Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 31;9(3):227–262. doi: 10.1080/23328940.2022.2037376

Table 1.

| List of 153 non-meteo-based thermal stress indicators identified in the systematic search. These are complex models requiring some or all the meteorological parameters (air temperature, relative humidity, wind speed, and solar radiation) in addition to other information. Nomograms and other instruments were also considered non-meteo based indicators. The fourth column titled “Literature” cites the eligible article that was used to extract data for the present thermal stress indicator. Precise information regarding the original article of each thermal stress indicator can be found in the supplementary material.

ID Thermal Stress Indicator First Authors; Year Literature Reason for considered as non-meteo-based
Parameter Type
1 Acclimatization Thermal Strain Index de Freitas; 2009 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0001.jpg  
2 Adaptation Strain Index Blazejcztk; 2014 [18,19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0002.jpg  
3 Air Cooling Power Mitchell; 1971 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0003.jpg  
4 Air Diffusion performance Index ASHRAE; 1989 [35] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0004.jpg  
5 Air Pressure Thermometer Amonton; 1702 [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0005.jpg
6 Air Thermometer Dulong; 1815 [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0006.jpg
7 Air Thermometer Galileo; 1592 [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0007.jpg
8 Apparatus for Thermal Expansion of Gasses Gay-Lussac; 1802 [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0008.jpg
9 Berkeley Comfort Model Huizenga; 2001   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0009.jpg  
10 Bioclimatic Contrast Index Blazejczyk; 2011 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0010.jpg  
11   Bioclimatic Distance Index Mateeva; 2003 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0011.jpg  
12 Bioclimatic Index Olgyay; 1963 [37]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0012.jpg
13 Black Sphere Actinograph Poschmann; 1932 [19,38]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0013.jpg
14 Body Temperature Index Dayal; 1974 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0014.jpg  
15 Body-atmosphere Energy Exchange Index de Freitas; 1989 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0015.jpg  
16 Classification of Weather in Moments Rusanov; 1973 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0222.jpg graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0223.jpg
17 Climate Index Becker; 2000 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0017.jpg  
18 Closed Air Thermometer Amonton; 1702 [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0018.jpg
19 Climatic Heat Hubac, 1989 [39] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0019.jpg  
20 Clothing Insulation Mount;1982 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0020.jpg  
21 Cold Strain Index Moran; 1999 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0021.jpg  
22 COMfort formulA (COMFA) Brown; 1986   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0022.jpg  
23 Comfort Chart Mochida; 1979 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0023.jpg  
24 Comfort Index Terjung; 1966 [19,23,40]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0024.jpg
25 Corrected Effective Temperature (basic) Vernon; 1932 [19]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0025.jpg
26 Corrected Effective Temperature (normal) Vernon; 1932 [19]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0026.jpg
27 Corrected Humid Operative Temperature Horikoshi; 1985 [41] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0027.jpg  
28 Craig Index Craig; 1950 [42] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0028.jpg  
29 Cumulative Discomfort Index Tennenbaum; 1961 [43] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0029.jpg  
30 Cumulative Effective Temperature Sohar; 1962 [22] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0030.jpg  
31 Cumulative Heat Strain Index Frank; 1996 [19,44] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0031.jpg  
32 Cylinder Brown;1986 [19]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0032.jpg
33 Daily Weather Types Lecha; 1998 [19,23] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0224.jpg graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0225.jpg
34 Effective Draft Temperature Koestel; 1955 [35] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0034.jpg  
35 Effective Heat Strain Index Kamon;1981 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0035.jpg  
36 Ellipsoid index Blazejczyk; 1998 [19,23]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0036.jpg
37 Equilibrating Columns Dulong; 1802 [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0037.jpg
38 Equilibrium Rectal Temperature Givoni; 1972 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0038.jpg  
39 Equivalent Uniform Temperature Wray; 1980   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0039.jpg  
40 Eupathescope Dufton; 1929 [19,38]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0040.jpg
41 Evans Scale Evans; 1980 [18,19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0226.jpg graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0227.jpg
42 Exceedance Borgeson; 2011   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0042.jpg  
43 Facial Cooling Index Tikuisis; 2002 [45] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0043.jpg  
44 Frigorimeter Dorno; 1928 [19,38]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0044.jpg
45 Globe Thermometer Vernon; 1932 [46]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0045.jpg
46 Grade of Heat Strain Hubac; 1989 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0046.jpg  
47 Heart Rate Index Dayal; 1974 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0047.jpg  
48 Heart Rate Index Givoni; 1973 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0048.jpg  
