Skip to main content
. 2019 Oct 6;212(6):279–285. doi: 10.5694/mja2.50355
Year Number of participants Study design and follow‐up Intervention and duration of therapy Main outcome Comments
1963–64 30 769 Prospective placebo‐controlled RCT of Shigella dysentery; follow‐up 109 days24 Phage preparation peroral once a week; therapy 109 days
  • Incidence of dysentery 3.8 times higher in placebo group

  • Microbiologically confirmed Shigella dysentery 2.6 times higher in placebo group

  • Effectiveness reported to be greater in infants aged 6–12 months and lowest in children aged 5–7 years

  • Original article in Russian, information drawn from review

1970 8 Case–control study of Vibrio cholerae; no follow‐up26 High dose of phage (1013 PFU), half‐hourly to hourly, until diarrhoea resolved; therapy 5–6 days
  • Duration and volume diarrhoea reduced in 4/8 patients; tetracycline more effective

  • V. cholerae excretion cleared within 18 hours in responders

  • Loss of V. cholerae motility reported within 90 minutes of dosing

  • No phage resistance reported after therapy; no statistical analyses reported

2009 39 Prospective double‐blind RCT of chronic venous leg ulcers; no follow‐up27 Phage application via ultrasonic debridement device, followed by wound dressing and bandage; therapy 12 weeks
  • Safety demonstrated: no significant adverse events

  • Ulcer healing 12 weeks and 24 weeks — no difference (not powered for this)

  • Bacteriophage‐impregnated dressings included lactoferrin

2009 24 Prospective double‐blind RCT of chronic otitis externa; Pseudomonas aeruginosa; follow‐up 6 weeks28 105 PFU phage application plus meticulous ear cleaning; single application
  • Significant improvement in symptoms and signs of otitis in phage‐treated group, and in erythema for phage v control at Day 7 (= 0.02) and Day 21 (= 0.014); ulceration, granulation and polyps at Day 7 (= 0.017) and Day 42 (= 0.025)

  • 3/12 phage‐treated patients demonstrated near‐complete reduction in all visual analogue scores, along with undetectable P. aeruginosa, compared with none in the placebo group

  • Trial stopped early during interim analysis by primary investigator due to clinical improvement in the phage‐treated group

  • Phage replication in vivo was detected for a mean of 23.1 days (median, 21 days) in the treatment group

2016 120 Prospective double‐blind RCT of acute diarrhoea in children; follow‐up 21 days29 T4 phage cocktail or Microgen ColiProteus phage cocktail; therapy 4 days
  • No difference in stool load or frequency between groups

  • Safety: no adverse events

  • No significant phage replication in stool (stool output < oral input). No difference in phage titres seen between stool with phage‐sensitive Escherichia coli compared with those without phage‐sensitive E. coli

  • Trial stopped early at interim analysis due to perceived lack of efficacy

  • Phage interventions targeted E. coli but only 60% of participants had confirmed pathogenic E. coli

  • Diarrhoeal illnesses were probably the result of complex polymicrobial interplay — potential explanation for a lack of efficacy of narrow spectrum phage treatment

2019 27 Prospective double‐blind RCT of clinically infected burn wounds (P. aeruginosa); follow‐up 14 days10 Alginate template soaked in PP1131 at ~ 1 × 106 PFU/mL, applied topically to wounds daily; therapy 7 days
  • Time to sustained reduction in two‐quadrant bacterial burden was significantly longer in the phage group (median, 144 h [95% CI, 48–NR] v 47 h [95% CI, 23–122]; HR, 0.29 [95% CI, 0.10–0.79]; P = 0.018)

  • Higher proportion of participants had successful treatment outcome in the standard care group than in the phage group (13/17 [76%] v 9/17 [53%]; = 0.15)

  • Study population heterogeneity: patients in the phage group were older whereas patients in the standard care group had more severe burns

  • The actual phage dose delivered to patients was substantially lower than anticipated

  • There were phage‐susceptibility differences in phage‐treated patients who had clinical success (89% susceptible) v those that failed (24% susceptible)

HR = hazard ratio; NR = not reached; PFU = plaque‐forming unit; PP1131 = cocktail of 12 natural lytic anti‐P. aeruginosa bacteriophages; RCT = randomised controlled trial.