Table 1.
Comparison of SR servo motor with brushes and hybrid stepper motor or BLDC motor.
Features | Servo Motor SR (Brushed) |
Step Motor (Hybrid) or BLDC Motor |
---|---|---|
Cost | The cost of a servo motor or servo system is greater than the cost of a step motor system with the same rated power. | Step motors are generally cheaper than servo motors that have the same rated power value. |
Size | They are available in a wide variety of sizes from small to very large motors and can operate huge machines. | In the step motors, there are not as many size options as in servo motors, especially for large sizes. |
Noise | Servo motors produce very little noise compared to step motors. | They produce a small hum due to the screening process. However, a high-quality driving system reduces the level of this noise. |
Power range | They are available in DC and AC motors and thus have a very wide range of available power. | The range of available power in step motors is smaller than in servo motors. |
Performance | In general, servo motors are very efficient motors. In small loads mainly, a yield of 80–90% is reported. | The step motors consume enough power, a lot of which is converted into heat. Usually, their performance is at about 70% and depends on the driving system. |
Life | Coolers every 2000 h of operation must be replaced. Codecs may also be needed to replace them | The only place that wears out is the bearing. This gives the step motors a slight lead. |
Low speed high torque | They work very well in low-speed applications, mainly due to very low friction. | They provide more torque at low speeds (RPM). |
High speed high torque | They maintain rated torque at about 90% of their speed without load. | Step motors lose up to 80% of their maximum torque, at 90% of their maximum speed. |
Power ratio by weight/size | Given the effectiveness of the servo motors, they have an excellent power ratio in terms of weight and size. | Step motors are less efficint than servo motors. This usually means a lower motor size power–weight ratio. |