Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 13;9:967887. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2022.967887

Table 2.

Mapping matrix of potential intervention functions, policy categories and Behavior Change Techniques (BCI) to previously identified determinants of inappropriate statin prescription and healthy lifestyle promotion categorized by Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) dimensions identified from the qualitative study.

TDF What needs to change (statin
prescription/healthy lifestyle
promotion)
Intervention function policy
category
Potential BCTs
Knowledge Be aware of the problem of inappropriate statin prescription Education Feedback on behavior
Training Feedback on outcome of the behavior
Be knowledgeable of the CVD prevention clinical guidelines, especially regarding adequate or recommended care depending on actual CVD risk Persuasion
Enablement
Information about social and health consequences
Credible source
Have updated and unified clinical practice criteria based on independent scientific evidence Information about others' approval
Regulation (principles of practice) Social comparison
Be aware of the beneficial impact of healthy lifestyles for the prevention of CVD (professionals and patients) Guidelines (mandating changes to adequate service provision) Service provision (training) Instruction on how to perform a behavior
Demonstration of the behavior
Be knowledgeable of the evidence-based healthy lifestyle promotion intervention in primary care (physical activity and healthy diet) Communication/marketing Behavioral practice/ rehearsal
Habit formation
Behavioral substitution
Goal setting (behavior)
Action planning
Self-monitoring of behavior
Review behavior goal(s)
Problem solving
Cognitive and interpersonal skills Increase skills to estimate and to address/communicate on CVD risk with a focus that goes beyond the numbers and risk factors Education Instruction on how to perform a behavior
Increase skills for appropriate statin prescription Training Demonstration of the behavior
Persuasion Behavioral practice/rehearsal
Have skills in prescribing physical activity and other healthy lifestyles (healthy diet, giving up smoking) Enablement Feedback on behavior
Environmental restructuring Review behavior goal(s)
Have a standardized protocol that facilitates clinical actions to promote habits Self-monitoring of behavior
Service provision (continued training/tools) Adding object to the environment
Guidelines (mandating changes related to service provision) Prompts /Cues
Communication/marketing Goal setting (behavior)
Regulation Action planning
Self-monitoring of behavior
Memory, attention, and decision processes Remember to provide the recommended clinical practice in CVD primary prevention Training Prompts/cues
Environmental restructuring Framing/reframing
Remove visual cues that induce an inappropriate approach to high cholesterol in low-risk patients Enablement Adding objects to the environment
Environmental planning Restructuring the physical environment
Avoidance/reducing exposure to cues for the behavior (inappropriate statin prescription)
Behavioral regulation Reflect on the performance/practice of inappropriate prescription of statins in primary prevention of CVD Education
Training
Goal setting (behavior)
Feedback on behavior
Have clear and specific objectives, at a personal and organizational level, in reduction of inappropriate statin prescription in primary prevention of CVD Modeling
Enablement
Self-monitoring of behavior
Have access to data on inappropriate statin prescribing in primary prevention of CVD. Service provision (auditing)
Have access to healthy lifestyles promotion practice data
Environmental context and resources Have a simple tool that favors correct estimation of CVR, according to evidence, that considers additional characteristics of the people (e.g., antecedents) Environmental restructuring
Enablement
Adding/Removing object to the environment
Prompts /Cues
Have support systems in the electronic records that remind about and promote practice in primary prevention of CVD according to the CPGs (avoiding statins and recommending promotion of lifestyles) Restriction

