Commentary Table.
Phase 1 | Phase 2 | |
---|---|---|
Use of CanCHEC Cohorts for Overall Analysis | Cohort-specific analyses and meta-analyses | Cohort-specific and pooled cohort analyses with duplicates removed (see Commentary Figure 1) |
Linking CanCHEC and CCHS Participants to Death Records | Probabilistic and deterministic linkage | Deterministic only linkage |
PM2.5 Exposure Modeling | Developed a high-resolution exposure model using single daily satellite observations | Improved the model with multiple daily satellite observations and colocated ground measurements |
PM2.5 Exposure Windows and Lag Time | 1-, 3-, and 8-year moving average with a 1-year lag | 10-year moving average with a 1-year lag based on analysis showing larger effect estimates for longer moving averages |
PM2.5 Exposure Assignment for Person-Years with Missing Postal Codes | Imputed as the national population-weighted average exposure | Imputed based on the population-weighted average exposure from nearby postal codes |
Covariate Adjustment | Directed Acyclic Graph informed (group-level covariates only), fully adjusted (included group- and individual-level covariates), and indirectly adjusted for health behaviors | Fully adjusted only |
Evaluation of the Concentration-Response Shape | RCS, SCHIF | RCS, extended SCHIF, and threshold |
Copollutant Analysis | Linear HR models adjusted for NO2, O3, and Ox | Linear HR models adjusted for O3 and Ox, stratified by O3 and Ox tertiles and nonlinear model adjustment for linear O3and Ox |
Additional Sensitivity Analyses | With and without immigrants included | Exclusion of person-years with PM2.5exposure >U.S. and Canadian air quality standards, and mortality risk by regional airshed |
Ox = gaseous pollutant oxidant capacity.