Skip to main content
. 2022 Jan 29;13(5):1566–1583. doi: 10.1093/advances/nmac008

TABLE 1.

Study quality assessment criteria and coding schema1

Criteria Unmet/unmentioned responses (score = 0) Partially met responses (score = 1) Completely met responses (score = 2)
A priori aim/hypothesis specific to food insecurity No mention of food insecurity in aim/hypothesis Implications of food insecurity in aim/hypothesis (e.g., hunger or difficulty affording food) Explicit mention of food insecurity in aim/hypothesis
Study population clearly specified and defined No mention of the population the sample is meant to represent Population partially and/broadly defined Population clearly defined
Participant recruitment Convenience or purposive sampling N/A Random sample or census
Sample size, n <100 ≥100 and ≤999 ≥1000
Sufficient sample reporting No report of response rate or nonresponse bias evaluation Report response rate or nonresponse bias evaluations Report response rate and nonresponse bias evaluations
Reliable and valid measures of food insecurity Measures without prior pilot or validity/reliability testing Measures with limited testing or tested in different population Measures with validity/reliability testing in related population
1

N/A, not applicable.