Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 21;9(10):594. doi: 10.3390/bioengineering9100594

Table 1.

Risk of bias of the studies included in this review: the green symbol represents a low risk of bias, while the yellow symbol represents a high risk of bias.

Random Sequence Generation Allocation Concealment Blinding Incomplete Outcome Data Selective Reporting
Aslan et al., 2020
[9]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Paolantonio et al., 2020
[10]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Gautam et al., 2022
[11]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Górski et al., 2020
[12]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Gamal et al., 2014
[13]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Aggour et al., 2017
[14]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Hazari et al., 2021
[15]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Cieplik et al., 2018
[16]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Temraz et al., 2019
[17]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Ferrarotti et al., 2018
[18]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Chen et al., 2016
[19]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Gonçalves et al., 2008
[20]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Rani et al., 2018
[21]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Bajaj et al., 2013
[22]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Queiroz et al., 2016
[23]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Pajnigara et al., 2017
[24]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Huidrom et al., 2022
[25]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Sneha et al., 2021
[26]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Isehed et al., 2018
[27]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Lee et al., 2020
[28]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Jo et al., 2019
[29]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Stumbras et al., 2021
[30]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Saito et al., 2021
[31]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Gonshor et al., 2011
[32]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Majzoub et al., 2020
[33]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Canullo et al., 2019
[34]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Kadkhodazadeh et al., 2021
[35]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Chiapasco et al., 2020
[36]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Beretta et al., 2021
[37]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Manavella et al., 2018
[38]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Zafiropoulos et al., 2020
[39]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Beretta et al., 2015
[40]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Yoshikawa et al., 2020
[41]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Thakkalapati et al., 2015
[42]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Pal et al., 2018
[43]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Zhou et al., 2020
[44]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Panda et al., 2016
[45]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Bassi et al., 2015
[46]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Poli et al., 2020
[47]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Bhide et al., 2022
[48]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Park et al., 2018
[49]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Jensen et al., 2013
[50]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Maeda et al., 2021
[51]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Urban et al., 2021
[52]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Blume et al., 2021
[53]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Urban et al., 2022
[54]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Khojasteh et al., 2019
[55]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg
Windisch et al., 2021
[56]
graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i002.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg graphic file with name bioengineering-09-00594-i001.jpg