Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 21;16(1):124–138. doi: 10.14444/8181

Table 2.

Methodological quality evaluation.

Authors Design Representatives of Exposed Cohort Selection of Nonexposed Cohort Ascertainment of Exposure Assesment of Outcome Length Follow-Up
Hellinger S et al22 ●● ●●
Tacconi L et al13 ●● ●●
Kyung-Hoon K et al14
Hahn P et al23* ●●
Heo DH et al24 ●●
Siu CK et al25 ●● ●●
Oertel JM et al26 ●● ●●
Bruder M et al27 ●● ●●
Denis DR et al2 ●● ●●
Birch BD et al28
Eshraghi Y et al7
Zhenbo Z et al29 ●● ●●
Alimi M et al30 ●● ●● ●●●
Sukkarieh HG et al31 ●● ●●
Knafo S et al32
Komp M et al33 ●● ●● ●●●
Ortiz O et al51
Cambron SC et al11 ●● ●●
Ganau M et al3
Ha SW et al35 ●●
James A et al36 ●●
Amoretti N et al11 ●● ●● ●●
Landi A et al37 ●●
Schulz M et al16
El Shazly A et al38
Matsumoto M et al39
Xu R et al40 ●● ●●
Allen TL et al10 ●● ●●●
Martha JF et al9 ●●
Terao T et al41
Weiner BK et al39 ●●
Sehati N et al43 ●●
Acharya R et al1
Metellus P et al44 ●●
Deinsberger R et al15
Sandhu FA et al45 ●●
Epstein NE et al46 ●● ●●
Pirotte B et al47
Bureau NJ et al12
Salmon B et al48
Banning CS et al46
Trummer M et al49
Lyons MK et al50 ●●

Design: One dot for prospective or randomized controlled trials. Representatives of exposed cohort: One dot for study reporting detailed inclusion criteria, two dots for studies reporting detailed inclusion and exclusion criteria. Selection of non-exposed cohort: One dot for each study reporting a control group. Ascertainment of exposure: One dot for the authors confirming the intraoperative presence of a JFC, two dots if the histological confirmation was reported and an accurate JFC description provided. Assesment of outcome: One dot for each different clinical score utilized by authors for measuring postoperative outcomes. Length of follow-up: One dot if the follow-up was more than 24 months.