49 Heat Budget Index de Freitas; 1985 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0049.jpg  
50 Heat Strain Decision Aid Model Cadarette; 1999 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0050.jpg  
51 Heat Strain Index (corrected) McKarns; 1966 [22]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0051.jpg
52 Heat Strain Predictive Systems Lustinec; 1965 [20] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0052.jpg  
53 Heat Stress Index Watts; 2004 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0053.jpg  
54 Heat Stress Prediction Model Pandolf; 1986 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0054.jpg  
55 Heat Tolerance Index Hori; 1978 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0055.jpg  
56 Heat Tolerance Limits Vogt;1982 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0056.jpg  
57 Heated Thermometer Heberden; 1826 [47]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0057.jpg
58 Heat Load Blazejczyk; 1994 [48] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0058.jpg  
59 Humid Operative Temperature Nishi; 1971 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0059.jpg  
60 Hybrid Thermometer Kircher; 1643 [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0060.jpg
61 Hypso-barometer Fahrenheit; 1724 [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0061.jpg
62 Increment Temperature Equivalent to Radiation Load Lee; 1964 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0062.jpg  
63 Index of Clothing Required for Comfort de Freitas; 1986 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0063.jpg  
64 Index of Pathogenicity of Meteorological Environment Latyshev; 1965 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0064.jpg  
65 Index of Physiological Effect Robinson; 1945 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0065.jpg  
66 Index of Thermal Stress Givoni; 1969 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0066.jpg  
67 Index of Thermal Stress Kondratyev; 1957 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0067.jpg  
68 Integral Index of Cooling Conditions Afanasieva; 2009 [19,49] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0068.jpg  
69 Integral Load Index Matyukhin; 1987 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0069.jpg  
70 Kata Thermometer Hill; 1916 [19,50]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0070.jpg
71 Mahani Climate Index / Mahoney Scale Mahoney; 1967 [51] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0228.jpg graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0229.jpg
72 Maximum Exposure Time Brauner; 1995 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0072.jpg  
73 Maximum Recommended Duration of Exercises Young; 1979 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0073.jpg  
74 Mean Equivalence Lines Wenzel; 1978 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0074.jpg  
75 MENEX model Blazejczyk; 1994 [22] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0075.jpg  
76 Mercury Weight Thermometers Dulong; 1815 [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0076.jpg
77 Metal Man (thermal manikin) Pedersen; 1948 [19]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0077.jpg
78 Meteorological Health Index Bogatkin; 2006 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0078.jpg  
79 Modified Effective Temperature Smith; 1952 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0079.jpg  
80 Modified Physiological Equivalent Temperature Lin; 2019 [52] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0080.jpg  
81 Munich Energy Balance Model Hope; 1984 [22] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0081.jpg  
82 New Effective Temperature Gagge; 1971 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0082.jpg  
83 Outdoor Comfort Zone Ahmed; 2003 [53]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0083.jpg
84 Outdoor Neutral Temperature Aroztegui; 1995 [54] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0084.jpg  
85 Outdoor Thermal Environment Index Nagano; 2011 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0085.jpg  
86 Optimum Summer Weather Index Davis; 1968 [55] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0086.jpg  
87 Overheating Risk Nicol; 2009 [22] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0087.jpg  
88 Overheating Risk Robinson; 2008 [22] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0088.jpg  
89 Perceived Temperature Jendritzky; 2000 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0089.jpg  
90 Perceptual Hyperthermia Index Gallagher; 2012 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0090.jpg  
91 Physiological Equivalent Temperature Mayer; 1987 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0091.jpg  
92 Physiological Heat Exposure Limit Chart; 1977 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0092.jpg  
93 Physiological Index of Strain Hall; 1960 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0093.jpg  
94 Physiological Strain Blazejczyk; 2005 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0094.jpg  
95 Physiological Strain Index Moran; 1998 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0095.jpg  
96 Physiological Subjective Temperature Blazejczyk; 2007 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0096.jpg  
97 Predicted Effects of Heat Acclimatization Givoni; 1973 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0097.jpg  
98 Predicted Four-Hour Sweat Rate McArdle; 1947 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0098.jpg  
99 Predicted Heat Strain Malchaire; 2001 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0099.jpg  
100 Predicted Mean Vote—Fuzzy Hamdi; 1999 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0100.jpg  
101 Predicted Mean Vote—Indoors Fanger; 1970 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0101.jpg  
102 Predicted Mean Vote—Outdoors Gagge; 1986 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0102.jpg  
103 Predicted Mean Vote—Outdoors Jendritzky; 1981 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0103.jpg  
104 Predicted Percentage Dissatisfied Index Fanger; 1970 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0104.jpg  
