Table 3.
Cancer type | Cell | Drug | Concentration | TTFields parameters | Time and effect | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ovarian cancer | A2780, OVCAR3, CAOV-3 | Paclitaxel | 0–100 nM | 200 kHz,2.7 V/cm | 72 h CI A2780:1.03, OVCAR3:0.81, CAOV-3:0.86. | [37] |
MPM | MSTO-211H, NCI-H2052 | Cisplatin | 1–10,000 nM | 150 kHz, 1 V/cm | Pemetrexed+TTFields vs. Cisplatin+TTFields: additive vs. synergistical effect. | [28] |
Pemetrexed | 1–100 nM | Cisplatin+TTFields: Apoptosis↑ | ||||
Triple therapy (two drugs+TTFields): proliferation and clonal formation↓ | ||||||
Lung cancer | Gefitinib-resistant PC-9GR, H1975 cells | Osimertinib | 0.5 μM | 1 V/cm | Proliferation↑, cell death, apoptosis↓ | [29] |
TTFields attenuates the inhibitory effect of Osimertinib | ||||||
HCC827 | Erlotinib | 0–20 nM | 150 kHz,1.75 V/cm | 72 h: Proliferation and clonal formation↓ | [34] | |
H1299, LLC1, HTB-182, KLN205 | Pemetrexed | 0–0.1 nM | 150 kHz,1.75 V/cm | 72 h: Proliferation and clonal formation↓ | [34] | |
Paclitaxel | 0–100 nM | |||||
Cisplatin | 0–10 nM | |||||
H157, H4006, A549, H1299 | Cisplatin | Cisplatin PIC25 (μM) : H157 1, H4006 0.75, A549 2, H1299 = 2. | 100-200 kHz | Olaparib+IR + TTFields:CI>1. | [22] | |
Olaparib | Olaparib 0–40 μM | Olaparib+IR, Olaparib+TTFields:CI ≈ 1. | ||||
Liver cancer | Huh7 | Doxorubicin | 0–10 µM | 120 kHz, 1 Vpp | 72 h: therapeutic effect↑ | [38] |
Glioma | LN-18, LN-229, T-325, ZH-161 | TMZ | 5 μM-200 μM | 2 V/cm | 24 h: LN-229, ZH-161: sensitization | [20] |
U118 | Dacarbazine | 0-100 mM | 150 kHz, 1.75 V/cm | 72 h: IC50: Dacarbazine 6.4 mM→0.023 mM, Paclitaxel 5 nM→0.005 nM, Doxorubicin 0.04 μM → 0.002 μM, Cyclophosphamide 6.6 mM→0.044 mM. | [31] | |
DRI: Dacarbazine 175, Paclitaxel 316, Doxorubicin 23, Cyclophosphamide 152 | ||||||
U373 | Thymidine | 2 mM | 200 kHz | For G1/S blocked cells, proliferation, clonal formation, DNA damage and apoptosis= | [62] | |
U373, U87 | Sorafenib | 5 μM | 150 kHz, 0.9 V/cm | 48 h: proliferation ↓ , cell death ↑ . | [26, 32] | |
STAT3 expression ↓ . Knocking down STAT3: TTFields effect↑ | ||||||
24 h: S phase, migration, invasion and angiogenesis↓ | ||||||
48 h: clonal formation ↓ , apoptosis, autophagy, ROS ↑ | ||||||
U-87 MG, U-138 MG, U-343 MG | MPS1-IN-3 | 4 µM | 200 kHz, 1.7 V/cm | U-87 MG, GaMG: 72 h:proliferation ↓ . | [49] | |
U-87 MG, 72 h: abnormal nuclei, G2/M, apoptosis ↑ . | ||||||
MPS1-IN-3 prolongs TTFields effect | ||||||
U87-MG, KNS42, SF188 | Paclitaxel | High vs Low concentration | 130 kHz, 10 V, 450 μs | Synergistically effect. | [45] | |
Mebendazole | SubG0↑ | |||||
