Table 2.
Summary of each study’s risk of bias and applicability concern using the PROBAST (Prediction model Risk Of Bias ASsessment Tool)—review authors’ judgements
Author, year | Risk of bias | Applicability | Overall | ||||||
Participant selection | Predictors | Outcome | Analysis | Participant selection | Predictors | Outcome | Risk of bias | Applicability | |
Bauersachs et al, 200723 | ? | ? | + | – | ? | ? | + | – | ? |
Binstock and Larkin, 201924 | ? | ? | ? | – | – | ? | ? | – | – |
Cavazza et al, 201225 | – | ? | ? | – | – | + | ? | – | – |
Chau et al, 201926 | ? | ? | ? | – | ? | ? | ? | – | ? |
Chauleur et al, 200827 | ? | ? | ? | – | ? | ? | ? | – | ? |
Dargaud et al, 201728 | ? | ? | ? | – | ? | ? | ? | – | ? |
Dargaud et al, 200529 | – | ? | ? | – | ? | + | ? | – | ? |
Ellis-Kahana et al, 202039 | – | ? | ? | – | ? | ? | ? | – | ? |
Gassmann et al, 202130 | ? | ? | ? | – | ? | ? | ? | – | ? |
Hase et al, 201831 | ? | ? | ? | – | – | ? | ? | – | – |
Lindqvist et al, 200832 | – | ? | ? | – | ? | ? | ? | – | ? |
Lok et al, 201933 | ? | ? | – | – | – | + | ? | – | – |
Shacaluga and Rayment, 201934 | – | ? | ? | – | ? | ? | ? | – | ? |
Sultan et al, 201635 | – | ? | + | + | + | ? | + | – | ? |
Testa et al, 201536 | ? | ? | ? | – | ? | ? | ? | – | ? |
Tran et al, 201937 | – | ? | ? | – | ? | ? | ? | – | ? |
Weiss and Bernstein, 200038 | – | ? | ? | – | ? | ? | ? | – | ? |
+ indicates low risk of bias/low concern regarding applicability; –, indicates high risk of bias/high concern regarding applicability; and ? indicates unclear risk of bias/unclear concern regarding applicability