Table 3.
Study | Year of publication/country | Population and sample size | Study design | Pesticides assessed | Exposure assessment method | Pesticide or metabolite concentrations | Health effect and assessment method/instrument | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Studies on OCs | ||||||||
Studies in children | ||||||||
1. Torres-Sánchez et al.107 | 2007/Mexico | 244 mother–child (0–12 months of age) pairs from malaria-endemic zone | Prospective cohort | OCs | Maternal serum DDE before and during each trimester of pregnancy |
(): -DDE: ; ; |
Neurodevelopment: mental and psychomotor development (BSID-II) | Higher DDE during first trimester of pregnancy was associated with lower PDI scores in first year of life ( per 2-fold increase in ; 95% CI: , ). Null associations between DDE and MDI scores. |
2. Torres-Sánchez et al.108 | 2009/Mexico | 270 mother–child (12–30 months of age) pairs | Prospective cohort | OCs | Maternal serum DDE during each trimester of pregnancy |
(): -DDE: ; ; ; -DDT: ; ; |
Neurodevelopment: mental and psychomotor development (BSID-II) | Null associations of prenatal DDE with PDI and MDI scores. |
3. Bahena-Medina et al.109 | 2011/Mexico | 265 mother–child (1 month of age) pairs | Prospective cohort | OCs | Maternal serum DDE during each trimester of pregnancy |
DDE (): First trimester: ; ; ; ; ; ; Second trimester: ; ; ; ; ; Third trimester: ; ; ; ; ; |
Neurodevelopment: neonatal reflexes (NBAS), neurological soft signs (Graham-Rosenblith scale), mental and psychomotor development (BSID) | Null associations between prenatal DDE exposure and neonatal neurodevelopment. |
4. Dallaire et al.110 | 2012/Guadeloupe | 153 mother–child (7 months of age) pairs living near banana plantations | Prospective cohort | OCs (chlordecone) | Questionnaire (infant dietary intake history) Cord blood chlordecone Breast milk chlordecone at 3 months |
chlordecone (): ; |
Neurodevelopment: visual recognition, memory, and processing speed (FTII, TAC, Brunet-Lezine scale) | Those in the highest tertile of cord blood chlordecone concentrations (classified as ) scored lower on the novelty preference test (; 95% CI: , 0) than those in the second tertile of cord chlordecone concentrations (classified as and ) (; 95% CI: , 0.1). Detectable concentrations of chlordecone in cord blood were associated with increased odds of low fine motor scores (; 95% CI: 1.1, 1.5). |
5. Boucher et al.111 | 2013/Guadeloupe | 141 mother–child (18 months of age) pairs living near banana plantations | Prospective cohort | OCs (chlordecone) | Questionnaire (infant dietary intake history) Cord blood chlordecone Breast milk chlordecone at 3 months |
chlordecone (): ; |
Neurodevelopment: personal–social, communication, problem-solving, fine motor, and gross motor (ASQ-19) | Higher chlordecone concentrations in cord blood were associated with lower fine motor scores among boys (; ). |
6. Torres-Sánchez et al.112 | 2013/Mexico | 203 mother–child (42–60 months of age) pairs | Prospective cohort | OCs | Maternal serum DDE during each trimester of pregnancy | Median (P10–P90) ( lipid): DDE: ; ; ; DDT: ; ; |
Neurodevelopment: verbal, perceptual performance, quantitative, memory, motor skills, and general cognitive index (MSCA) | Higher DDE during third trimester of pregnancy was associated with poorer verbal ( per 2-fold increase in ; 95% CI: , ), quantitative (; 95% CI: , ), and memory (; 95% CI: , ) skills and a poorer general cognitive index (; 95% CI: , ) at 42–60 months of age. |
7. Osorio-Valencia et al.113 | 2015/Mexico | 167 mother–child (60 months of age) pairs | Prospective cohort | OCs | Maternal serum DDE during each trimester of pregnancy |
-DDE ( lipid): First trimester: ; ; second trimester: ; ; third trimester: ; |
Neurodevelopment: lateralization and spatial orientation (MSCA) | Higher DDE during second trimester of pregnancy was associated with poorer spatial orientation ( per 2-fold increase in ; 95% CI: , 0.04). |
8. Campos et al.118 | 2015/Brazil | 46 children (6–16 years of age) | Cross-sectional | OCs | Child serum HCH, HCB, DDE, DDT, endosulfan, aldrin, endrin, dieldrin, methoxychlor, and mirex | Median (range) (): ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; |
Neurodevelopment: cognitive function (WISC-III) | Higher was associated with poorer performance IQ ( per increase ; 95% CI: , 0), resistance to distraction (; 95% CI: , 0), and processing speed (; 95% , ). Higher was associated with poorer resistance to distraction (; 95% , ) and processing speed (; 95% , 0). Higher -DDT was associated with poorer processing speed (; 95% , ). |
9. Cordier et al.117 | 2015/Guadeloupea | 75 mother–child (18 months of age) pairs | Prospective cohort | OCs | Cord blood and breast milk chlordecone, cord blood DDE | Median (P25–P75) () in entire study population (111 mother–child pairs): ; cord blood ; |
Neurodevelopment: personal–social, communication, problem-solving, fine motor, and gross motor (ASQ-19) | Association between cord chlordecone and fine motor scores among boys (reported by Boucher et al.111) was not mediated by TSH. |
