Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 11;10(10):2009. doi: 10.3390/microorganisms10102009

Table 1.

Main characteristics of studies reporting about gut microbiota in children and adolescents with psychiatric disorders.

Ref. No Study Year Country Sample Size Gender %
M/F
Mean Age
in Years
Mean BMI Diagnostic Tool
Patients Controls
Sample Storage Medication
Use *
Dietary Questionnaire Evaluation
of GIT Symptoms
ASD + PDD − NOS
[19] Cao et al. 2021 China ASD: 45
HC: 41
ASD: 80/20
HC: 82.9/17.1
ASD: 6.8
HC: 5.2
ASD: 16.6
HC: 15.2
AMSE
CARS
CABS
DSM-5
Psychiatric evaluation
ASD psychometric tests
Microbial preservation solution was used, samples stored at room temperature No ATB, probiotic or psychiatric medication prior sample collection N/A N/A
[25] Kang et al. 2018 USA ASD: 23
HC: 21
ASD: 95.7/4.3
HC: 71.4/28.6
ASD: 8.4
HC: 10.1
N/A ATEC
PDD-BI
N/A −80 °C No ATB or antifungal drugs 1 month prior sample collection yes 6-GSI
[26] Carissimi et al. 2019 Italy ASD: 30
HC: 14
ASD: 96.7/3.3
HC: 50/50
Median age
ASD: 3
HC: 10
N/A DSM-5
ADOS-2
GMDS
N/A −80 °C No ATB, probiotic or prebiotic 2 weeks prior sample collection N/A GIH
[27] Liu et al. 2019 China ASD: 30
HC: 20
ASD: 83/17
HC: 80/20
ASD: 4.4
HC: 4.3
N/A DSM-5
ICD-10
N/A −80 °C No ATB, probiotic, prebiotic or antifungal drugs 3 months prior sample collection Participants with special diets excluded 6-GSI
[28] Ma et al. 2019 China ASD: 45
HC: 45
ASD: 86.7/13.3
HC: 86.7/13.3
ASD: 7.0
HC: 7.3
N/A DSM-5
CARS
N/A −80 °C No ATB, probiotic or prebiotic 3 months prior sample collection 79-item food frequency questionnaire N/A
[29] Wang et al. 2019 China ASD: 43
HC: 31
ASD: 83.7/16.3
HC: 54.8/45.2
ASD: 4.5
HC: 3.1
N/A DSM-5 No psychiatric
disorder
−80 °C N/A yes Rome IV
[30] Dan et al. 2020 China ASD: 143
HC: 143
ASD: 90.9/9.1
HC: 88.8/11.2
ASD: 4.9
HC: 5.2
N/A DSM-5 No serious psychiatric disorder −80 °C No ATB, probiotic or prebiotic 3 months prior sample collection, no use of AIDs or antioxidant drugs N/A Rome IV
[31] Kang et al. 2013 USA ASD: 20
HC: 20
ASD: 90/10
HC: 85/15
ASD: 6.7
HC: 8.3
N/A ADOS
ADI-R
ATEC
PDD-BI
N/A −80 °C No ATB or antifungal drugs 1 month prior sample collection, probiotic and nutrient use recorded Special diets and seafood consumption recorded 6-GSI
[32] Chen et al. 2021 China ASD: 138
HC: 60
ASD: 84.8/15.2
HC: 45/55
ASD: 6.1
HC: 6.7
N/A ADOS
CARS
DSM-5
WISC-R
WPPSI
Gesell development scales −80 °C No ATB 1 month prior sample collection N/A GSI
[33] Vernocchi et al. 2022 Italy ASD: 41
HC: 35
ASD: 87.8/12.2
HC: 60/40
ASD: 6.5
HC: 8
ASD: 16.5
HC: 15.8
DSM-5
ADOS-2
ADI-R
CBCL
IQ/DQ tests
N/A −80 °C ATB, probiotic and psychiatric medication recorded Specific diets recorded Rome IV
[34] Wong et al. 2022 China ASD: 92
HC: 112
ASD: 100/0
HC: 100/0
ASD: 8.4
HC: 8.1
N/A DSM-5
AQ-10
SDQ
SCAS-P
AQ-10
SDQ
SCAS-P
−80 °C No ATB or regular probiotic use 1 month prior sample collection, use of psychiatric medication recorded yes
