Table 5.
Predictors of relapse among both groups (relapsed and abstinent), with regard to ASI
| Relapsed group | Abstinent group | Test of significance | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| N=76 (50.7%) | N=74 (49.3%) | Test | p value | Sig. | ||
| ASI- Medical | No problem | 0 (0%) | 1 (1.35%) | Fisher’s Exact test | 0.522 | NS |
| Slight problem | 43 (56.58%) | 42 (56.76%) | ||||
| Moderate problem, some ttt indicated | 6 (7.89%) | 9 (12.16%) | ||||
| Considerable problem, ttt necessary | 2 (2.63%) | 0 (0%) | ||||
| Extreme problem, ttt absolutely necessary | 25 (32.89%) | 22 (29.73%) | ||||
| ASI –Legal | No problem | 39 (51.32%) a | 56 (75.68%) b | X2= 12.525 | 0.014 | S |
| Slight problem | 3 (3.95%) a | 1 (1.35%) a | ||||
| Moderate problem, some ttt indicated | 6 (7.89%) a | 5 (6.76%) a | ||||
| Considerable problem, ttt necessary | 9 (11.84%) a | 7 (9.46%) a | ||||
| Extreme problem, ttt absolutely necessary | 19 (25%) a | 5 (6.76%) b | ||||
| ASI –occupational | No problem | 0 (0%) | 1 (1.35%) | Fisher’s Exact test | 0.475 | NS |
| Slight problem | 0 (0%) | 1 (1.35%) | ||||
| Moderate problem, some ttt indicated | 13 (17.11%) | 15 (20.27%) | ||||
| Considerable problem, ttt necessary | 26 (34.21%) | 29 (39.19%) | ||||
| Extreme problem, ttt absolutely necessary | 37 (48.68%) | 28 (37.84%) | ||||
| ASI-Substance | Moderate problem, some ttt indicated | 1 (1.32%) a | 5 (6.76%) a | Fisher’s Exact test | 0.023 | S |
| Considerable problem, ttt necessary | 30 (39.47%) a | 40 (54.05%) a | ||||
| Extreme problem, ttt absolutely necessary | 45 (59.21%) a | 29 (39.19%) b | ||||
| ASI-social | Moderate problem, some ttt indicated | 13 (17.11%) a | 26 (35.14%) b | X2= 6.335 | 0.042 | S |
| Considerable problem, ttt necessary | 50 (65.79%) a | 38 (51.35%) a | ||||
| Extreme problem, ttt absolutely necessary | 13 (17.11%) a | 10 (13.51%) a | ||||
| ASI-Psychiatric | No problem | 0 (0%) | 1 (1.35%) | Fisher’s Exact test | 0.208 | NS |
| Slight problem | 35 (46.05%) | 43 (58.11%) | ||||
| Moderate problem, some ttt indicated | 31 (40.79%) | 20 (27.03%) | ||||
| Considerable problem, ttt necessary | 10 (13.16%) | 10 (13.51%) | ||||
P value > 0.05: significant; S significant, NS non-significant, N number, ASI addiction severity index, ttt treatment
Each superscript letter (a and b) denotes a subset of Group categories whose column proportions do not differ significantly from each other at the .05 level