10. Ogaz-Gonzales et al.114 | 2018/Mexico | 142 mother–child (42–60 months of age) pairs | Prospective cohort | OCs | Questionnaire (pesticide use history) Maternal serum DDE during first and third trimester of pregnancy |
Mean (P10–P90) DDE (): |
Neurodevelopment: verbal, perceptual performance, quantitative, memory, motor skills, and general cognitive index (MSCA) | Higher third-trimester maternal DDE was associated with lower motor development in children whose mothers had lower intake of DHA (an omega-3 fatty acid) ( per 2-fold increase in ; 95% CI: , 0.1), but not in children whose mothers had a higher DHA intake. Higher maternal DDE was associated with poorer memory skills in children whose mothers had lower ARA (an omega-6 fatty acid) intake ( per 2-fold increase in ; 95% CI: , ) but not in children whose mothers had a higher ARA intake. |
11. Saint-Amour et al.115 | 2020/Guadeloupe | 285 mother–child (7–8 years of age) pairs | Prospective cohort | OCs (chlordecone) | Cord blood and child (7 years of age) blood chlordecone | Median (range) chlordecone (): ; |
Neurodevelopment: visual contrast sensitivity (FrACT) | Higher cord plasma chlordecone (continuous) was associated with lower scores (; 95% CI: , 0). Child chlordecone (continuous) was associated with lower scores among boys (; 95% CI: , 0). |
12. Cordier et al.116 | 2020/Guadeloupe | 116 mother–child (7 years of age) pairs | Prospective cohort | OCs (chlordecone) | Cord blood and child (7 years of age) blood chlordecone | Median (range) chlordecone (): ; |
Neurodevelopment: sex-typed play behavior (feminine, masculine, or neutral play reported as a proportion of the complete playing time) | Null associations of cord blood and child chlordecone with sex-typed play behavior. |
Studies in adults | ||||||||
13. Steenland et al.119 | 2014/Costa Rica | 89 adults from historically (and now partially) agricultural area | Cross-sectional | OCs | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) Serum HCH, DDE, DDT, and dieldrin |
(): Past occupational pesticides exposure: ; ; ; No past occupational pesticides exposure: ; ; ; |
Neurodegeneration: spatial and temporal orientation, short-term memory, attention, calculation, language, praxis (MMSE); tremor-at-rest (UPDRS) | Null associations of serum OC (parent compounds or metabolites) with MMSE and tremor-at-rest. |
Studies on OPs or CBs | ||||||||
Studies in children | ||||||||
14. Handal et al.130 | 2007/Ecuador | 142 children (24–61 months of age) from 2 communities with industrial flower farms and from a community with local agriculture and crops for food | Cross-sectional | CBs, OPs | Questionnaire (parental occupational and residential exposure history, child outdoor activities) | Not applicable | Neurodevelopment: communication, fine motor, gross motor, problem-solving, personal–social (ASQ), visual–motor skills (Beery-Buktenica VMI developmental test) | Maternal employment in the flower industry at time of child assessment was associated with improved communication (; 95% CI: , 8.5) and problem-solving (; 95% CI: 0.7, 9.4) skills. Pesticide use on domestic crops was also associated with better gross motor (; 95% CI: 0.6, 9.2) and personal–social (; 95% CI: , 9.0) scores, whereas pesticide use within the home was associated with lower communication scores (; 95% CI: , ). Children who played with irrigation water had lower fine motor (; 95% CI: , ) and problem-solving (; 95% CI: , ) scores. |
15. Handal et al.121 | 2007/Ecuador | 154 children (3–61 months of age) from 2 communities with industrial flower farms/129 children from a community with local agriculture and crops for food | Cross-sectional | CBs, OPs | Questionnaire (parental occupational and residential exposure history) | Not applicable | Neurodevelopment: communication, fine motor, gross motor, problem solving, personal–social (ASQ) | Children 3–23 months of age from industrial flower farms communities had lower gross motor (, ), fine motor (, ), and socioindividual (, ) scores compared with children from a local agriculture community. Children 24–61 months of age from industrial flower farms communities had lower gross motor scores compared with children of similar ages from a local agriculture community (, ). |
16. Handal et al.120 | 2008/Ecuador | 121 children (3–23 months of age) from 2 communities with industrial flower farms and from a community with local agriculture and crops for food | Cross-sectional | CBs, OPs | Questionnaire (maternal occupational exposure history during pregnancy) | Not applicable | Neurodevelopment: communication, fine motor, gross motor, problem solving, personal–social (ASQ), prehension and visual acuity (targeted development tests) | Children whose mothers worked as floriculturists during pregnancy had lower communication (; 95% CI: , 0.3) and fine motor ; 95% CI: , ) scores and had an increased risk of poor visual acuity (; 95% CI: 1.1, 20) than children whose mothers did not. |