7 day food record
R4PDQ
[35] Finegold et al. 2010 USA ASD: 33
SIB: 7
HC: 8
ASD: 72.7/27.3
SIB: 28.6/71.4
HC: 62.5/37.5
Age range
2–13
N/A Authors’ evaluation of social, language, sensory and behaviour impairment N/A −80 °C No probiotic
or ATB
1 month prior sample collection
Special diets recorded yes
[36] Coretti et al. 2018 Italy ASD: 11
HC: 14
ASD: 81.8/18.2
HC: 57.1/42.9
ASD: 1.5
HC: 1.5
N/A DSM-5
ADOS-2 ADI-R
GMDS
VABS
CARS
N/A −80 °C No ATB, probiotic, prebiotic or synbiotic 1 month prior sample collection 3 days diet diary Rome III
[37] Li et al. 2019 China ASD: 59
HC: 30
ASD: 84.7/15.3
HC: 66.7/33.3
ASD: 4
HC: 5
N/A DSM-5
ADOS
ABC
N/A −80 °C No ATB, probiotic or prebiotic 3 months prior sample collection,
no AIDs or antioxidant drugs
N/A yes
[38] Zhai et al. 2019 China ASD: 78
HC: 58
ASD: 71.8/28.2
HC: 53.4/46.6
ASD: 5.0
HC: 4.9
N/A DSM-4-TR
ICD-10
ATEC
No history of ASD or neurological diseases −80 °C No ATB for 1 month prior sample collection, no probiotic or prebiotic N/A Participants with GI symptoms excluded
[39] Ding et al. 2020 China ASD: 77
HC: 50
ASD: 76.6/23.4
HC: 78/22
ASD: 1.6
HC: 1.8
N/A DSM-5
CARS
Social life ability scale,
Gessel Develop. Schedules
WISC
N/A −80 °C No ATB, probiotic or prebiotic 1 month prior sample collection yes N/A
[40] Zou et al. 2020 China ASD: 48
HC: 48
ASD: 79.2/20.8
HC: 50/50
ASD: 5
HC: 4
ASD: 17.4
HC: 16.3
DSM-4
ADI-R
CGI-S
ABC-I
No serious psychiatric disorder −80 °C No ATB or probiotic prior sample collection N/A N/A
[41] Ye et al. 2021 China ASD: 71
HC: 18
ASD: 100/0
HC: 100/0
ASD: 4.3
HC: 4.6
N/A ABC
DSM-5
ABC
DSM-5
−80 °C No ATB or probiotic 1 month prior sample collection, no AIDs or antioxidant drugs in HC group N/A N/A
[42] De Angelis et al. 2013 Italy ASD: 10
PDD: 10
SIB: 10
46.7/53.3
in all participants
Age range
4–10
N/A ADOS
ADI-R
CARS
N/A −80 °C No ATB, probiotic or prebiotic 1 month prior sample collection N/A Participants with GI symptoms excluded
[43] Niu et al. 2019 China ASD: 114
HC: 40
ASD: 83.3/16.7
HC: 50/50
ASD: 4.5
HC: 4.2
N/A DSM-5
ATEC
N/A N/A No ATB, probiotic or other GI treatment 1 month prior sample collection N/A yes
[44] Zurita et al. 2020 Ecuador ASD: 25
HC: 34
ASD: 96/4
HC: 91.4/8.6
ASD: 8.9
HC: 8.5
N/A ADI-R SCQ −80 °C No ATB or steroids 2 weeks prior sample collection 24-h dietary record N/A
[45] Fujishiro et al. 2022 Japan ASD: 7
HC: 9
ASD: 71.4/28.6
HC: 66.7/33.3
ASD: 10.1
HC: 14.6
N/A WISC-IV
Denver-II
ASSQ
M-CHAT
Paediatric and
Psychological
evaluation
WISC-IV
Denver-II
ASSQ
M-CHAT
Paediatrician and
Psychological
evaluation
−80 °C N/A yes yes
[46] Wan et al. 2022 China ASD: 64
HC: 64
ASD: 82.8/17.2
HC: 84.4/15.6
Median age
ASD: 2.5
HC: 2.3
N/A DSM-4
DSM-5
SRS-2 N/A No ATB, antifungal drugs, probiotic or prebiotic 2 months prior sample collection 3 day food record
Food frequency questionnaire
N/A
[47] Gondalia et al. 2012 Australia ASD: 51
HC: 53
