Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 26;22:1964. doi: 10.1186/s12889-022-14385-1

Table 3.

Studies included in the review

First author and publication year Study designs Population groups Domains Barriers and facilitators investigated AMSTAR-2 rating

Abaraogu U

2018 [14]

8 cross-sectional

4 cohort

5 qualitative

1 mixed-methods

Older adults Leisure

Better skills

Better/More positive general social support

Existence of facilities within places

Higher motivation and having goals

More positive beliefs about consequences

More/Better knowledge

Participation in supervised activities

Worse health condition

Moderate

Aranda-Balboa M

2020 [15]

27 cross-sectional Adults Travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better road safety

Better street connectivity

Better/More positive general social support

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Broekhuizen K

2014 [16]

17 observational

16 experimental

Children and adolescents Education

Availability of personal equipment

Better general urban design and built environment

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of facilities within places

Longer recess duration

Participation in supervised activities

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Brunton G

2005 [17]

5 experimental

5 qualitative

Children and adolescents Leisure

Better public transport provision

Better road safety

Better skills

Better/More positive social norms

Better/More positive support from family

Better/More positive support from friends

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Pleasure and fun with physical activity

Higher motivation and having goals

Higher physical activity of friends and family

Lack of time and presence of concurrent behaviours

Lower costs

More positive beliefs about consequences

Negative emotions

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Bunn F

2008 [18]

6 cross-sectional

4 experimental

14 qualitative

Adults Leisure

Better quality of instructors

Better quality of physical activity programs

Better/More positive general social support

More positive beliefs about capabilities

More positive beliefs about consequences

More/Better knowledge

Negative emotions

Positive past experiences

Moderate

Congello N

2018 [19]

1 experimental

3 qualitative

3 mixed-methods

Adults and older adults Leisure

Better public transport provision

Better/More positive social norms

Better/More positive support from friends

Lack of time and presence of concurrent behaviours

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Craike M

2019 [20]

67 cross-sectional

6 cohort

Adults Leisure

Better walkability

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive social norms

Better/More positive support from family

Better/More positive support from friends

More positive beliefs about capabilities

More positive beliefs about consequences

Quality and condition of places

Worse health condition

Worse perceived safety

Low

D’Haese S

2015 [21]

61 cross-sectional

4 cohort

Children Leisure and travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better land use mix

Better road safety

Better street connectivity

Better walkability

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of facilities within places

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Low

Day K

2018 [22]

143 cross-sectional

16 cohort

Adolescents, adults, and older adults Leisure, travel, and work/education

Better general urban design and built environment

Better road safety

Low

Dennett R

2020 [23]

41 experimental Adults and older adults Leisure

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive support from friends

Better/More positive support from others

Higher motivation and having goals

More/Better knowledge

High

Elshahat S

2020 [24]

32 cross-sectional

1 case study

Adults and older adults Leisure and travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better land use mix

Better public transport provision

Better road safety

Better street connectivity

Better walkability

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of facilities within places

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Escalante Y

2014 [25]

8 experimental Children and adolescents Work/Education

Existence of facilities within places

Quality and condition of places

Low

Farrance C

2016 [26]

5 experimental

3 qualitative

2 mixed-methods

Older adults Leisure

Better quality of instructors

Better quality of physical activity programs

Better/More positive social norms

More positive beliefs about consequences

Positive past experiences

Moderate

Hilland T

2020 [27]

32 cross-sectional

3 cohort

Adults and older adults Leisure and travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better walkability

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive social norms

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

More positive beliefs about consequences

Quality and condition of places

Worse health condition

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Hutzler Y

2010 [28]

7 cross-sectional

12 experimental

4 qualitative

Adolescents and adults Leisure

Better public transport provision

Better skills

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive support from family

More positive beliefs about capabilities

More positive beliefs about consequences

Low

Ikeda E

2018 [29]

31 cross-sectional

5 cohort

1 case–control

Children and adolescents Travel

Better land use mix

Better road safety

Better walkability

Better/More positive social norms

Better/More positive support from family

Better/More positive support from friends

Better/More positive support from others

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Jaarsma E

2014 [30]

51 cross-sectional

3 cohort

3 experimental

Adolescents, adults, and older adults Leisure

Better general urban design and built environment

Better skills

Better/More positive social norms

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Pleasure and fun with physical activity

Higher motivation and having goals

Lack of time and presence of concurrent behaviours

Lower costs

More positive beliefs about consequences

More/Better knowledge

Worse health condition

Moderate

Kärmeniemi M

2018 [31]

21 cohort

30 experimental

Children, adolescents, adults, and older adults Leisure and travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better walkability

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of facilities within places

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Liangruenrom M

2019 [32]

167 cross-sectional Children, adolescents, adults, and older adults Leisure, travel, work/education, and household

Better general urban design and built environment

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive support from family

Better/More positive support from friends

Better/More positive support from others

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Pleasure and fun with physical activity

Lack of time and presence of concurrent behaviours

More positive beliefs about capabilities

More positive beliefs about consequences

More/Better knowledge

Positive past experiences

Worse health condition

Moderate

Lindsay Smith G

2017 [33]

22 cross-sectional

3 cohort

2 experimental

Older adults Leisure

Better/More positive general social support

Negative emotions

Moderate

Lorenc T

2008 [34]

16 qualitative Children, adolescents, and adults Travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better road safety