17. Harari et al.123 | 2010/Ecuador | 84 children (6–8 years of age) living in a floricultural area | Cross-sectional | OPs | Questionnaire (parental occupational and residential exposure history) Urinary DAPsb Blood AChEb |
Not applicable | Neurodevelopment: simple motor speed (finger tapping task), motor coordination (Santa Ana Form Board), attention (CPT), short-term auditory memory (WISC and Stanford-Binet), visual performance (Raven’s test and Stanford-Binet copying test), visual memory (Stanford-Binet copying recall test) | Children whose mothers were exposed to pesticides during pregnancy showed poorer motor speed (; 95% CI: , ), motor coordination (; 95% CI: 1.03, 27.6), visual performance (Raven’s test: ; 95% CI: 0.2, 1.0), and visual memory (; 95% CI: 1.02, 42.9) compared with children of unexposed mothers. Children whose fathers were exposed to pesticides during pregnancy showed poorer visual memory (; 95% CI: 1.8, 101.9) than children of unexposed fathers. Children with current exposure (i.e., at least one detectable urinary DAP metabolite) had longer reaction times compared with children with no exposure (; 95% CI: , 141.7). |
18. Muñoz-Quesada et al.127 | 2011/Chile | 25 children (6–11 years of age) from rural communities | Cross-sectional | OPs | Child urinary DAPs | Geometric mean (range) (): ; ; |
Neurodevelopment: cognitive function (WISC-III) | Negative association between urinary DMTP and processing speed (, ). Null associations of other DAP metabolites and WISC-III outcomes. |
19. Martos-Mula et al.129 | 2013/Argentina | 42 children (7–10 years of age) living in an agricultural area/29 children living in a nonagricultural area | Cross-sectional | OPs, CBs | Questionnaire Blood AChE, BChE |
Not applicable | Neurodevelopment: associative memory (Digit and Symbol subtest), short-term memory (Digit Memory test), maze test (motor, visuospatial processing), cognitive function (WISC-III), gross motor and balance tests | Children living in an agricultural area had poorer motor function and visuospatial processing than children living in a nonagricultural area (). Null associations between enzyme activities and neurodevelopmental outcomes. |
20. Suarez-Lopez et al.122 | 2013/Ecuador | 307 children (4–9 years of age) living in floricultural communities | Cross-sectional | OPs | Questionnaire (parental occupational and residential exposure history) Blood AChE |
Not applicable | Neurodevelopment: attention and inhibitory control, language, memory and learning, sensorimotor, visuospatial processing (NEPSY-II) | Boys, but not girls, in the highest tertile of AChE activity had increased odds of poor neurodevelopment ( 9th percentile) than boys in the lowest tertile (total neurodevelopment ; 95% CI: 0.8, 31.5; attention/executive functioning ; 95% CI: 1.2, 17.4); memory/learning ; 95% CI: 1.2, 31.1). |
21. Fortenberry et al.128 | 2014/Mexico | 187 mother–child (6–11 years of age) pairs | Prospective cohort | OPs (chlorpyrifos) | Maternal urinary TCPy during third trimester of pregnancy | Geometric mean (P10–P90) TCPy (): 1.76 (0.45–6.40) | Neurodevelopment: attention and hyperactivity (CRS-R, CPT, BASC-2) | Increased ADHD index for the highest TCPy tertile compared with the lowest tertile for boys (; 95% CI: , 11.3). Increased attention problems for the middle TCPy tertile compared with the lowest tertile for girls (; 95% CI: , 12.4). |
22. Suarez-Lopez et al.126 | 2017/Ecuador | 308 children (4–9 years of age) living in floricultural communities | Cross-sectional | OPs | Questionnaire (parental occupational and residential exposure history) Blood AChE |
Not applicable | Neurodevelopment: attention and inhibitory control, language, memory and learning, sensorimotor, visuospatial processing (NEPSY-II) | Children examined sooner after Mother’s Day had lower attention/inhibitory control (score difference per 10.8 d ; 95% CI. 0.10, 0.7), visuospatial processing (0.6; 95% CI: 0.3, 0.9), and sensorimotor (0.4; 95% CI: 0.1, 0.8) scores than children examined later. Further adjustment for AChE activity had overall a small effect on most associations but strengthened associations in the attention and inhibitory control domain by about 16%. |
23. Suarez-Lopez et al.124 | 2019/Ecuador | 529 adolescents (11–17 years of age) living in floricultural communities | Cross-sectional | OPs | Blood AChE | Not applicable | Mental health disorders: anxiety (MASC-2) and depression symptoms (CDI-2) | Lower AChE activity was associated with more depression symptoms ( per SD decrease in AChE ; 95% CI: 0, 2.2). Associations were stronger among girls (; 95% CI: 0.1, 3.1) than boys (; 95% CI: , 2.3) and among younger (; 95% CI: , 3.4) than older children (; 95% CI: , 2.0). No associations were observed with anxiety scores. |
24. Suarez-Lopez et al.125 | 2021/Ecuador | 300 adolescents (11–17 years of age) living in floricultural communities | Cross-sectional | OPs | Blood AChE | Not applicable | Mental health disorders: anxiety (MASC-2) and depression symptoms (CDI-2) | Lower AChE activity was associated with more depression symptoms ( per 10% decrease in AChE ; 95% CI: 0, 1.9) and increased odds of an elevated depression score (; 95% CI: 1.0, 2.7). These associations were stronger among girls than boys. Adjustment for cortisol, testosterone and dehydroepiandrosterone reduced gender differences by 18%–62%. |