ASD: 82.4/17.6
HC: 35.8/64.2
Age range
2–12
N/A Psychiatrist, psychologist
evaluation
CARS
N/A −20 °C No ATB or antifungal drugs 15 days prior sample collection, probiotic use recorded N/A yes
[48] Son et al. 2015 USA ASD: 59
SIB: 44
ASD: 88/12
SIB: 48/52
ASD: 10.3
SIB: 10.0
N/A ADOS
CBCL
CBCL −80 °C No ATB or probiotic 1 month prior sample collection One-week food/calorie count diary
Special diets recorded
QPGS-RIII
SSC
[49] Strati et al. 2017 Italy ASD: 40
HC: 40
ASD: 77.5/22.5
HC: 70/30
ASD: 11.1
HC: 9.2
N/A DSM-5
ADOS
ABC
CARS
N/A −80 °C No ATB, probiotic or prebiotic 3 months prior sample collection,
no use of AIDs or antioxidant drugs
N/A Rome III
[50] Berding et al. 2018 USA ASD: 26
HC: 32
ASD: 73.1/26.9
HC: 59.4/40.6
ASD: 4.1
HC: 4.8
ASD M: 16.8
ASD F: 15.1
HC M: 16.3
HC F: 16.8
PDDBI-SV N/A −80 °C No ATB, probiotic or prebiotic 3 months prior sample collection, no routine medication YAQ
3-day food diary
Patients with special diet excluded
6-GSI
Bristol stool chart
[51] Pulikkan et al. 2018 India ASD: 30
HC: 24
ASD: 93.3/6.7
† HC: 62.5/37.5
Median age
ASD: 9.5
HC: 9.5
Median BMI
ASD: 14.78
HC: 15.79
CARS
INDT-ASD
ISAA
Paediatric evaluation −80 °C No ATB, AIDs or antioxidant 1 month prior sample collection 7 days diet diary
No gluten-free diet
yes
[52] Zhang et al. 2018 China ASD: 35
HC: 6
ASD: 82.9/17.1
HC: 83.3/16.7
ASD: 4.9
HC: 4.6
N/A DSM-5 Medical evaluation
Parent interview
−80 °C No ATB, probiotic, prebiotic or APs 1 month prior sample collection Participants with special diets excluded N/A
[53] Ahmed et al. 2020 Egypt ASD: 41
SIB: 45
HC: 45
ASD: 68.3/31.7
SIB: 48.9/51.1
HC: 62.2/37.8
ASD: 5.6
SIB: 4.3
HC: 5.4
N/A DSM-5
CARS
N/A −80 °C No probiotic before sample collection yes 6-GSI
[54] Ha et al. 2021 Korea ASD: 54
HC: 38
ASD: 79.6/20.4
HC: 47.4/52.6
ASD: 7
HC: 6
N/A DSM-5
ADOS-2
ADI-R
SRS
IQ tests
Psychiatric evaluation
IQ tests
−80 °C No ATB 3 months and probiotic for 15 days prior sample collection N/A N/A
[55] Plaza-Díaz et al. 2019 Spain ASD: 48
HC: 57
N/A ASD: 1.8
HC: 2.1
ASD: 15.9
HC: 16.2
ADOS
PDD-BI
ADI-R
Battelle test
CARS
DSM-5
ICD-10
N/A −80 °C No treatment of behavioural comorbidities 24 h diet recorded
Food frequency questionnaire
N/A
[56] Xie et al. 2022 China ASD: 101
HC: 104
ASD: 85.1/14.9
HC: 76.9/22.1
ASD: 4.3
HC: 4.4
ASD: 16.3
HC: 15.7
DSM-5
CARS
N/A −80 °C No ATB, antifungal, AIDs, antioxidant, probiotic or prebiotic 1 month prior sample collection Participants with special diets excluded N/A
[57] Chiappori et al. 2022 Italy ASD: 6
HC: 6
ASD: 83.3/16.7
HC: 50/50
Age range:
ASD: 6–17
HC: 10–20
N/A DSM-5 N/A −80 °C N/A N/A N/A
[58] Sun et al. 2019 China ASD: 9
HC: 6
ASD: 88.9/11.1
HC: 66.7/33.3
Age range
3–12
N/A ICD-11 N/A −80 °C N/A N/A yes
[59] Parracho et al. 2005 UK ASD: 58
SIB: 12
HC: 10
ASD: 82.8/17.2
SIB: 58.3/41.7
HC: 60/40
ASD: 7
SIB: 6
HC: 6
N/A N/A N/A −20 °C No probiotic or
prebiotic in HC group for 6 months prior study,
