Table 1 |.
Model | Type | Species | Method | Strengths | Limitations | Refs |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Published work | ||||||
M-DP-1 | In vivo | Mouse | CRISPR–Cas9-based genome editing Transposon-mediated somatic gene transfer |
In vivo tumour growth Mimics many features of FLC |
Slow tumorigenesis Incomplete penetrance Lacks fibrous bands Lacks molecular features of FLC that are primate-specific |
58 |
M-DP-2 | In vivo | Mouse | CRISPR–Cas9-based genome editing | In vivo tumour growth Mimics many features of FLC |
Slow tumorigenesis Incomplete penetrance Lacks fibrous bands Lacks molecular features of FLC that are primate-specific |
57 |
ZF-DP-1 | In vivo | Zebrafish | Zebrafish DNAJ–PKAc over-expression | In vivo model | Evolutionarily more distant from humans than mice Lacks molecular features specific to mammals and primates |
96 |
PDX-1 | In vivo | Human | Xenograft of patient-derived FLC tumour cells in immune-deficient mice | In vivo tumour growth Mimics most/all major features of FLC Can be maintained stably in spheroid (3D) culture |
Generally, tumour grown in host flank, not liver (non-orthotopic model) Not metastatic from flank |
36 |
PDX-2 to PDX-7 | In vivo | Human | Xenograft of patient-derived FLC tumour cells in immune-deficient mice | In vivo tumour growth Mimics most/all major features of FLC Derived directly from primary Liver tumours and metastases |
Generally, tumour grown in host flank, not liver (non-orthotopic model) Not metastatic from flank |
97 |
HepG2-DP | In vitro | Human | Lentiviral DP over-expression | All human cells Straightforward to culture and manipulate |
No presence of cells from microenvironment Hepatoblastoma background Transformed cells |
33,50 |
C3A-DP | In vitro | Human | LentiviraL DP over-expression | All human cells Straightforward to culture and manipulate |
No presence of cells from microenvironment HCC background Transformed cells |
33 |
AML12-DP | In vitro | Mouse | CRISPR–Cas9-based genome editing | Primary hepatocytes Straightforward to culture and manipulate |
Mouse not human origin Transgenic for human TGFα | 50,76,89 |
Unpublished or preliminary work | ||||||
FLX-1 cell line | In vitro | Human | Cell culture from PDX-1 xenograft model | (Nearly) all human tumour cells Established line that retains molecular features of FLC for multiple passages Amenable to treatment and transfection |
Limited (if any) microenvironmental signalling Relatively slow growth |
N. Bardeesy (personal communication) |
Huh7-DP | In vitro | Human | Lentiviral DP over-expression | All human cells Straightforward to culture and manipulate |
No presence of cells from microenvironment HCC background Transformed cells |
P.S., unpublished work |
HEK293-DP | In vitro | Human | CRISPR– Cas9-based genome editing |
All human cells Straightforward to culture and manipulate |
No presence of cells from microenvironment Non-hepatic background Transformed cells |
95 (a preprint article) |
All of these 16 in vitro and in vivo models currently in use for fibrolamellar carcinoma (FLC) research offer some strengths but also have key limitations, pointing to the critical need for improved models. DP, DNAJB1–PRKACA; HCC, hepatocellular carcinoma; TGFα, transforming growth factor-α.