Table 4.
Outcomes | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Author | Location | N (Age) | Design | Intervention Protocol | PA | SB/Screen Time |
BMI | Motor Skills |
Barkin et al. (2012) |
United States | 106 children (M = 4.1 years) |
12-week RCT |
|
X * | |||
Bonvin et al. (2013) * |
Switzerland | 648 children (M = 3.3 years) |
9-month RCT |
|
X 0 | X 0 | X 0 | |
Davison et al. (2011) |
United States | 422 children (M = 3.4 years) |
12-month Pre- post measured (nonpaired quasi experimental) |
|
X * | X * | ||
Fitzgibbon et al. (2013) * | United States | 157 children (M = 4.5 years) |
14-week RCT |
|
X 0 | X 0 | X 0 | |
Laukkanen et al. (2017) * |
Finland | 44 children (M = 6.1 years) |
6-month RCT |
|
X * | X * | X 0 | |
Puder et al. (2011) * |
Switzerland | 652 children (M = 5.2 years) |
12-month RCT |
|
X 0 | X * | X 0 | X * |
Quattrin et al. (2012) * |
United States | 96 children (M = 4.6 years) |
12-week RCT |
|
X * | |||
Stark et al. (2014) * | United States | 18 children (M = 4.6 years) |
6-month RCT |
|
X 0 | X * | ||
Trost & Brookes (2021) * | Australia | 34 children (M = 5.3 years) |
8-week RCT |
|
X 0 | X * | ||
Tomayko et al. (2016) * |
United States | 150 children (M = 4.0 years) |
24-month RCT |
|
X 0 | X * | X * | |
Van de Kolk et al. (2019) | Netherlands | 191 children (M = 3.1 years) |
3-month Quasi- experimental design |
|
X * | X * | X 0 | |
Walton et al. (2015) | Canada | 48 children (M = 3.0 years) |
9-week RCT |
|
X 0 | X 0 | X 0 | |
Yin et al. (2012) | United States | 384 children (M = 4.1 years) |
18-week Quasi- experimental pretest/posttest design |
|
X * | X 0 | X * | X * |
Zask et al. (2012) * |
Australia | 560 children (M = 4.5 years) |
10-month RCT |
|
X * | X * |
Notes. Author citations containing * = those studies are also presented in Table 1. X * = significant positive effect at p < 0.05, X 0 = non-significant effect at p > 0.05, PA = physical activity, SB = sedentary behavior, BMI = body mass index.