Studies in adults | ||||||||
25. Wesseling et al.136 | 2010/Costa Rica | 78 male banana farmworkers with poisoning/130 non-poisoned workers from company payrolls | Cross-sectional | OPs, CBs | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history, history of OP pesticide poisoning) Blood AChEb |
Not applicable | Mental health disorders: psychological distress and suicidal ideation (BSI) | Farmworkers with history of OP pesticide poisonings had increased odds of somatization (; 95% CI:1.6, 6.0), obsessive-compulsiveness (; 95% CI:1.6, 6.2), interpersonal sensitivity (; 95% CI:1.5, 5.8), depression (; 95% CI: 1.3, 4.7), hostility (; 95% CI: 1.1, 4.6), anxiety (; 95% CI:1 1.4, 4.4), phobia (; 95% CI: 1.0, 3.6), and psychoticism (; 95% CI: 1.1, 4.3). Individuals with history of OP pesticide poisonings had increased odds of having suicidal thoughts in the previous month (; 95% CI: 1.5, 8.8), with increasing risk for those with more poisonings (; 95% CI: 1.7, 14.5). Farmworkers with history of CB pesticide poisonings had increased odds of somatization (; 95% CI: 1.1, 6.2). |
26. Muñoz-Quezada et al.132 | 2016/Chile | 93 farmworkers/84 controls | Cross-sectional | OPs | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) | Not applicable | Neurobehavioral performance: cognitive function (WAIS-IV), visuospatial memory and visual perception (ROCF), visual memory and visuoconstruction skills (BVRT), neurological alterations with frontal involvement (MMSE), and motor performance | Farmworkers had lower WAIS-IV verbal comprehension (; 95% CI: , ), processing speed (; 95% CI: , ), and total IQ (; 95% CI: , ) scores than controls. Farmworkers also had lower MMSE scores (; 95% CI: , ) and poorer discrimination sensitivity (; 95% CI: 0.2, 1.2) and deep reflexes (; 95% CI: 0.0, 2.2) than controls. |
27. Corral et al.131 | 2017/Chile | 32 farmworkers/32 individuals living in agricultural communities/38 controls | Cross-sectional | OPs | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) | Not applicable | Neurobehavioral performance: spatial and temporal orientation, short-term memory, attention, calculation, language, praxis (MMSE), memory and attention (WAIS-R DST), visuoconstruction skills and visual memory (ROCF), divided attention and resistance to interference (Stroop), attention (d2), executive function (FAB), and verbal fluency (Barcelona for Animals and Letter P) | Both farmworkers and people living in agricultural communities had increased odds of poorer (i.e., below cutoff value) executive function (; 95% CI: 5.6, 359.7 and ; 95% CI: 1.7, 32.4, respectively), memory and attention (DST forward: ; 95% CI: 1.6, 14.9, and DST backward: ; 95% CI: 2.4, 22.4; DST forward: ; 95% CI: 1.4, 13.8, and DST backward: ; 95% CI: 1.02, 8.3, respectively), and verbal fluency (animals: ; 95% CI: 1.3, 25.6, and Letter P: ; 95% CI: 4.3, 64.6; animals: ; 95% CI: 1.04, 19.4, and Letter P: ; 95% CI: 2.1, 31.3, respectively) than the unexposed group. |
28. Grillo Pizarro et al.135 | 2018/Chile | 55 farmworkers/58 unexposed controls | Cross-sectional | OPs | Questionnaire (occupational and residential exposure history) | Not applicable | Peripheric polyneuropathy | Farmworkers exposed to OP pesticides had increased odds of peripheric polyneuropathy compared with controls (; 95% CI: 1.2, 10.5) |
29. Serrano-Medina et al.137 | 2019/Mexico | 140 farmworkers/100 controls | Cross-sectional | OPs | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) Blood AChE |
Not applicable | Mental health disorders: neuropsychiatric disorders (MINI based on DSM-IV) | Farm work was associated with increased odds of suicide (; 95% CI: 2.4, 11.9), whereas higher AChE activity levels were associated with decreased odds of suicide (, ). |
30. Buralli et al.138 | 2020/Brazilc | 42 pesticide applicators/36 farmworkers who did not apply pesticides | Cross-sectional | OPs | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) Blood AChE, BChEb |
Not applicable | CMD (SRQ-20) | Farmworkers who did not spray pesticides had a higher probability of feeling easily tired (; 95% CI: 1.3, 7.7) and worthless (; 95% CI: 1.7, 31.0) compared with pesticide applicators. |
31. Ramírez-Santana et al.134 | 2020/Chile | 87 adults occupationally exposed (OE)/81 environmentally exposed (EE)/100 unexposed controls (RG) | Cross-sectional | OPs, CBs | Questionnaire (occupational and residential exposure history) Blood AChE, BChE, APEH |