105 Predicted Rectal Temperature Givoni; 1972 [21] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0105.jpg  
106 Predicted Sweat Loss Shapiro; 1982 [22] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0106.jpg  
107 Prescriptive Zone Lind; 1970 [22] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0107.jpg  
108 Qs Index Rublack; 1981 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0108.jpg  
109 Quotient of Heat Stress Hubac; 1989 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0109.jpg  
110 Reference Index Pulket; 1980 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0110.jpg  
111 Relative Heat Strain Lee; 1966 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0111.jpg  
112 Required Clothing Insulation Holmer; 1984 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0112.jpg  
113 Required Sweat Rate Vogt; 1981 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0113.jpg  
114 Respiratory Heat Loss Rusanov; 1989 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0114.jpg  
115 Resultant Thermometer Missenard; 1935 [38]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0115.jpg
116 Santorio’s Thermometer Santorio; 1612 [56]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0116.jpg
117 Skin Temperature Mehnert; 2000 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0117.jpg  
118 Skin Temperature Energy Balance Index de Freitas; 1985 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0118.jpg  
119 Skin Wettedness Gonzalez; 1978 [19,23] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0119.jpg  
120 Skin Wettedness Kerslake; 1972 [22] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0120.jpg  
121 Spatial Synoptic Classification Kalkstein; 1996 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0121.jpg  
122 Standard Effective Temperature Gonzalez; 1974 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0122.jpg  
123 Standard Effective Temperature Gagge; 1986 [21] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0123.jpg  
124 Standard Effective Temperature for Outdoors Pickup; 2000 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0124.jpg  
125 Still Shade Temperature Burton; 1955 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0125.jpg  
126 Subjective Temperature Index Blazejczyk; 2005 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0126.jpg  
127 Summer Severity Index McLaughlin; 1977 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0127.jpg  
128 Survival Time Outdoors in Extreme Cold de Freitas; 1987 [19,23] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0128.jpg  
129 Temperature Load cited by Kioka; 2006 [57] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0129.jpg  
130 Thermal Acceptance Ratio Ionides; 1945 [19,23] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0130.jpg  
131 Thermal Balance Rusanov; 1981 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0131.jpg  
132 Thermal Discomfort Gagge; 1986 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0132.jpg  
133 Thermal Insulation of Clothing Aizenshtat; 1964 [18,19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0133.jpg  
134 Thermal Insulation of Clothing Budyko; 1960 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0134.jpg  
135 Thermal Insulation of Clothing Rusanov; 1981 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0135.jpg  
136 Thermal Insulation of Protective Clothing Afanasieva; 1977 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0136.jpg  
137 Thermal Sensation Fountain; 1995 [54] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0137.jpg  
138 Thermal Sensation Givoni; 2003 [19,23] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0138.jpg  
139 Thermal Sensation Index Kiuchi; 2001 [57] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0139.jpg  
140 Thermal Strain Index Lee; 1958 [19,23] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0140.jpg  
141 Thermal Work Limit Brake; 2002 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0141.jpg  
142 Thermal-Insulation Characteristics of Clothing Kondraty; 1957 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0142.jpg  
143 Thermo-Integrator Winslow; 1935 [19,23]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0143.jpg
144 Thermoscope Hero; 40 AD [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0144.jpg
145 Thermoscope Philo; 200 BC [36]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0145.jpg
146 Total Heat Hubac, 1989 [39] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0146.jpg  
147 Total Thermal Stress Auliciems; 1981 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0147.jpg  
148 Tourism Climate Index Mieczowski; 1985 [55] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0148.jpg  
149 Weather Stress Index Kalkstein; 1986 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0149.jpg  
150 Weather–Climate Contrasts Rusanov; 1987 [19] graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0150.jpg  
151 Wet Bulb Thermometer Haldane; 1905 [58]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0151.jpg
152 Wet Globe Thermometer Botsford; 1971 [59]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0152.jpg
153 Wind Effect Index Terjung; 1966 [19,23,40]   graphic file with name KTMP_A_2037376_ILG0153.jpg

Inline graphicMetabolic Rate

Inline graphicElevation / Barometric Pressure

Inline graphicSkin Temperature

Inline graphicClothing Insulation

Inline graphicCloud Level

Inline graphicDuration of Effort

Inline graphicLong-wave Radiation

Inline graphicAcclimatization status

Inline graphicHeart Rate

Inline graphicPrecipitation

Inline graphicNo Environmental Data

Inline graphicWater Intake

Inline graphicCore Temperature

Inline graphicCovered Distance

Inline graphicSpecialized Equipment

Inline graphicSweat Rate / Water loss / Vapor Pressure at Skin Surface

Inline graphicEvaporative Heat Loss from Skin

Inline graphicQuestionnaire

Inline graphicDelta Data (fluctuation throughout the time)

Inline graphicNo Fitted Equation / Nomogram

Inline graphicaverage temperature over multiple measures