Table 1.
The advantages and shortcomings of different physical methods for eradicating biofilms
Physical methods | Advantages | Shortcomings | Refs. |
---|---|---|---|
Non‐thermal (cold) plasma |
*Antimicrobials generated locally *High level of oxidation/reactive species renders resistance unlikely |
*Accessibility of plasma *Biofilm EPS may protect cells deeper down *Response to plasma is species‐dependent *Highly localized |
[265] |
Microbubbles | *Physical action reduces probability of resistance *Readily combined with irrigants and shear |
*Accessibility *Biofilm can resist removal due to the viscoelasticity *Residual cells may remain |
[266] |
Photodynamic and/or photothermal therapy |
*Antimicrobial activity can be controlled locally *Can be readily combined with surface modifications |
*Delivery to infected site and transport into biofilm *Accessibility of light *Biofilm EPS may protect cells * Cytotoxic effects due to the generated heat |
[265] |
Ultrasound |
*Readily projected through skin and soft tissue *Local delivery *Physical action reduces probability of resistance |
*Limited targeting *Influence of pressure waves on viscoelastic biofilms not well understood *Local delivery limited to small and accessible areas |
[267] |
Magnetic manipulation systems |
*Avoiding the limited tissue penetration *Physical targeting *Efficiently penetrate biofilm *Biofilm mechanical destruction |
*Difficult to target in vivo | [247, 268] |
Catalytic therapy |
*Use via the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), deactivating bacteria by destructing the proteins, DNA, and polysaccharides *Damage the EPS of biofilms and weaken the resistance of bacteria in biofilms to environmental stress |
*Low therapeutic efficacy without the addition of H2O2 *Lack of targeting ability to bacterial biofilms |
[257, 269] |
Electrical stimulation |
*Projected through induction or connected wires *On‐demand antimicrobial generation *Also promote wound healing |
*Electrochemistry of body fluids not well understood * Heat generation *Delivery of electrical currents to deep tissue *Cytotoxicity |
[270] |