Not applicable | Neurobehavioral performance at one (RG) or two (OE and EE) time points: general mental status (MMSE), memory (WMS III, Digit span forward, ROCF memory, 1036 A-B and A-B recall), language (WAIS subtest vocabulary), constructive praxis (ROCF copy, WAIS subtest block design), executive function (Tower of London movements and time resolution tests, WCST perseverative errors, Barcelona test categorical evocation animals and words), attention (WAIS digit span backward, d2 test, Stroop word–color and inhibitory control tests, Trail Making Test A, WAIS symbols), Psychomotricity (Purdue pegboard test, MOART reaction time, MOART finger tapping test), Mood (BDI-II depression inventory, Hamilton anxiety scale) | Both exposure groups (OE and EE) had poorer executive function (Tower of London time, WCST perseverative errors), psychomotricity [MOART reaction time (right and left hand)], and mood (BDI-II depression inventory, Hamilton anxiety scale) than the RG. Seasonal exposure impaired performance in both exposure groups on all tests except those related to attention and mood. During the spray season, BChE activity was associated with decreased scores on tests of logical, auditory, and visual memory; inhibitory control of cognitive interference; constructional and planning abilities; executive function; and motor speed and coordination among those in the EE group. Weaker associations were observed for AChE levels and tests of logical memory, constructional abilities, and fine motor coordination in the EE group. In the OE group, levels of the three biomarkers were associated with worse performance on tests of inhibitory control of cognitive interference (2 tests with AChE, 2 tests with BChE, and 1 test for APEH); results were only significant for AChE. |
32. Ramírez-Santana et al.133 | 2020/Chile | 78 adults occupationally exposed (OE)/78 environmentally exposed (EE) | Cross-sectional | OPs, CBs | Questionnaire (occupational and residential exposure history) Blood AChE, BChE |
Not applicable | Changes in neurobehavioral performance from prespray to spraying season in OE and EE: General mental status (MMSE), memory (WMS III, Digit span forward, ROCF memory, 10/36 SRT A-B and A-B recall), language (WAIS subtest vocabulary), constructive praxis (ROCF copy, WAIS subtest block design), executive function (Tower of London movements and time resolution tests, WCST perseverative errors, Barcelona test categorical evocation animals and words), attention (WAIS digit span backward, d2 test, Stroop word–color and inhibitory control tests, Trail Making Test A, WAIS symbols), Psychomotricity (Purdue pegboard test, MOART reaction time, MOART finger tapping test), Mood (BDI-II depression inventory, Hamilton anxiety scale) | AChE inhibition was associated with worse performance on tests of attention (Stroop word–color and inhibitory control test, Trail Making A test) in the EE group and worse performance on tests of memory (WMS) and attention (Trail Making A test) in the OE group. BChE inhibition was associated with worse performance on tests of general mental status (MMSE), memory (WMS III-I, WMS III-II, Digit span forward, 10/36 SRT-A, 10/36 SRT-B, 10/36 SRT-A recall, 10/36 SRT-B recall), language (WAIS), attention (Stroop word–color and inhibitory control tests), executive function (Tower of London movements, WCST perseverative errors, Barcelona tests animals) in the EE group and worse performance on a test of attention (Stroop word–color test) in the OE group. |
Studies on other pesticides or multiple pesticide classes | ||||||||
Studies in children | ||||||||
33. Eckerman et al.143 | 2007/Brazil | 38 adolescents (10–18 years of age) from rural areas/28 adolescents from urban areas | Cross-sectional | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (exposure index based on 86 occupational history questions plus number of hours worked per day applying chemical plus number of years worked) | Not applicable | Neurobehavioral: BARS (CPT, MTS, DST, PRT, RTT, SAT, SDL, SDT, TAP) | Compared with adolescents from rural areas, adolescents from urban areas performed better on tests of response speed and coordination (TAP_NP), attention and working memory (DS-F), and complex function (SD_LAT), but worse on a cognition test (SDL) (). Among the youngest age group (10–11 y), rural participants had poorer mean scores in tests of response time and coordination (TAP_P, TAP_NP, TAP_ALT), motivation (PRT), attention and working memory (DS-F; CPT_HLAT; SAT_LAT), reaction time (RT_ALL), complex function (SDT_LAT), and visual memory and delay (MTS_LAT) ( for each) than urban participants. |
34. Lu et al.139 | 2009/Costa Rica | 18 children (4–10 years of age) of conventional coffee farmworkers/17 children of organic coffee farmworkers | Cross-sectional | OPs, herbicides, pyrethroids | Child urinary 2,4-D, TCPy, 3-PBA, and IMPY |
(): La Amistad: 2, ; ; ; ; Las Mellizas: ; ; ; ; |
Neurodevelopment: cognition (BARS, figure-drawing task, long-term memory test) | Null associations between urinary pesticide metabolites and neurodevelopmental outcomes. |
35. van Wendel et al.140 | 2016/Costa Rica | 140 rural children (6–9 years of age) living near banana and plantain plantations | Cross-sectional | Mn-containing fungicides, OPs, pyrethroids | Questionnaire (parental occupational exposure history) Child urinary TCPy, ETU, and 3-PBA |
Median (P25–P75) (): ; ; |
