28.15** | 2.41ns | 14.00** | 34.17** | 35.78** | 5.98** | 11.51** | 1.10ns | 2.30ns | 22.45** | 20.43** | |
Y × C × N | 5.48** | 3.48* | 1.71ns | 0.50ns | 4.04* | 1.46ns | 1.66ns | 1.87ns | 11.51** | 4.16* | 27.31** | 19.65** |
Values followed by different lowercase letters are significantly different with p < 0.05; within cultivars, values with different uppercase letters are significantly different with p < 0.05 according to the least significant difference test. **p < 0.01; *p < 0.05; nsNot significant. The bold values are the mean value of one cultivar in different N treatments.