Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 28;9(29):2203291. doi: 10.1002/advs.202203291

Table 1.

The advantages and shortcomings of different physical methods for eradicating biofilms

Physical methods Advantages Shortcomings Refs.
Non‐thermal (cold) plasma

*Antimicrobials generated locally

*High level of oxidation/reactive species renders resistance unlikely

*Accessibility of plasma

*Biofilm EPS may protect cells deeper down

*Response to plasma is species‐dependent

*Highly localized

[265]
Microbubbles *Physical action reduces probability of resistance *Readily combined with irrigants and shear

*Accessibility

*Biofilm can resist removal due to the viscoelasticity

*Residual cells may remain

[266]
Photodynamic and/or photothermal therapy

*Antimicrobial activity can be controlled locally

*Can be readily combined with surface modifications

*Delivery to infected site and transport into biofilm

*Accessibility of light

*Biofilm EPS may protect cells

* Cytotoxic effects due to the generated heat

[265]
Ultrasound

*Readily projected through skin and soft tissue

*Local delivery

*Physical action reduces probability of resistance

*Limited targeting

*Influence of pressure waves on viscoelastic biofilms not well understood

*Local delivery limited to small and accessible areas

[267]
Magnetic manipulation systems

*Avoiding the limited tissue penetration

*Physical targeting

*Efficiently penetrate biofilm

*Biofilm mechanical destruction

*Difficult to target in vivo [247, 268]
Catalytic therapy

*Use via the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), deactivating bacteria by destructing the proteins, DNA, and polysaccharides

*Damage the EPS of biofilms and weaken the resistance of bacteria in biofilms to environmental stress

*Low therapeutic efficacy without the addition of H2O2

*Lack of targeting ability to bacterial biofilms

[257, 269]
Electrical stimulation

*Projected through induction or connected wires

*On‐demand antimicrobial generation

*Also promote wound healing

*Electrochemistry of body fluids not well understood

* Heat generation

*Delivery of electrical currents to deep tissue

*Cytotoxicity

[270]