Neurodevelopment: cognitive function (WISC-IV), behavioral problems (CPRS-R), visual sensory function (LDD-15), visuospatial construction and visual memory (ROCF), verbal memory and learning abilities (CAVLT-2), visual–motor coordination (DTVP-2), fine motor function (WRAVMA), and attention (RTT) | Higher TCPy was associated with poorer working memory in boys ( per 10-fold increase in ; 95% CI: , ) and poorer visual–motor coordination (; 95% CI: , ); oppositional disorders (; 95% CI: 1.8, 28.6) and decreased ability to discriminate colors (; 95% CI: 1.6, 30.3) in boys and girls combined. Higher was associated with poorer verbal learning outcomes (; 95% CI: , ). Higher 3-PBA was associated with poorer processing speed scores, particularly in girls (; 95% CI: , ). |
36. Watkins et al.142 | 2016/Mexico | 187 mother–child (2–3 years of age) pairs | Prospective cohort | Pyrethroids | Maternal urinary 3-PBA during third trimester of pregnancy | 3-PBA (): 0.26 | Neurodevelopment: cognitive, language, personal–social, fine and gross motor development (BSID-II) | Children whose mothers had medium and high 3-PBA during pregnancy had lower MDI scores at 24 months than children whose mothers had low 3-PBA (; 95% CI: , 0.8 and ; 95% CI: , 0.8, respectively). Null associations of prenatal 3-PBA with PDI scores at 24 or 36 months. |
37. Mora et al.141 | 2018/Costa Rica | 355 mother–child (1 year of age) pairs living near banana plantations aerially sprayed | Prospective cohort | Mn-containing fungicides | Maternal urinary ETU, blood Mn, and hair Mn during pregnancy |
(): ; ; |
Neurodevelopment: cognition, motor function, language, and social–emotional development (BSID-III) | Girls whose mothers had higher urinary ETU during pregnancy had lower social–emotional scores ( per 10-fold points; 95% CI: , 0.4), whereas those whose mothers had higher hair Mn during pregnancy had lower cognitive scores ( per 10-fold points; 95% CI: , 0.1). Among boys, higher hair Mn during pregnancy was associated with lower social–emotional scores ( per 10-fold points; 95% CI: , ). Null associations for blood Mn, language, and motor outcomes. |
38. Christian et al.145 | 2018/Jamaica | 298 children (2–8 years of age) with ASD/298 controls without ASD | Case–control | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (maternal exposure history) | Not applicable | ASD (ADOS, ADI-R) | Maternal exposure to pesticides from 3 months before pregnancy to end of breastfeeding was associated with increased risk of ASD (; 95% CI: 1.1, 2.6), with some evidence of effect modification by exposure to oil-based paints and paint solvents. |
39. Friedman et al.144 | 2020/Ecuador | 307 children (4–9 years of age) living in floricultural communities | Cross-sectional | Multiple pesticide classes | Proximity to floricultural crops | Not applicable | Neurodevelopment: attention and inhibitory control, language, memory and learning, sensorimotor, visuospatial processing (NEPSY-II) | For every 100 m closer in proximity to treated floricultural crops, participants had increased odds of low memory/learning (; 95% CI: 1.1, 1.5) and language (; 95% CI: 1.0, 1.2) scores. Compared with those living from crops, those living within of crops had lower language (; 95% CI: , ), attention/inhibitory control (, 95% CI: , ), and memory/learning (; 95% CI: , 0.2) scores. |
Studies in adults | ||||||||
40. Araújo et al.159 | 2007/Brazilc | 102 farmworkers | Cross-sectional | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) Blood AChE |
Not applicable | Neurological symptoms (neurological examination and perception of neurological symptoms) | Null association between inhibition of AChE activity and intoxication symptoms. |
41. Steenland et al.146 | 2013/Costa Rica | 400 adults years of age from historically (and now partially) agricultural area | Cross-sectional | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) | Not applicable | Neurodegeneration: spatial and temporal orientation, short-term memory, attention, calculation, language, praxis (MMSE); PD risk (UPDRS) | Exposed subjects performed worse on the MMSE than the nonexposed (), had increased odds of abnormal scores on two UPDRS items (tremor-at-rest ; 95% CI: 1.3–5.2 and finger tapping ; 95% CI: 1.03, 8.4), and had an increased risk of PD (; 95% CI: 0.9, 7.3). |
42. Faria et al.152 | 2014/Brazil | 2,400 tobacco farmworkers | Cross-sectional | Fungicides, herbicides, neonicotinoids, OPs, pyrethroids | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) | Not applicable | Mental health disorders: MPD (SRQ-20) | Increased risk of MPD among those who entered the treated area following application (; 95% CI: 1.3, 2.2) and those who had contact through clothes wet from pesticides (; 95% CI: 1.1, 1.7). Workers from farms in which OPs were used had an increased risk of MPD compared with those who were not exposed (; 95% CI: 1.2, 1.9). Number of poisonings was positively associated with risk of MDP (PR for 1 ; 95% CI: 1.1, 2.2; PR for 2 ; 95% CI: 1.8, 3.4). |
