Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 31;19(17):10860. doi: 10.3390/ijerph191710860

Table 5.

The summary results of Risk of bias assessment as per JBI critical appraisal checklist.

No Authors Country Study Design Sample Size (n) Quality Assessment (%) Risk of Bias Rating
1 Machado et al. [42] Brazil Retrospective Case control 1588 90.0 LOW
2 Zhang et al. [43] China Retrospective Case control 171 90.0 LOW
3 Alam et al. [44] Saudi Arabia Retrospective
Case control
123 80.0 LOW
4 Alam and Alfawzan [19] Saudi Arabia Retrospective
Case control
123 80.0 LOW
5 Wang et al. [45] China Retrospective
Case control
144 60.0 MODERATE
6 Golabbakhsh et al. [46] Iran Retrospective
Case-control
30 80.0 LOW
7 Wang et al. [47] China Retrospective
Case control
110 80.0 LOW
8 Orozco-Arroyave et al. [48] South America Retrospective
Case control
238 80.0 LOW
9 Orozco-Arroyave et al. [40] South America Retrospective
Case control
202 90.0 LOW
10 Mathad et al. [41] South America Retrospective
Case control
326 50.0 HIGH
11 Li et al. [49] China Retrospective 2568 50.0 HIGH
12 Shafi et al. [50] Pakistan Prospective 1000 70.0 LOW