Table 3.
Author | Year | Population | Resuscitation Fluids/Fluid Balance | IAP (mmHg) | Intervention | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fietsam et al. [101] | 1989 | Surgery | >25 L of fluid | NR | DL | NR |
Burrows et al. [63] | 1995 | Surgery | 21 L of crystalloid; 4 U RCC | NR | DL | Alive |
Burrows et al. [63] | 1995 | Trauma | Pre-op: 7.3 mL/kg/h vs. Postop: 14.2 mL/kg/h | 39 | DL | NR |
Burrows et al. [63] | 1995 | Trauma | Pre-op: 9.2 mL/kg/h vs. Postop: 5.5 mL/kg/h | 40 | DL | Died |
Burrows et al. [63] | 1995 | Trauma | Pre-op: 14.7 mL/kg/h vs. Postop: 3.2 mL/kg/h | NR | DL | Alive |
Ivy et al. [33] | 1999 | Burn | 32 L | 49 | DL | Died |
Ivy et al. [33] | 1999 | Burn | 24 L | 50 | Escharotomy | Died |
Ivy et al. [33] | 1999 | Burn | 32 L | 36 | None | Died |
Kopelman et al. [65] | 2000 | Trauma | + FB: 25 L | 34 | DL | Died |
Kopelman et al. [65] | 2000 | Trauma | 26 L of crystalloid | 25 | DL | Died |
Kopelman et al. [65] | 2000 | Trauma | + FB: 29.5 L | 22 | DL | Died |
Kopelman et al. [65] | 2000 | Trauma | + FB: 10 L | 26 | DL | Alive |
Kopelman et al. [65] | 2000 | Trauma | + FB: 5 L | 46 | DL | Alive |
Macalino et al. [77] | 2002 | Sepsis | 14 L crystalloids | 27 | NMB | Died |
Kula et al. [72] | 2004 | Sepsis | 10 L + FB first 96 h. 4:1 (crystalloid: colloid) |
>25 | DL CVVH |
Died |
Kula et al. [72] | 2004 | Sepsis | 12.5 L + FB first 96 h (crystalloids) | 29 | CVVH | Died |
Shiiya et al. [103] | 2005 | Surgery | 34.1 L crystalloids vs. 13.7 L blood products | NR | DL | Alive |
Parra et al. [34] | 2006 | Burn/Trauma | 25.55 L of crystalloid 12 U RCC |
34 | DL | Alive |
De Wolf et al. [100] | 2008 | Surgery | Massive fluid resuscitation | 24 in 1st patient 27 in 2nd patient |
DL | Alive |
Tsuang et al. [76] | 2007 | Sepsis | 17 L fluid during first 20 h | 54 | DL | Alive |
Chamisa et al. [64] | 2008 | Trauma | Not reported | >35 | DL | Died |
Kula et al. [73] | 2008 | Trauma | 7.5 L + FB first 48 h. 4:1 (crystalloid: colloid) | 26 | CVVH | NR |
Kula et al. [73] | 2008 | Trauma | 17 L + FB first 96 h. 3:1 (crystalloid: colloid) | 28 | CVVH | NR |
Augustin et al. [90] | 2010 | Surgery | 16 L + FB | 19 | DL | Died |
Augustin et al. [90] | 2010 | Surgery | 23 L + FB | 35 | None | Died |
Rabbi et al. [102] | 2012 | Surgery | Not reported | 50 | DL | Alive |
Park et al. [46] | 2014 | SAP | Not reported | 31 | PCD | Alive |
Bressan et al. [91] | 2016 | Surgery | 4 L crystalloids 2 RCC during first 24 h |
21 | DL | Alive |
Michel et al. [66] | 2016 | Trauma | 10.5 L (crystalloids, colloids & blood products) | NR | DL | Alive |
Lee et al. [45] | 2019 | SAP | 6 L | 28 | DL | Alive |
+ FB: positive fluid balance; NR: not reported; CVVH: continuous veno-venous hemofiltration; NMB: neuromuscular blocker; SAP: severe acute pancreatitis; PCD: Percutaneous Catheter Drainage; DL: decompressive laparotomy; RCC: red cell concentrate.