Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 6;12:16764. doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-20779-3

Table 5.

Environmental Risk Assessment (ERA) parameters estimated for field populations of Aenasius arizonensis.

Insecticide Population Recommended dose (g ai ha−1) Ex IOBC classification Risk index Risk category Selectivity ratio (SR) Hazard quotient (HQ) Hazard category
Imidacloprid Junagadh 25 74.83 Slightly harmful 0.31 Low risk 0.00021 27.778 Safe
Ludhiana 25 68.30 Slightly harmful 0.14 Low risk 0.00092 22.222 Safe
Saoner 25 61.46 Slightly harmful 0.24 Low risk 0.00014 28.571 Safe
Chhindwara 25 82.77 Moderately harmful 0.51 Medium risk 0.00004 100 Slightly to moderately
Profenofos Junagadh 500 81.15 Moderately harmful 0.73 High risk 0.00007 333.33 Slightly to moderately
Ludhiana 500 71.81 Slightly harmful 0.58 Medium risk 0.00013 555.56 Slightly to moderately
Saoner 500 72.66 Slightly harmful 0.70 High risk 0.00004 645.16 Slightly to moderately
Chhindwara 500 78.69 Slightly harmful 0.75 High risk 0.00002 2222.2 Slightly to moderately
Thiodicarb Junagadh 750 79.86 Slightly harmful 0.32 Low risk 0.00018 500 Slightly to moderately
Ludhiana 750 60.84 Slightly harmful 0.04 Low risk 0.00006 500 Slightly to moderately
Saoner 750 61.68 Slightly harmful 0.15 Low risk 0.00076 348.84 Slightly to moderately
Chhindwara 750 77.79 Slightly harmful 0.37 Low risk 0.00005 833.33 Slightly to moderately

ERA parameters were estimated on the females of Aenasius arizonensis exposed to lethal doses of imidacloprid, profenofos and thiodicarb.

Ex denotes Reduction coefficient.

IOBC classification is based on Reduction coefficient values.

Risk category: categorizing of insecticides based on Risk Indices in 0–1 scale with 0 = safe and 1 = Highly risk.

Selectivity ratio (SR)values < 1 indicates the non selective nature of the insecticides;

Hazard category : If HQ is less than 50—a pesticide is considered safe, 50–2500—slightly to moderately toxic and > 2500 as dangerous.