Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 26;2022(9):CD015048. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD015048.pub2

Chi 2006.

Study characteristics
Methods Retrospective study
Participants Women with stage IIIC epithelial ovarian cancer
The median age at study entry was 60 years (range: 22 to 87)
All women presented with FIGO stage IIIC: 465 (100%)
Tumour cell type: serous 331 (72%), endometrioid: 57 (12%), clear cell: 22 (5%), mixed: 53 (11%)
Tumour grade: 1: 13 (3%), 2: 90 (19%), 3: 339 (73%), unknown: 23 (5%)
Ascites: median 1600 mL (range: 0 to 17,000 mL), presence of ascites (N = 429): no = 58 (14%); yes = 371 (86%)
Residual disease details Type of surgeon: gynaecologic oncologist
Options for residual disease on the standardised operative form were as follows:
  1. NMRD: 67 (14.4%)

  2. Gross residual disease < 0.5 cm: 70 (15.1%)

  3. SVRD of 0.6 cm to 1.0 cm: 99 (21.3%)

  4. LVRD of 1 cm to 2 cm: 53 (11.4%)

  5. LVRD > 2.0 cm: 176 (37.8%)


Optimal is defined in 2 ways as NMRD and SVRD (< 1 cm), suboptimal defined as LVRD (> 1 cm)
Postoperative chemotherapy records were available in 440/465 (95%) women. Of these 440 women, 426 (97%) were treated with primary platinum‐based systemic chemotherapy with the intent to treat with at least 6 cycles.
Outcomes Three women (0.6%) died within 30 days of surgery
Overall survival: HR adjusted for age and ascites using Cox model:
SVRD (< 1 cm) vs NMRD HR 2.07 (95% CI 1.23 to 3.46)
LVRD (> 1 cm) vs NMRD HR 3.70 (95% CI 2.27 to 6.04)
Risk of bias (QUIPS) 1. Study participation (a‐f): low risk
Adequate number of participants and description of target population. Baseline characteristics, eligibility criteria, sampling frame and period/place study took place presented clearly.
2. Study attrition (a‐e): unclear risk
Unclear if patients with incomplete follow‐up were excluded before arriving at the stated sample size. Insufficient information to permit judgement.
3. Prognostic factor measurement (a‐f): low risk
Valid and reliable measurement of RD
Outcome level assessment:
Outcome: overall survival
4. Outcome measurement (a‐c): low risk
Valid and reliable measurement of outcome
5. Adjustment for other prognostic factors (a‐g): unclear risk
HR for OS was adjusted for residual disease, age and ascites in a multivariable Cox model
6. Statistical analysis and reporting (a‐d): high risk
No conceptual framework; unclear of variable selection criteria in multivariate model
Outcome: progression‐free survival
Not reported
Notes Median follow‐up: 38 months (range: 1 to 199 months)
17‐year death rate:
'Optimal' group: 105/236
'Suboptimal' group: 188/229
Median overall survival in relation to the 5 residual disease categories was:
NMRD: 106 months; gross < 0.5 cm: 66 months; 0.6 cm to 1.0 cm: 48 months; 1 cm to 2 cm: 33 months; and > 2 cm: 34 months