Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 28;19(19):12378. doi: 10.3390/ijerph191912378

Table 8.

Diabetes classification results are shown in case-1, case-2, and case-3, where features are selected from the DDC-2017 dataset, DDC-2011 dataset, and both datasets, including missing value imputation and hyperparameter tuning. The metrics of the best-performing single model are highlighted in bold fonts, whereas the blue underlines are used to indicate them in the proposed ensemble models.

Cases Different Classifiers Sn ↑ Sp ↑ Acc ↑ AUC ↑
Merged datasets
(Case-1)
GNB 0.904±0.014 0.181±0.016 0.575±0.009 0.587±0.008
BNB 0.796±0.102 0.288±0.144 0.565±0.010 0.584±0.006
RF 1.000±0.000 0.000±0.000 0.545±0.000 0.545±0.000
DT 0.741±0.058 0.484±0.088 0.624±0.014 0.674±0.029
XGB 0.748±0.013 0.521±0.022 0.644±0.007 0.717±0.008
LGB 0.641±0.011 0.647±0.010 0.643±0.007 0.715±0.006
GNB + BNB 0.815±0.070 0.283±0.100 0.573±0.100 0.590±0.007
RF + DT 0.778±0.040 0.431±0.070 0.620±0.014 0.670±0.031
LGB + XGB 0.703±0.005 0.585±0.015¯ 0.649±0.008 0.721±0.007
GNB + BNB + DT + RF 0.839±0.026¯ 0.340±0.090 0.612±0.028 0.658±0.027
GNB + BNB + XGB + LGB 0.787±0.006 0.485±0.013 0.650±0.006¯ 0.722±0.009¯
DT + RF + XGB + LGB 0.746±0.016 0.531±0.020 0.649±0.006 0.721±0.006
GNB + BNB + DT + RF + XGB + LGB 0.803±0.012 0.461±0.019 0.647±0.003 0.720±0.007
Merged datasets
(Case-2)
GNB 0.904±0.014 0.181±0.016 0.575±0.009 0.587±0.008
BNB 0.796±0.102 0.288±0.144 0.565±0.010 0.584±0.006
RF 1.000±0.000 0.000±0.000 0.545±0.000 0.545±0.000
DT 0.754±0.023 0.442±0.051 0.612±0.014 0.655±0.022
XGB 0.734±0.023 0.529±0.027 0.641±0.009 0.715±0.009
LGB 0.644±0.005 0.650±0.014 0.647±0.006 0.715±0.006
GNB + BNB 0.815±0.070 0.283±0.100 0.573±0.010 0.590±0.007
RF + DT 0.835±0.032 0.344±0.053 0.612±0.014 0.652±0.022
LGB + XGB 0.696±0.014 0.589±0.017¯ 0.647±0.009 0.720±0.007
GNB + BNB + DT + RF 0.891±0.023¯ 0.247±0.065 0.598±0.018 0.647±0.021
GNB + BNB + XGB + LGB 0.783±0.009 0.492±0.014 0.650±0.004¯ 0.722±0.008¯
DT + RF + XGB + LGB 0.748±0.014 0.525±0.018 0.647±0.005 0.721±0.006
GNB + BNB + DT + RF + XGB + LGB 0.810±0.008 0.456±0.022 0.649±0.006 0.720±0.007
Merged datasets
(Case-3)
GNB 0.912±0.014 0.136±0.053 0.559±0.020 0.579±0.017
BNB 1.000±0.000 0.000±0.000 0.545±0.000 0.545±0.000
RF 1.000±0.000 0.000±0.000 0.545±0.000 0.545±0.000
DT 1.000±0.000 0.000±0.000 0.545±0.000 0.545±0.000
XGB 0.712±0.012 0.560±0.008 0.643±0.007 0.714±0.010
LGB 0.650±0.010 0.654±0.013 0.652±0.008 0.724±0.010
GNB + BNB 0.966±0.023 0.043±0.014 0.545±0.008 0.576±0.012
RF + DT 1.000±0.000¯ 0.000±0.000 0.545±0.000 0.545±0.000
LGB + XGB 0.690±0.009 0.609±0.005 0.653±0.006 0.726±0.010
GNB + BNB + DT + RF 0.983±0.021 0.016±0.018 0.543±0.003 0.577±0.010
GNB + BNB + XGB + LGB 0.788±0.018 0.493±0.035 0.653±0.010 0.726±0.012
DT + RF + XGB + LGB 0.761±0.009 0.530±0.005¯ 0.656±0.005¯ 0.728±0.009¯
GNB + BNB + DT + RF + XGB + LGB 0.834±0.017 0.428±0.036 0.649±0.012 0.722±0.012