GBM | KR158-luc | TMZ | 300 µM | 200 kHz | 72 h: adaptive immune= | [69] |
Patient-derived glioblastoma stem cell-like cells (GSCs) | TMZ | 1.5 μM-160 μM | 200 kHz, 1 V/cm | 8 days: same inhibitory efficacy in two cell types (MGMT expression + /-). | [54] | |
U251-MG, MZ-54 | Dexamethasone | 65 μM | 1.48–1.41 V/cm | 48 h: sensitization. | [44] | |
Dexamethasone: decrease IR induced-effect but does not affect TTFields induced-effect | ||||||
Dexamethasone+TTFields: PFS and OS = | ||||||
U87-MG, GBM2, GBM39 | Withaferin A | 0–0.1uM | 200 kHz, 4 V/cm 2.5 V/cm | 50 kHz vs. 200 kHz, 500 kHz: no sensitization vs. sensitization. Intensity dependent | [36] | |
Colonic cancer | HCT116 | 5-FU | 5 µmol/L | 0.9–1.2 V/cm | 48 h: sensitization. | [30] |
Proliferation, clonal formation, migration, invasion↓ | ||||||
Autophagy, apoptosis, organoid cell death↑ | ||||||
Cervical cancer | HeLa | Doxorubicin | 0–10 µM | 120 kHz, 1 Vpp | 72 h: therapeutic effect↑ | [38] |
Breast cancer | EmtR1 cells, MCF-7/Mx, MDA-MB-231/Dox cells | Doxorubicin | 0.04–0.6 μM, | 150 kHz, 1.75 V/cm | TTFields+chemotherapy 72 h: Same efficacy in WT cell and drug-resistant cell. DRI: Doxorubicin 105-250 vs. Paclitaxel 815- >10,000 | [27] |
Paclitaxel | 5 nM–0.1 μM | |||||
JIMT-1,BT-474 | Trastuzumab | 5 μM | – | 72 h: Synergistical effect, clonal formation ↓ , apoptosis↑ | [33] | |
MDA-MB-231 | Doxorubicin | IC50 = 0.31 μM | 150 kHz, 4 V/cm | Synergistical effect | [36] | |
MDA-MB-231 | Doxorubicin, Paclitaxel, Cyclophosphamide | 0–10 μM, 0–1000 nM, 0–100 mM | 150 kHz, 1.75 V/cm | 72 h IC50: Doxorubicin 0.04 μM → 0.002 μM, Paclitaxel 5.00 nM→0.005 nM, Cyclophosphamide 6.60 mM→0.044 mM. | [31] | |
24 h treatment then quit for 48 h: Control and the chemotherapy group vs. Combined group: cell proliferation recovered rapidly vs. did not recover. | ||||||
Pancreatic cancer | PC-1.0 (hamster), AsPC-1 | Gemcitabine | – | 150 kHz, 2.9 ± 0.2 V/cm | Therapeutic effect↑ | [35] |
Irinotecan | ||||||
5-FU | ||||||
Paclitaxel | ||||||
Liver cancer | Huh7 | Doxorubicin | 0–10 µM | 120 kHz, 1 Vpp | 72 h: therapeutic effect↑ | [38] |
↑ up-regulate,↓ down-regulate, = unchanged.
5-FU 5-Fluorouracil, WT wide type, DRI dose reduction index, IC50 half maximal inhibitory concentration, CI combination index, TMZ Temozolomide, STAT3 signal transducer and activator of transcription 3, MGMT O6 -methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase, OS overall survival, PFS progression-free survival, MDA-MB-231/Dox cells doxorubicin resistant MDA-MB-231 cells, EmtR1 cells AA8 cells- Emetine-resistant sub-lines, MCF-7/Mx MCF-7 cells Mitoxantrone-resistant sub-lines, Vs versus.