Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 16;12:947981. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2022.947981

Table 3.

Sensitivity analysis showing the effect of lung cancer in COPD.

Study design Deletion Result
Cohort study Thomsen M, 2012 (34) ES = 5.23%, 95% CI [4.29%, 6.18%]
Lin SH, 2013 (37) ES = 5.02%, 95% CI [4.09%, 5.95%]
Sandelin M, 2018 (23) ES = 5.17%, 95% CI [4.22%, 6.11%]
Ahn SV, 2020 (24) ES = 4.91%, 95% CI [3.99%, 5.82%]
de Torres JP, 2007 (38) ES = 5.19%, 95% CI [4.26%, 6.12%]
Purdue MP, 2007 (39) ES = 5.18%, 95% CI [4.24%, 6.11%]
Wilson DO, 2008 (40) ES = 5.10%, 95% CI [4.17%, 6.04%]
Rodríguez, L. A. 2010 (41) ES = 5.18%, 95% CI [4.24%, 6.11%]
de Torres JP, 2011 (42) ES = 4.97%, 95% CI [4.04%, 5.89%]
Kornum JB, 2012 (43) ES = 5.14%, 95% CI [4.16%, 6.12%]
Shen TC, 2014 (44) ES = 5.15%, 95% CI [4.21%, 6.09%]
Husebø GR, 2019 (24) ES = 5.04%, 95% CI [4.12%, 5.97%]
Park HY, 2020 (25) ES = 5.22%, 95% CI [4.33%, 6.11%]
Machida H, 2021 (26) ES = 5.01%, 95% CI [4.08%, 5.93%]
Ställberg B, 2018 (47) ES = 5.04%, 95% CI [4.12%, 5.97%]
Mannino DM, 2003 (48) ES = 5.19%, 95% CI [4.26%, 6.13%]
Hasegawa W, 2014 (45) ES = 4.85%, 95% CI [4.10%, 5.59%]
Roberts CM, 2011 ES = 5.20%, 95% CI [4.26%, 6.15%]
Chubachi S, 2016 (35) ES = 5.11%, 95% CI [4.18%, 6.04%]
Divo M, 2012 (13) ES = 4.95%, 95% CI [4.02%, 5.88%]
Westerik JA, 2017 (36) ES = 5.20%, 95% CI [4.25%, 6.14%]
Cross-sectional study Jung, HI, 2018 (53) ES = 5.10%, 95% CI [4.17%, 6.03%]
Montserrat-Capdevila J. 2021 (28) ES = 5.20%, 95% CI [4.24%, 6.15%]
Jurevičienė E. 2022 (29) ES = 5.13%, 95% CI [4.20%, 6.06%]
Masuda S, 2017 (54) ES = 5.21%, 95% CI [4.28%, 6.14%]
Nishida Y, 2017 (55) ES = 4.75%, 95% CI [3.82%, 5.67%]
Jo YS, 2015 (51) ES = 4.86%, 95% CI [3.93%, 5.78%]
Deniz S, 2016 (52) ES = 5.20%, 95% CI [4.27%, 6.13%]
Case-control study Sakai T. 2020 (27) ES = 4.84%, 95% CI [3.92%, 5.76%]
Schneider C, 2010 (49) ES = 5.00%, 95% CI [4.09%, 5.91%]
Greulich T, 2017 (50) ES = 5.27%, 95% CI [4.20%, 6.35%]