Better skills

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive social norms

Better/More positive support from family

Better/More positive support from friends

Better/More positive support from others

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Pleasure and fun with physical activity

Higher motivation and having goals

Lack of time and presence of concurrent behaviours

Lower costs

More positive beliefs about capabilities

More positive beliefs about consequences

Negative emotions

Quality and condition of places

Worse health condition

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Maitland C

2013 [35]

38 observational

11 experimental

Adolescents Leisure

Availability of personal equipment

Better/More positive support from family

Higher physical activity of friends and family

Moderate

Mendonça G

2014 [36]

64 cross-sectional

9 cohort

2 experimental

Adolescents Leisure and travel

Better/More positive support from family

Better/More positive support from friends

Low

Olekszechen N

2016 [37]

25 cross-sectional

3 experimental

5 qualitative

Adults Travel

Availability of personal equipment

Better land use mix

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive social norms

Existence of facilities within places

Lack of time and presence of concurrent behaviours

More positive beliefs about consequences

Negative emotions

Positive past experiences

Low

Pan X

2021 [38]

14 cross-sectional

2 cohort

5 experimental

Children and adolescents Travel

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

High

Pollard T

2017 [39]

36 cross-sectional Adults and older adults Leisure and travel Pleasure and fun with physical activity High

Pont K

2009 [40]

38 cross-sectional Children and adolescents Travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better road safety

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Rhodes R

2013 [41]

8 cross-sectional

52 cohort

Adolescents, adults, and older adults Leisure

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Pleasure and fun with physical activity

Higher motivation and having goals

Lack of time and presence of concurrent behaviours

More positive beliefs about capabilities

Negative emotions

Positive past experiences

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Rhodes R

2020 [42]

37 cross-sectional

9 cohort

Children, adolescents, adults, and older adults Leisure and travel

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive social norms

Higher motivation and having goals

More positive beliefs about consequences

Moderate

Ridgers N

2012 [43]

42 cross-sectional

11 not specified

Children and adolescents Work/Education

Better quality of physical activity programs

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive social norms

Existence of facilities within places

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Pleasure and fun with physical activity

Higher motivation and having goals

Lack of time and presence of concurrent behaviours

Longer recess duration

Participation in supervised activities

Quality and condition of places

Moderate

Rothman L

2018 [44]

61 cross-sectional

1 case–control

1 mixed-methods

Children and adolescents Travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better road safety

Existence of active travel infrastructure

More positive beliefs about consequences

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Salvo G

2018 [45]

36 qualitative Adults and older adults Leisure and travel

Better road safety

Better street connectivity

Better/More positive social norms

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of facilities within places

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Negative emotions

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Low

Scarapicchia T

2017 [46]

20 cohort Adults Leisure

Availability of personal equipment

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive support from family

Better/More positive support from friends

Positive past experiences

Moderate

Smith M

2017 [47]

15 cross-sectional

12 cohort

1 experimental

Children, adolescents, adults, and older adults Travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better land use mix

Better public transport provision

Better road safety

Better street connectivity

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of facilities within places

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Quality and condition of places

Moderate

Stanley R

2012 [48]

17 cross-sectional

5 experimental

Adolescents Leisure and work/education

Availability of personal equipment

Better land use mix

Better quality of physical activity programs

Better/More positive general social support

Better/More positive support from family

Better/More positive support from friends

Better/More positive support from others

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of facilities within places

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Pleasure and fun with physical activity

Higher physical activity of friends and family

Longer recess duration

More positive beliefs about capabilities

More positive beliefs about consequences

Participation in supervised activities

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Stappers N

2018 [49]

1 cross-sectional

4 cohort

10 experimental

4 not specified

Adults Leisure and travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better public transport provision

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Low

Tovar M

2018 [50]

21 cross-sectional Adults and older adults Leisure

Better/More positive general social support

More positive beliefs about capabilities

Worse health condition

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Van Cauwenberg J

2011 [51]

28 cross-sectional

3 cohort

Older adults Leisure and travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better land use mix

Better public transport provision

Better road safety

Better street connectivity

Better walkability

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Van Cauwenberg J

2018 [52]

71 cross-sectional

1 cohort

Older adults Leisure

Better land use mix

Better public transport provision

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Quality and condition of places

Low

Van Hecke L

2018 [53]

14 cross-sectional

17 qualitative

Adolescents Leisure

Availability of personal equipment

Better public transport provision

Better road safety

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of facilities within places

Quality and condition of places

Moderate

Van Holle V

2012 [54]

69 cross-sectional

1 cohort

Adults and older adults Leisure and travel

Better general urban design and built environment

Better public transport provision

Better road safety

Better walkability

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate

Xiao C

2019 [55]

9 experimental Adults Travel Better public transport provision Moderate

Yarmohammadi, S

2019 [56]

20 cross-sectional

14 qualitative

Older adults Leisure

Better general urban design and built environment

Better/More positive general social support

Existence of facilities within places

Higher motivation and having goals

Lack of time and presence of concurrent behaviours

Lower costs

More positive beliefs about consequences

Negative emotions

Participation in supervised activities

Quality and condition of places

Worse health condition

Moderate

Zhang R

2019 [57]

25 cross-sectional Children, adolescents, adults, and older adults Leisure

Better road safety

Better/More positive social norms

Better/More positive support from family

Better/More positive support from friends

Existence of active travel infrastructure

Existence of facilities within places

Existence of, shorter distance to, and better access to places

Quality and condition of places

Worse perceived safety

Moderate