43. Portilla-Portilla et al.155 | 2014/Colombia | 49 adults from a rural area | Cross-sectional | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (occupational and environmental history of exposure to neurotoxic pesticides) | Not applicable | Neurological symptoms (self-reported) | Participants with pesticide exposure had increased odds of irritability (; 95% CI: 1.1, 2.8), dizziness (; 95% CI: 1.1, 4.9), phosphenes (; 95% CI: 1.0, 6.6), epistaxis (; 95% CI: 1.0, 8.3), and fasciculations (; 95% CI: 1.1, 66.9). |
44. Campos et al.149 | 2016/Brazil | 869 adults from a rural population | Cross-sectional | Herbicides, natural pesticides, OPs, OCs, pyrethroids | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) | Not applicable | Mental health disorders: MPD (SRQ-20) and depression (self-reported) | Ever feeling ill after a pesticide application was associated with common mental disorders (; 95% CI: 1.6, 4.3) and self-reported depression (; 95% CI: 1.6, 4.2). Age at onset of pesticide exposure y (; 95% CI: 1.7, 2.8), exposure to pyrethroids (; 95% CI: 1.0, 3.2) and aliphatic alcohol (; 95% CI: 1.04, 3.8), and greater period of exposure to dinitroaniline (; 95% CI: 1.0, 4.7) and sulfonyl urea (; 95% CI: 1.1, 23.0) were associated with self-reported depression. |
45. Azevedo and Meyer158 | 2017/Brazil | 51 endemic disease control agents with essential tremor/204 endemic disease control agents with no tremor (controls) | Case–control | Larvicides, OCs, OPs, pyrethroids | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) | Not applicable | Neurodegeneration: essential tremor | Null association of cumulative pesticide exposure load (calculated by multiplying years of application, frequency of application, and hours worked per day) with essential tremor. Workers who had applied pesticides for 16–16.9 y had increased odds of essential tremor compared with workers who had applied pesticides for y (; 95% CI: 1.3, 18.0). |
46. Hansen et al.147 | 2017/Bolivia | 120 male endemic disease control agents | Cross-sectional | Pyrethroids | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) | Not applicable | Neurobehavioral performance: hand tremor, postural balance, vocabulary (BNT), audiovisual reaction (RTT), cognition (BARS), visual attention (CPT), complex cognitive function (SDT), attention and memory (DST, SDL), and visual memory (MTS) | Higher pesticide spraying intensity was associated with increased odds of poor postural balance among those exposed to pyrethroids (OR per 1-quintile increase in ; 95% CI: 1.1, 13.6). Higher spraying intensity was also associated with worse neurocognitive performance ( per 1-quintile increase for all ; 95% CI: , and for workers exposed to pyrethroids ; 95% CI: , ). Cumulative pesticide exposure was associated with worse neurocognitive performance ( per 1-quintile increase for all ; 95% CI: , and for workers exposed to pyrethroids ; 95% CI: , ). |
47. Conti et al.148 | 2018/Brazil | 220 male farmworkers | Cross-sectional | Glyphosate, fungicides, neonicotinoids | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) | Not applicable | Mental health disorders: depression (BDI-II) | Pesticide exposure was associated with increased odds of more severe depressive symptoms (; 95% CI: 1.2, 25.9). |
48. Palzes et al.160 | 2019/Costa Rica | 48 farmworkers | Cross-sectional | Mn-containing fungicides | Hair and toenail Mn |
() Mn: ; |
Cortical brain activity (fNIRS) | Null association of hair and toenail Mn concentrations with brain activity during working memory task. |
49. Conti et al.150 | 2020/Brazil | 288 adults from a rural area | Cross-sectional | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (pesticide exposure in general, did not distinguish between residential and occupational) | Not applicable | Mental health disorders: depression (BDI-II) | Pesticide use was associated with increased odds of depression (, ). |
50. Vasconcellos et al.156 | 2020/Brazil | 32 participants with PD | Cross-sectional | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history) | Not applicable | PD | 78% of patients with PD had worked in agriculture and 75% had contact with pesticides. |
51. Silvestre et al.157 | 2020/Brazil | 88 PD cases/264 controls | Case–control | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (occupational and environmental exposure history) | Not applicable | PD | Pesticide use at work was associated with increased odds of PD (; 95% CI: 1.6, 7.6). |
52. Cruzeiro Szortyka et al.153 | 2021/Brazil | 2,469 tobacco growers | Cross-sectional | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history, history of APP, pesticide-related work tasks) | Not applicable | Mental health disorders: suicidal ideation (SRQ), suicide attempts (self-reported) | Performing between 6 and 9 pesticide-related tasks (; 95% CI: 1.0, 3.3) and history of APP (; 95% CI: 1.2, 4.7) were associated with increased prevalence of suicidal ideation. |
53. Gonzaga et al.154 | 2021/Brazil | 547 farmworkers (311 occupationally exposed/236 following agroecological practices) | Cross-sectional | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history, history of APP) | Not applicable | Mental health disorders: suicidal ideation (SRQ-20) | Occupational pesticide exposure (; 95% CI: 1.2, 4.6) and history of APP (; 95% CI: 3.0, 24.7) were associated with increased odds of suicidal ideation. |