ATB usage recorded
yes yes
[60] Adams et al. 2011 USA ASD: 58
HC: 39
ASD: 86.2/13.8
HC: 46.2/53.8
ASD: 6.9
HC: 7.7
N/A Professional assessment
ATEC
Parent report N/A No ATB or antifungal drugs 1 month prior sample collection,
probiotic use recorded
Seafood and fish-oil consumption recorded 6-GSI
[61] Wang et al. 2011 Australia ASD: 23
SIB: 22
HC: 9
ASD: 91.3/8.7
SIB: 50/50
HC: 44.4/55.6
ASD: 5.1
SIB: 6
HC: 4.8
N/A CARS
DSM-IV
ASSQ −80 °C ATB and probiotic use recorded Special diets recorded FGID
questionnaire
[62] Tomova et al. 2015 Slovakia ASD: 10
SIB: 9
HC: 10
ASD: 90/10
SIB: 77.8/22.2
HC: 100/0
Age range
ASD: 2–9
SIB: 5–17
HC: 2–11
N/A ICD-10 CARS
ADI
Psychiatric evaluation
Parent interview
−80 °C All participants medication free N/A Parental questionnaire
[63] Rose et al. 2018 USA ASD: 50
HC: 41
ASD: 84/16
HC: 92.7/7.3
Age range
3–12
N/A DSM-4
ADI-R
ADOS
ABC
SCQ
MSEL
VABS
ABC
N/A No ATB or antifungal drugs 1 month prior sample collection Dietary changes recorded GIH
Rome III
[64] Yitik Tonkaz et al. 2022 Turkey ASD: 30
SIB: 30
HC: 30
ASD: 86.7/11.3
SIB: 53.3/46.7
HC: 43.3/56.7
ASD: 7.3
SIB: 9.4
HC: 8.5
ASD: 17.7
SIB: 17.5
HC: 17.1
Psychiatric evaluation
DAWBA
DSM-5
CARS
Psychiatric evaluation
DAWBA
−80 °C No ATB or antifungal drugs 2 months prior sample collection, no probiotic or prebiotic prior sample collection Yes
Participants with special diets excluded
GSI
ADHD
[6] Wang et al. 2020 Taiwan ADHD: 30
HC: 30
ADHD: 76.7/23.3
HC: 60/40
ADHD: 8.4
HC: 9.3
N/A K-SADS-E
SNAP-IV
WISC
ADHD-RS
K-SADS-E
SNAP-IV
WISC
ADHD-RS
−80 °C Patients using ATB or probiotic
excluded
N/A
Vegetarians excluded
N/A
[17] Aarts et al. 2017 Netherlands ADHD: 19
HC: 77
ADHD: 68.4/31.6
HC: 53.2/46.8
ADHD: 19.5
HC: 27.1
ADHD: 23.8
HC: 23.0
DSM-4
K-SADS
N/A −80 °C No ATB or other medication 1 month prior sample collection N/A N/A
[77] Wan et al. 2020 China ADHD: 17
HC: 17
ADHD: 82.3/17.7
HC: 76.5/23.5
Median age
ADHD: 8
HC: 8
ADHD: 16.1
HC: 15.9
K-SADS CPRS K-SADS
CPRS
−80 °C No probiotic 1 month prior sample collection
N/A for ATB use
yes
Participants with special diets excluded
N/A
[78] Jiang et al. 2018 China ADHD: 51
HC: 32
ADHD: 49/51
HC: 68/32
ADHD: 8.5
HC: 8.5
ADHD: 16.4
HC: 16.1
K-SADS-PL CPRS Clinical interview
CPRS
−80 °C No ATB and probiotic for 2 month prior sample collection or concurrent use or history of ADHD drugs yes
Vegetarians excluded
N/A
[79] Szopinska-Tokov et al. 2020 Netherlands ADHD: 41
HC: 47
ADHD: 63/37
Ctrl: 49/51
ADHD: 20.2
HC: 20.5
Median BMI
ADHD: 23
HC: 22
K-SADS
CTRS
CAARS
N/A −80 °C 19 patients using ADHD medication N/A N/A
[80] Wang et al. 2022 Taiwan ADHD: 41
HC: 39
ADHD: 73.2/26.8
HC: 56.4/43.6
ADHD: 8
HC: 10
ADHD: 17.5
HC: 17.8
K-SADS-E
WISC-IV
Conners‘ CPT
SNAP-IV
K-SADS-E −80 °C No AIDs, ATB or probiotic 1 month prior sample collection,
no history of ADHD medication
Vegetarians excluded N/A
[81] Prehn-Kristensen et al. 2018 Germany ADHD: 14
