Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 11;8:416. doi: 10.1038/s41420-022-01206-y

Table 3.

Summary of the frequency, intensity, duration, drug concentration, and the effect of TTFields combined drugs on various tumor cells.

Cancer type Cell Drug Concentration TTFields parameters Time and effect Ref.
Ovarian cancer A2780, OVCAR3, CAOV-3 Paclitaxel 0–100 nM 200 kHz,2.7 V/cm 72 h CI A2780:1.03, OVCAR3:0.81, CAOV-3:0.86. [37]
MPM MSTO-211H, NCI-H2052 Cisplatin 1–10,000 nM 150 kHz, 1 V/cm Pemetrexed+TTFields vs. Cisplatin+TTFields: additive vs. synergistical effect. [28]
Pemetrexed 1–100 nM Cisplatin+TTFields: Apoptosis↑
Triple therapy (two drugs+TTFields): proliferation and clonal formation↓
Lung cancer Gefitinib-resistant PC-9GR, H1975 cells Osimertinib 0.5 μM 1 V/cm Proliferation↑, cell death, apoptosis↓ [29]
TTFields attenuates the inhibitory effect of Osimertinib
HCC827 Erlotinib 0–20 nM 150 kHz,1.75 V/cm 72 h: Proliferation and clonal formation↓ [34]
H1299, LLC1, HTB-182, KLN205 Pemetrexed 0–0.1 nM 150 kHz,1.75 V/cm 72 h: Proliferation and clonal formation↓ [34]
Paclitaxel 0–100 nM
Cisplatin 0–10 nM
H157, H4006, A549, H1299 Cisplatin Cisplatin PIC25 (μM) : H157 1, H4006 0.75, A549 2, H1299 = 2. 100-200 kHz Olaparib+IR + TTFields:CI>1. [22]
Olaparib Olaparib 0–40 μM Olaparib+IR, Olaparib+TTFields:CI ≈ 1.
Liver cancer Huh7 Doxorubicin 0–10 µM 120 kHz, 1 Vpp 72 h: therapeutic effect↑ [38]
Glioma LN-18, LN-229, T-325, ZH-161 TMZ 5 μM-200 μM 2 V/cm 24 h: LN-229, ZH-161: sensitization [20]
U118 Dacarbazine 0-100 mM 150 kHz, 1.75 V/cm 72 h: IC50: Dacarbazine 6.4 mM→0.023 mM, Paclitaxel 5 nM→0.005 nM, Doxorubicin 0.04 μM → 0.002 μM, Cyclophosphamide 6.6 mM→0.044 mM. [31]
DRI: Dacarbazine 175, Paclitaxel 316, Doxorubicin 23, Cyclophosphamide 152
U373 Thymidine 2 mM 200 kHz For G1/S blocked cells, proliferation, clonal formation, DNA damage and apoptosis= [62]
U373, U87 Sorafenib 5 μM 150 kHz, 0.9 V/cm 48 h: proliferation ↓ , cell death ↑ . [26, 32]
STAT3 expression ↓ . Knocking down STAT3: TTFields effect↑
24 h: S phase, migration, invasion and angiogenesis↓
48 h: clonal formation ↓ , apoptosis, autophagy, ROS ↑ 
U-87 MG, U-138 MG, U-343 MG MPS1-IN-3 4 µM 200 kHz, 1.7 V/cm U-87 MG, GaMG: 72 h:proliferation ↓ . [49]
U-87 MG, 72 h: abnormal nuclei, G2/M, apoptosis ↑ .
MPS1-IN-3 prolongs TTFields effect
U87-MG, KNS42, SF188 Paclitaxel High vs Low concentration 130 kHz, 10 V, 450 μs Synergistically effect. [45]
Mebendazole SubG0↑
GBM KR158-luc TMZ 300 µM 200 kHz 72 h: adaptive immune= [69]
Patient-derived glioblastoma stem cell-like cells (GSCs) TMZ 1.5 μM-160 μM 200 kHz, 1 V/cm 8 days: same inhibitory efficacy in two cell types (MGMT expression + /-). [54]
U251-MG, MZ-54 Dexamethasone 65 μM 1.48–1.41 V/cm 48 h: sensitization. [44]
Dexamethasone: decrease IR induced-effect but does not affect TTFields induced-effect
Dexamethasone+TTFields: PFS and OS = 
U87-MG, GBM2, GBM39 Withaferin A 0–0.1uM 200 kHz, 4 V/cm 2.5 V/cm 50 kHz vs. 200 kHz, 500 kHz: no sensitization vs. sensitization. Intensity dependent [36]
Colonic cancer HCT116 5-FU 5 µmol/L 0.9–1.2 V/cm 48 h: sensitization. [30]
Proliferation, clonal formation, migration, invasion↓
Autophagy, apoptosis, organoid cell death↑
Cervical cancer HeLa Doxorubicin 0–10 µM 120 kHz, 1 Vpp 72 h: therapeutic effect↑ [38]
Breast cancer EmtR1 cells, MCF-7/Mx, MDA-MB-231/Dox cells Doxorubicin 0.04–0.6 μM, 150 kHz, 1.75 V/cm TTFields+chemotherapy 72 h: Same efficacy in WT cell and drug-resistant cell. DRI: Doxorubicin 105-250 vs. Paclitaxel 815- >10,000 [27]
Paclitaxel 5 nM–0.1 μM
JIMT-1,BT-474 Trastuzumab 5 μM 72 h: Synergistical effect, clonal formation ↓ , apoptosis↑ [33]
MDA-MB-231 Doxorubicin IC50 = 0.31 μM 150 kHz, 4 V/cm Synergistical effect [36]
MDA-MB-231 Doxorubicin, Paclitaxel, Cyclophosphamide 0–10 μM, 0–1000 nM, 0–100 mM 150 kHz, 1.75 V/cm 72 h IC50: Doxorubicin 0.04 μM → 0.002 μM, Paclitaxel 5.00 nM→0.005 nM, Cyclophosphamide 6.60 mM→0.044 mM. [31]
24 h treatment then quit for 48 h: Control and the chemotherapy group vs. Combined group: cell proliferation recovered rapidly vs. did not recover.
Pancreatic cancer PC-1.0 (hamster), AsPC-1 Gemcitabine 150 kHz, 2.9 ± 0.2 V/cm Therapeutic effect↑ [35]
Irinotecan
5-FU
Paclitaxel
Liver cancer Huh7 Doxorubicin 0–10 µM 120 kHz, 1 Vpp 72 h: therapeutic effect↑ [38]

up-regulate, down-regulate, = unchanged.

5-FU 5-Fluorouracil, WT wide type, DRI dose reduction index, IC50 half maximal inhibitory concentration, CI combination index, TMZ Temozolomide, STAT3 signal transducer and activator of transcription 3, MGMT O6 -methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase, OS overall survival, PFS progression-free survival, MDA-MB-231/Dox cells doxorubicin resistant MDA-MB-231 cells, EmtR1 cells AA8 cells- Emetine-resistant sub-lines, MCF-7/Mx MCF-7 cells Mitoxantrone-resistant sub-lines, Vs versus.