Table 3.
Additional procedures, survival, and Harris Hip Score.
| Study | No. of hips | Additional procedure | Survival | Harris Hip Score |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preoperative | Postoperative | ||||
| Zhang 2019 | 63 | Morselized allografting for acetabular protrusion | 16 years: 96.8% (EP = reoperation) | 46 | 83 |
| Zhou 2018 | 77 | Bulk allograft (2 hips) and impaction bone grafting (12 hips) was used in Paprosky type III acetabular bone loss | 4 years: 94.2% (EP = radiological or clinical failure) | 46.7 ± 13.2 | 83.1 ± 9.0 |
| Salem 2018 | 17 | Particulate bone grafting from the iliac crest | No re-revision at last follow-up (mean 3.5 years) | 42 (24–59) | 85 (72–92) |
| Moon 2018 | 80 | Structural bone allograft (4 hips), morselized bone allograft (47 hips) | 16 years: 85% (worst); 91% (best) | 53 | 77 |
| McLaughlin 2018 | 30 | Packing acetabular deficiencies with allograft bone chips and local bone obtained from reaming | 16 years: 92.6% (EP = re-revision); 97.4% (EP = cup aseptic loosening) | 49 (37–59) | 86 (64–94) |
| Jo 2016 | 51 | Autogenic (ipsilateral iliac crest) or allogenic (fresh-frozen chip bone) morselized bone graft for medial cavitary bone defect | 13 years: 86.3% (EP = implant failure) | NA | No rim fixation: 75 ± 7.6 Rim fixation: 85 ± 8.5 |
| von Roth 2015 and Whaley 2001 | 89 | Particulate bone grafting (54 hips), and bulk bone grafting (9 hips) | 20 years: 83% (free from any acetabular revision), 88% (free from aseptic loosening of the metal acetabular component), and 85% (free from aseptic or radiographic definite loosening of the metal acetabular component) | 56 | 71 (30–95) |
| Gustke 2014 and Gustke 2004 | 216 | Particulate autografting (51 hips), particulate allografting (49 hips), bulk allografting (38 hips) | 4 years: 98%; 16y:96% (acetabular component) | 44 | 72 |
| Lachiewicz 2013 | 108 | Bone grafting (108 hips): crushed cancellous allograft only (98 hips), iliac crest autograft (4 hips), both allograft and autograft (5 hips) | 10 years: 97.3%, 15 years: 82.8% (EP = either acetabular cup revision for aseptic loosening or definite radiographic evidence of loosening); 10 years: 93.8%, 15 years: 79.8% (EP = acetabular cup removal for any reason); 10 years: 88.5%, 15 years: 56.5% (EP = any reoperation involving the hip) |
NA | |
| Wedemeyer 2008 | 17 | Morselized bone graft (15 hips) | NA | 62 | 83 |
| Fan 2008 | 47 | Allograft bone graft (25 patients) | 5 years: 94.5% (EP = implant failure) | NA | |
| Hendricks 2006 and Dearborn 2000 | 24 | Particulate autologous or allograft bone packing acetabular defects | NA | 54 (31–82) | 79 (46–98) |
| Patel 2003 | 43 | Bulk allograft (8 hips), morselized allograft alone (27 hips) | Acetabular shell: 14 years: 92%; acetabular shell: 13 years: 83% |
48 ± 15 | 81 ± 18 |
| Obenaus 2003 | 60 | Press-fit structural allografting (7 hips), mixture of autologous slurry and allogenic bone chips (10 hips) | NA | 58.7 (28–97.7) | 90.6 (61.1–100) |
EP, ending point.