Table 4.
Black shale area | Reference area | Well water in Finlandd | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Quaternary deposit wells (n = 49) | Bedrock wells (n = 15) | Quaternary deposit wells (n = 11) | Bedrock wells (n = 17) | Quaternary deposit wells (n = 739) | Bedrock wells (n = 263) | |
Water Mn µg/l | ||||||
Median | 5.07a, b | 24.9b | 1.77a, c | 7.84c | 4.36 | 16.3 |
2%–maximum | 0.34–1620 | 0.28–172 | 0.42–12.90 | 0.94–289 | 0.1–5330 | 0.2–4140 |
Hair Mn mg/kg | ||||||
Median | 0.94 | 2.03 | 0.83c | 1.37c | ||
2%–maximum | 0.20–11.1 | 0.27–9.04 | 0.25–9.83 | 0.21–36.44 | ||
Water Ni µg/l | ||||||
Median | 3.83b | 0.65b | 4.55c | 1.17c | 0.84 | 0.595 |
2%– maximum | 0.32–51.0 | 0.15–8.15 | 1.10–8.87 | 0.03–9.15 | 0.06–277 | < 0.06–67.50 |
Hair Ni mg/kg | ||||||
Median | 0.85b | 0.49b | 0.86 | 0.77 | ||
2%–maximum | 0.15–12.3 | 0.15–2.2 | 0.44–4.3 | 0.15–8.0 |
aMann–Whitney U-test: difference in Mn concentrations in water between Quaternary deposit wells of black shale and reference areas, p = 0.018
bMann–Whitney U-test: difference in Mn and Ni concentrations between Quaternary deposit and bedrock wells in the black shale areas, Mn in water p = 0.002, Ni in water p < 0.001, Ni in hair p = 0.007
cMann–Whitney U-test: difference in Mn and Ni concentrations between Quaternary deposit and bedrock wells of the reference areas, Mn in water p = 0.006, Mn in hair p = 0.047, Ni in water p = 0.003
dLahermo et al. (2002)