54. Farnham et al.151 | 2021/Costa Rica | 300 farmworkers | Cross-sectional | Multiple pesticide classes | Questionnaire (occupational exposure history, history of APP) | Not applicable | Neurological symptoms Mental health disorders: psychological distress and suicidal ideation (BSI) |
Self-reported APP was associated with fainting (; 95% CI: 1.8, 30.7), shaking hands (; 95% CI: 1.6, 7.6), numbness/tingling in hands or feed (; 95% CI: 1.7, 6.3), insomnia (, 95 % CI: 1.3, 4.8), accelerated heartrate (; 95% CI: 1.0, 5.5), dizziness (; 95% CI: 1.2, 4.7), increased irritability/anger (; 95% CI: 1.2, 4.6), low energy (; 95% CI: 1.2, 4.5), and difficulty concentrating (; 95% CI: 1.1, 3.9) during the 12 months prior to the interview. Farmworkers who reported an APP in the 10 y prior to the interview experienced increased odds of hostility (; 95% CI: 1.2, 17.7) and paranoid ideation (; 95% CI: 1.0, 18.2). |
Note: %change, percentage change; 2,4-D, 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate; 3-PBA, 3-phenoxybenzoic acid; AChE, acetylcholinesterase; ADHD, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; ADI-R, Autism Diagnostic Interview–Revised; ADOS, Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule; APEH, acyl peptide hydrolase; APP, acute pesticide poisoning; ARA, arachidonic acid; ASD, autism spectrum disorder; ASQ, Ages and Stages Questionnaire; BARS, BChE, butyrylcholinesterase; Behavioral Assessment and Research System; BASC-2, Behavior Assessment System for Children-2; BDI-II, Beck’s Depressive Inventory, 2nd edition; BNT, Boston Naming Test; BSI, Brief Symptom Inventory; BSID, Bayley Scales of Infant Development; BSID-II, Bayley Scales of Infant Development, 2nd edition; BVRT, Benton Visual Retention Test; CAVLT-2, Children’s Auditory Verbal Learning Test, 2nd edition; CB, carbamate; CDI-2, Children’s Depression inventory, 2nd edition; CI, confidence interval; CIT, 5-chloro-1,2-dihydro-1-isopropyl-[3H]-1; CMD, common mental disorders; CRS-R, Conners’ Parental Rating Scales–Revised; CPT, Continuous Performance Test; CPRS-R, Conner’s Parent Rating Scale–Revised Short Version; CPT, Continuous Performance Test; CPT_HLAT, Continuous Performance Latency for Hits; DAP, dialkylphosphate; DDE, dichlorodiphenyldichloroethylene; DDT, dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane; DEP, diethylphosphate; DHA, docosahexaenoic acid; DMP, dimethylphosphate; DMTP, dimethylthiophosphate; DSM-IV, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders; DS-F, DST, Digit Span Test; DTVP-2, Frostig Developmental Test of Visual Perception, 2nd edition; EE, environmentally exposed; ETU, ethylenethiourea; FAB, Frontal Assessment Battery; fNIRS, functional near-infrared spectroscopy; FrACT, functional acuity contrast test; FTII, Fagan Tests of Infant Intelligence; GSD, geometric standard deviation; HCH, hexachlorocyclohexane; IMPY, 2-isopropyl-4-methyl-6-hydroxypyrimidinol; IQ, intelligence quotient; LOD, limit of detection; LDD-15, Lanthony Desaturated D-15 Test; MASC-2, Multidimensional Anxiety Scale for Children, 2nd edition; MDI, Mental Development Index; MINI, Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview Diagnostic Test; MMSE, Mini-Mental State Exam; Mn, manganese; MOART, multi-operational apparatus for reaction time; MPD, minor psychiatric disorders; MSCA, McCarthy Scales of Children’s Abilities; MTS, matching to sample; MTS_LAT, matching to sample latency; NESPY-II, A Developmental Neuropsychological Assessment, 2nd edition; NBAS, Brazelton Neonatal Behavioral Assessment; OC, organochlorine; OE, occupationally exposed; OP, organophosphate; OR, odds ratio; PD, Parkinson’s disease; PDI, Psychomotor Development Index; PR, probability ratio; PRT, Progressive Ratio test; RG, rural group; RGDT, Random Gap Digit test; ROCF, Rey-Osterrieth complex figure test; RT_ALL, reaction time; RTT, reaction time test; SAT, selective attention test; SAT_LAT, selective attention test latency; SD, standard deviation; SDL, serial digit learning; SDT, Symbol Digit test; SDT_LAT, Symbol Digit test latency; SRQ-20, Self-Reporting Questionnaire 20-Item; SRT, spatial recall test; TAC, total abnormal cells; TAP, tapping test; TAP_ALT, tapping with alternate hands; TAP_NP, tapping with non-preferred hand; TAP_P tapping with preferred hand; TCPy, 3,5,6-trichloro-2-pyridinol; TSH, thyroid-stimulating hormone; UPDRS, United Parkinson’s Disease Rating Motor Subscale; VMI, visual motor integration test; WAIS; Weschler Adult Intelligence Scale; WAIS-R; Weschler Adult Intelligence Scale–Revised Version; WCST, Wisconsin Card Sorting test; WISC, Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children; WMS, Wechsler Memory Scale; WRAVMA; Wide Range Assessment of Visual Motor Ability.
Also included in Table 6 (thyroid function).
Investigators did not use exposure biomarker concentrations in multivariate analyses.
Also included in Table 9 (other health outcomes).