HC: 17
ADHD: 100/0
HC: 100/0
ADHD: 11.9
HC: 13.1
ADHD: 19.0
HC: 18.0
K-SADS-PL CBCL
FBB-HKS
K-SADS-PL
CBCL
FBB-HKS
Not clear 10 patients using ADHD medication for more than 1 year,
9 of them discontinued 48h prior sample collection
yes N/A
Rett syndrome
[88] Strati et al. 2016 Italy RTT: 50
HC: 29
RTT: 0/100
HC: N/A
RTT: 12
HC: 17
N/A Genetic testing
CSS
N/A −80 °C No ATB, probiotic or prebiotic 3 months prior sample collection All participants under Mediterranean-based diet Rome III
Anorexia Nervosa
[92] Schulz et al. 2020 Germany AN: 19
HC: 20
AN: 0/100
HC: 0/100
AN: 15.77
HC: 16.35
AN: 15.8
HC: 20.3
DSM-5
EDI
BDI
SCAS
EDE
EDI
BDI
SCAS
−80 °C No ATB or probiotic 1 month prior sample collection, other medication recorded N/A N/A
Depressive Disorder
[18] Thapa et al. 2021 USA MDD: 110
HC: 27
PC: 10
MDD: 35/65
HC: 63/37
PC: 57/43
MDD: 19.5
HC: 20.3
PC: 19.1
N/A IDS, BDI-II
BAI
DSM-IV-TR
A-LIFE
N/A −80 °C No ATB 6 months prior sample collection N/A N/A
[94] Ling et al. 2022 China MDD: 92
HC: 48
MDD: 45.7/54.3
HC: 45.8/54.2
MDD: 8.84
HC: 9.27
MDD: 21.9
HC: 21.3
HAMD
DSM-5
CCMD-3
HAMD −80 °C No ATB, probiotic, prebiotic, synbiotic or psychiatric drugs 1 month prior sample collection yes N/A
[95] Zhou et al. 2022 China DD: 70
HC: 101
DD: 37.8/62.2
HC: 46.6/53.4
D: 13.7
HC: 13.5
D: 19.6
HC: 19.9
ICD-10
Mini-International Neuropsych. Interview
SDS
SAS
Clinical
interview
−80 °C No AIDs, ATB, probiotic, prebiotic or synbiotic 1 month prior sample collection N/A Bristol stool scale
GSRS
Tic Disorder
[102] Wang et al. 2022 China TD: 28
HC 21
TD: 60.7/39.3
HC: 61.9/38.1
TD: 8.2
HC: 7.9
TD: 19.3
HC: 18.8
DSM-5
Expert Consensus on Diagnosis and Treatment of TD in China
No psychiatric disorder
No physical illness
−80 °C No GCs,
ISs and AHs 15 days prior sample collection
No ATB and probiotic 2 months prior sample collection
N/A N/A
[103] Xi et al. 2021 China TD: 49
HC: 50
TD: 77.6/22.4
HC: 78/22
TD: 8.84
HC: 8.78
TD: 18.3
HC: matched
DSM-5
YGTSS
No psychiatric disorder −80 °C No ATB, probiotic, vitamins, IMs 1 month prior sample collection N/A GSI

A-LIFE—Adolescents Longitudinal Interval Follow-up Evaluation. ABC—Aberrant Behavior Checklist. ABC—Autism Behavior Checklist. ABC-I—Aberrant Behavior Checklist Irritability subscale score. ADHD-RS—ADHD Rating Scale. ADI-R—Autism Diagnostics Interview—Revised. ADOS—Autism Diagnostics Observation Schedule. AIDs—anti-inflammatory drugs. AHs—antihistamines. AMSE—Autism Mental Status Exam. APs—Antipsychotics. AQ-10—Autism Spectrum Quotient, 10-item parent report version. ASD—Autism Spectrum Disorder. ASSQ—Autism spectrum screening questionnaire. ATEC—Autism Treatment Evaluation Checklist. BAI—Beck Anxiety Inventory. BDI—Beck Depression Inventory-II. CAARS—Conners Adult ADHD Rating Scales. CABS—Clancy Autism Behavior Scale. CARS—Childhood Autism Rating Scale. CGI-S—Clinical Global Impression Severity of Illness scale. CBCL—Child Behavior