Training
Avoidance/reducing exposure to cues for the behavior
Restructuring the physical environment
Restrict or impede the inappropriate prescription of statins because of simplicity and speed of clinical prescribing conduct Framing/reframing
Guidelines Behavior substitution
Having tools for a feasible (fast) and effective intervention in healthy lifestyles Service provision (IT support tools in EHR and training) Habit formation
Associative learning
Having access to resources within/outside the health care setting to favor the provision of recommended primary prevention of CVD practice (i.e., healthy lifestyle resources in the community) Action planning
Goal-setting (behavior) (organization level)
Nursing participation in the primary prevention of CVD: provision of the recommended intervention to avoid inappropriate prescription Demonstration of the behavior
Review behavior goals
Review outcome goals
Social influences Patients should be aware of the problem of inappropriate statin prescribing: Risks vs. Benefits Persuasion
Education
Information about social and health consequences
Feedback on behavioral outcomes
Patients must have knowledge of the criteria and practice guidelines: cholesterol, CVD, CVR (patients) Environmental restructuring
Restriction
Credible source
Prompts/cues
The general population must be aware of the problem of excessive medication Enablement Framing/reframing
Exposure
The organization must continuously become aware of the problem of inappropriate prescription of statins in healthcare practice (Adaptation; Priority health policies) Communication/marketing
Regulation (organizational priority & standards)
Review behavior goals
Review outcome goals
The organization must have up-to-date clinical criteria, established in the guidelines based on independent scientific evidence Environmental/social planning
Guidelines
Discrepancy between current behavior and goal
Instructions on how to perform the behavior
The organization must have a focus beyond the figures and risk factors, both in CPGs and in risk-screening tools and/or interventions Legislation Action planning
Habit reversal
Advertising or promoting the use of statins in primary prevention of CVD should be restricted Commitment
Removing objects to the environment
Avoidance/reducing exposure to cues for the behavior
Professional/social role and identity Believe that adequate CVD prevention is considered important at their peer and organizational level Education
Persuasion
Information about social and health consequences
Feedback on outcomes of the behavior
Be clear about the criteria for action and responsibilities at the inter-institutional and inter-sectorial level (external: e.g., business medicine) in CVD prevention, based on indication (primary, secondary prevention, etc.) Modeling
Enablement
Credible source
Social comparison
Understand that the role of the doctor goes beyond prescribing drugs Information about others' approval
Communication/marketing Identity associated with changed behavior
Family Medicine and Community Health professionals establishment should be the protagonists (leadership, responsibility) in primary prevention of CVD Regulation (organizational priority & standards) Valued identity
Guidelines (mandating changes to practice and service provision) Review behavior goals
Get other professionals (nurses) involved in the optimization of primary prevention of CVD Service provision Review outcome goals
Discrepancy between current behavior and goal
Instructions on how to perform the behavior
Action planning
Habit reversal
Commitment
Beliefs about consequences Perceive that not prescribing statins in primary prevention of CVD is not “not treating” Education
Persuasion
Demonstration of the behavior
Feedback on outcome(s) of behavior
Perceive that statins are not more effective than the promotion of habits to avoid CV events in primary prevention of CVD Modeling Information about health consequences
Incentivization Information about social and environmental consequences
Perceive that the statin, in primary prevention of CVD, may have adverse effects and is not entirely safe Credible source
Communication/marketing Identity associated with changed behavior
Have an expectation of the benefits of healthy lifestyle promotion actions (short, medium and long term) Guidelines (evidence diffusion) Valued identity
Service provision (continued training) Information about others' approval
Social support
Incompatible beliefs
Incentive
Beliefs about capabilities Perceive that one is able and has the necessary skills to provide the healthy lifestyle promotion Education Feedback on behavior
Training Focus on past success
Perceive that statin prescribing is not such a simple (low skill) or safe practice Persuasion Verbal persuasion about
Modeling capability
Perceive that one is competent and confident enough to carry out the CV risk screening process Enablement Vicarious consequences Information about social an environmental consequences
Information about health consequences
Perceive that one is competent and confident enough to respond to the sporadic arrival of patients in the target population for CVD primary prevention (they come infrequently), through the promotion of good habits Guidelines Demonstration of the behavior
Service provision (auditing and provision) (continued training) Instruction on how to perform a behavior
Perceive that statin treatment is not so easy for the patient (dosage) Behavioral practice/ rehearsal
Credible source
Have a sense of self-confidence in prescription of physical activity and other healthy lifestyles Problem solving
Action planning
Not have a perception of difficulty in modifying lifestyles (compared to taking a pill) Social support (practical)
Problem solving
Intentions Should have a strong intention not to prescribe statins inappropriately in primary prevention of CVD Education Information about health consequences
Persuasion Information about social and environmental consequences
Should have a strong intention to provide interventions to promote healthy habits for the primary prevention of CVD Incentivization Credible source
Modeling Identity associated with changed behavior
Discrepancy between current behavior and goal
Communication/marketing (evidence diffusion) Instructions on how to perform the behavior
Regulation (organizational priority & standards) Action planning
Guidelines (mandating changes to service provision) Habit reversal
Commitment
Feedback on outcome(s) of behavior
Incompatible beliefs
Incentive
Verbal persuasion about capability
Goals Have organizational objectives related to the reduction of inappropriate prescription of statins in primary prevention of CVD Education Review behavior goals
Persuasion Review outcome goals
Should consider the practice of primary prevention of CVD a priority in accordance with the recommendations. Incentivization Discrepancy between current behavior and goal
Modeling Instructions on how to perform the behavior
Should be committed to carrying out a practice of primary prevention of CVD according to the recommendations Enablement Goal-setting (behavior)
Action planning
Have the motivation (priority and commitment) to promote lifestyles in primary prevention of CVD Regulation (organizational priority & standards) Commitment
Guidelines (mandating changes to adequate service provision) Service provision (training) Self-monitoring of behavior
Monitoring of behavior by others
Feedback on behavior
Feedback on outcomes of the behavior
Reinforcement Receive positive or negative reinforcement related to adequate ECV prevention performance Training
Incentivization
Feedback on behavior
Material incentive
Should avoid prescribing out of habit, routine or inertia (to treat cholesterol) Coercion (behavior)
Environmental restructuring Material reward
Social reward
Service provision (auditing) Reward alternative
Regulation (principles of practice) behavior
Avoidance/reducing exposure to cues for the behavior (inappropriate statin prescription)
Emotion Not feel threatened (fear) for not prescribing a drug Education
Persuasion
Feedback on behavior
Feel confident about not prescribing a statin for CVD primary prevention Incentivization
Coercion
Information about health consequences
Credible source
Experience positive feelings/emotions associated with not doing defensive medicine
Guidelines
Discrepancy between current behavior and goal
Anticipated regret
Experience negative emotions when making an inappropriate prescription Communication and marketing
Regulation
Remove aversive stimulus
Information about others' approval
Feel safe and confident with the action guidelines Social support

Target behavior: Reduce the prescription of statins in the context of the primary prevention of CVD in low-risk patients and favor the promotion of healthy habits (regular physical activity, healthy diet and giving up smoking) at any opportunistic or programmed office visit for screening or addressing CVD risk factor and/or prevention.