Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 7;10(Suppl 1):e001829. doi: 10.1136/fmch-2022-001829

Table 2.

Description of included studies using the PICO framework

Author Study Intervention Outcomes Results Other
First author year location Design
(assessments) duration
Description N
Age
Programme description Psychosocial Visits/costs Missing data Funding
Conflict of interest
1. Referral, 2. link worker, 3. providers
Elston
2019

England, UK40
Before–after
(two times)
12 months
50+ with 2+ chronic conditions n=151 assessed
n=126 completed
‘Local health, social and economic services’. p. 2
  • Well-being Star

  • WEMWBS

Health and social care use 40/126 people
12 months
(32%)
Torbay Medical Research Fund
Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust
73% women 79.6 y
(mean)
  1. GPs and staff from community and social care, hospital discharge, housing, other organisations, self

  2. Link worker

  3. Coordinators from local service

Giebel
2021

England, UK41
Before–after
(three times)
6 months
People with dementia diagnosis and family carer n=25, 14 people with dementia
‘”Happy and Healthy” classes, which comprise physical and mental well-being exercises’. p. 1854
1. Psychiatrist, GPs and self-referral.
2. NR.
3. Community centre advisers.
SWEMWBS NA 3/25 people
3 months (12%)
National Institute for Health Research Applied Research Collaboration North West Coast
36% women 74 (8) y Mean (SD) 10/25 people
6 months (40%)
Jones
2020

Wales, UK42
Before–after
(two times)
16 weeks
Age 55+ years; community dwelling; no or mild cognitive impairment; and families n=159 Health Precinct ‘Lifestyle Management, National Exercise Referral Scheme (NERS) and Cardiac Rehabilitation’. p. 2
  • Campaign to End

    Loneliness Scale

  • EQ-5D-5L

  • Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale

GP appointments 93/159 people did not complete study (58%). Health and Care Research Wales Grant
61% women 72.4 (8.3) y
Mean (SD)
  1. Healthcare professionals or social care teams.

  2. NR.

  3. Health precinct programme-specific staff.

Kim
2021
South Korea43
Before–after
(two times)
10 weeks
Age 65+ years from rural area n=16 ‘The interventions consisted of three parts: music storytelling, a self-help group, and gardening’. p. 2
  • GDS-K

  • Self-Efficacy Scale

  • Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale

  • Social Participation Scale

  • UCLA Loneliness Scale

NA 6/16 people did not complete programme (38%). National Research Foundation of Korea, Grant/Award
All women 82 (5.9) y
Mean (SD)
  1. Public health doctor; administrative and welfare office.

  2. Link worker.

  3. Experts, staff and volunteers.

Loftus
2017 Northern Ireland, UK44
Quality Improvement
(two times)
12 weeks before and 12 weeks during the programme
65+ and chronic condition, GP visits+ or multiple meds n=68 ‘Social clubs, Men’s Shed, counselling, arts programme, falls prevention, exercises classes, crochet classes, personal development, craft classes, befriending and computer courses’. p. 97 NA GP surgery visits
GP home visits
GP telephone calls
Repeat medication prescriptions

40/68 (59%) declined social prescribing activity (not in per protocol analysis)
71% women 72.9 (7.3) y Mean (SD)
  1. Local GPs.

  2. Link worker.

  3. NR, but included a variety of activities.

Thomson
2018 England, UK45
Before–after
(three times)
10 weeks
65–94 y at risk for social isolation or loneliness n=115 Museum-based programme MWM-OA NR Grant from the Arts and Humanities Research Council
63% women 65–94 y
  1. Health and social care; organisations.

  2. NR.

  3. Museum facilitators and volunteers.

Vogelpoel
2014 London, UK46
Before–after
(2 weeks)
12 weeks
61–95 y with sensory impairment, socially isolated n=12 Community arts programme WEMWBS 4/12 people did not attend the full programme (33%) Authors work at Sense, a national charity for people with sensory impairment
75% women Mean >80 y
  1. Local GPs.

  2. Link worker.

  3. Sense support staff; communicator guides; visual and tactile arts facilitator.

Please note we did not include physical outcomes in the table as there were so few reported in the included studies.

EQ-5D-5L, EuroQol-5 Dimensions-5 Levels; GDS-K, Geriatric Depression Scale Korean Version; GP, general practitioner; MUM-OA, Museum Wellbeing Measure for Older Adults; NA, not assessed; NR, not reported; PAM, patient activation measure; PICO, population, intervention, comparator and outcome; RCFS, Rockwood Clinical Frail Scale; SWEMWBS, Short Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale; WEMWBS, Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Health and Well-being Scale; WHOQOL-BREF, WHO Quality of Life (Shorter version); y, years.