Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 22;53(11):14249–14268. doi: 10.1007/s10489-022-04221-9

Table 8.

Results of Wilcoxon signed-rank paired sampled test between the presented TextConvoNet_6, TextConvoNet_4, and other techniques/models (* showing the groups with the statistically significant difference)

Comparison Group P-value Effect r Comparison Group P-value Effect r
TextConvoNet_6 (Two-tailed) Vs. TextConvoNet_4 3.36E-05* 0.463 TextConvoNet_4 (Two-tailed) Vs. Yoonkim 0.00017* 0.419
Yoonkim 1.63E-07* 0.585 LSTM 3.36E-05* 0.463
LSTM 4.66E-08* 0.61 VDCNN 6.75E-07* 0.55
VDCNN 2.77E-07* 0.574 CLSTM 1.83E-05* 0.479
CLSTM 5.47E-08* 0.607 MNB 0.00039* 0.395
MNB 1.72E-06* 0.534 RF 4.66E-08* 0.61
RF 6.40E-08* 0.604 DT 6.50E-09* 0.648
DT 6.50E-09* 0.648 SVC 1.22E-05* 0.489
SVC 1.76E-07 0.83 GBC 1.29E-07* 0.59
GBC 1.76E-07* 0.583 KNN 9.89E-09* 0.64
KNN 1.07E-08* 0.639 XGBoost 5.82E-05* 0.449
XGBoost 1.20E-07 0.591 BiLSTM + Attention 8.79E-05* 0.438
BiLSTM + Attention 1.29E-08* 0.635 BERT 1.37E-08* 0.634
BERT 1.37E-08 0.634 HAN 1.50E-07* 0.587
HAN 1.16E-08* 0.638 BerConvoNet 0.055 0.178
BerConvoNet 0.00011* 0.412 CNN-BiLSTM 0.070 0.164
CNN-BiLSTM 1.05E-06* 0.53 TLGNN 4.66E-09* 0.64
TLGNN 4.66E-09* 0.642 SeqGNN 1.73E-05* 0.462
SeqGNN 3.8E-06* 0.50

*MNB= Multinomial Naïve Bayes, RF= Random Forest, DT= Decision Tree, SVC= Support Vector Classifier, GBC= Gradient Boosting Classifier