Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 13;21:97. doi: 10.1186/s12940-022-00901-8

Table 3.

HR (95% CI) for all-cause mortality considering both NO2 and PM2.5

Model NO2 or PM2.5 (μg/m3) n Two pollutants model—NO2 + PM2.5
HR (95% CI) p value
Model a Per 10 μg/m3 increment
NO2 10,759 0.978 (0.950, 1.008) 0.148
PM2.5 10,759 1.252 (1.227, 1.279)  < 0.001
Model b NO2 (μg/m3)
  [ 1.22, 10.00) 2704 1.111 (0.965, 1.278) 0.143
  [ 10.00, 20.00) 4564 0.980 (0.861, 1.114) 0.753
  [ 20.00, 30.00) 2216 1.101 (0.970, 1.250) 0.136
  [ 30.00, 40.00) 786 1.019 (0.884, 1.174) 0.795
  [ 40.00,109.04] 489 Reference /
PM2.5 (μg/m3)
  [ 14.8, 25.0) 218 0.171 (0.134, 0.218)  < 0.001
  [ 25.0, 35.0) 1149 0.209 (0.183, 0.237)  < 0.001
  [ 35.0, 50.0) 3834 0.516 (0.473, 0.563)  < 0.001
  [ 50.0, 70.0) 4226 0.728 (0.677, 0.783)  < 0.001
  [ 70.0,133.1] 1332 Reference /
Model c Combination of NO2 and PM2.5 (median cut-off)
 NO2 < 16 & PM2.5 < 51 3701 Reference /
 NO2 ≥ 16 & PM2.5 < 51 1765 1.295 (1.197, 1.401)  < 0.001
 NO2 < 16 & PM2.5 ≥ 51 1889 1.641 (1.521, 1.770)  < 0.001
 NO2 ≥ 16 & PM2.5 ≥ 51 3404 1.843 (1.715, 1.981)  < 0.001
Model d Combination of NO2 and PM2.5 (guideline cut-off)
 NO2 < 20 & PM2.5 < 35 1221 Reference /
 NO2 ≥ 20 & PM2.5 < 35 146 1.797 (1.380, 2.338)  < 0.001
 NO2 < 20 & PM2.5 ≥ 35 6047 2.756 (2.501, 3.038)  < 0.001
 NO2 ≥ 20 & PM2.5 ≥ 35 3345 3.241 (2.909, 3.610)  < 0.001

Model a, b, c, and d all adjusted for age, gender, education, household income, marital status, smoking status, drinking status, physical activity, residence, geographical region of residence, BMI, annual temperature mean, and annual temperature standard deviation