Checklist. CCMD-3—Chinese Classification of Mental Disorder. Conners‘ CPT—Conners Continuous Performance Test. CPRS—Conners Parent Rating Scales. CSS—Clinical Severity Score. CTRS—Conners Teacher Rating Scale. DAWBA—Development and Well-Being Assessment. DSM-4—Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders—4th Edition. DSM-4-TR—Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders—4th Edition, Text Revision. DSM-5—Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders—5th Edition. EDE—Eating Disorder Examination. EDE-Q—Eating Disorder Examination-Questionnaire. EDI—Eating Disorder Inventory 2. FBB-HKS—German ADHD rating scale for children. FGID questionnaire—Functional Gastrointestinal Disorder questionnaire. GCs—glucocorticoids. GDS—Gesell Developmental Scale. GHQ—Gastrointestinal Health Questionnaire. GIH—GI history survey. GMDS—Griffiths Mental Development Scales. GSI—Gastrointestinal Severity Index. GSRS—Gastrointestinal Symptom Rating Scale. HAMD—Hamilton Depression Scale. HC—non-related healthy controls. ICD-10—International Statistics Classification of Disease and Related Health Problems, 10th Revision. ICD-11—International Statistics Classification of Disease and Related Health Problems, 11th Revision. IDS—Inventory of Depressive Symptomatology. IMs—immunomodulators. INDT-ASD—INCLEN Diagnostic Tool for Autism Spectrum Disorder. ISAA—Indian Scale for Assessment of Autism. ISs—Immunosupressants. IQ/DQ—Intelligent Quotient and Developmental Quotient. K-SADS—Kiddie Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia. K-SADS-PL—Kiddie SADS—Present and Lifetime Version. MSEL—Mullen Scales of Early Learning. NSAI—Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. PC—Psychiatric Controls. PDD-BI—Pervasive Developmental Disorder Behavior Inventory. PDDBI-SV—Pervasive Developmental Disorder Behavior Inventory Screening Version. PDD-NOS—Pervasive Developmental Disorder Not Otherwise Specified. QPGS—RIII—Pediatric Rome III Version. ROME III Diagnostic Questionnaire for the Paediatric Functional GI Disorders. R4PDQ—Rome IV Diagnostic Questionnaires for Paediatric Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders: Parent-report Form for Children. SAS—Self-Rating Anxiety Scale. SCAS—Spence Children’s Anxiety Scale. SDS—Self-Rating Depression Scale. SCQ—Social Communication Questionnaire. SIB—siblings. SNAP-IV—Swanson, Nolan, and Pelham Version IV Scale. SRS—Social Responsiveness Scale. SRS-2—Social Responsiveness Scale second edition. SSC—Simon Simplex Medical History. VABS—Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. WISC—Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children. YAQ—Youth and Adolescence Food Frequency questionnaire. YGTSS—Yale Global Tic Severity Sc. † HC mostly consisted of sibling or blood relatives of ASD children. If period of medication use is not mentioned, this was not precised in the original article.