Table 10.
Species | Plant Part/Extract | Antioxidant Assay | Antioxidant Effect | References |
---|---|---|---|---|
A. acutiloba | aerial parts, 60% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 18.69 µg/mL DE | [40] |
aerial parts, 60% methanol |
ABTS | IC50 = 6.17 µg/mL DE | ||
aerial parts, 60% methanol |
CHEL | IC50 = 21.60 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, 60% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 29.87 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, 60% methanol |
ABTS | IC50 = 14.29 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, 60% methanol |
CHEL | IC50 = 25.76 µg/mL DE | ||
aerial parts, butanol fraction |
DPPH | IC50 = 8.96 µg/mL DE | ||
aerial parts, butanol fraction |
ABTS | IC50 = 1.42 µg/mL DE | ||
aerial parts, butanol fraction |
CHEL | IC50 = 11.43 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, butanol fraction |
DPPH | IC50 = 12.08 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, butanol fraction |
ABTS | IC50 = 8.78 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, butanol fraction |
CHEL | IC50 = 12.33 µg/mL DE | ||
aerial parts, diethyl acetate fraction |
DPPH | IC50 = 8.83 µg/mL DE | ||
aerial parts, diethyl acetate fraction |
ABTS | IC50 = 6.54 µg/mL DE | ||
aerial parts, diethyl acetate fraction |
CHEL | IC50 = 18.89 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, diethyl acetate fraction |
DPPH | IC50 = 15.37 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, diethyl acetate fraction |
ABTS | IC50 =10.39 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, diethyl acetate fraction |
CHEL | IC50 = 19.30 µg/mL DE | ||
aerial parts, diethyl ether fraction |
DPPH | IC50 = 41.46 µg/mL DE | ||
aerial parts, diethyl ether fraction |
ABTS | IC50 = 16.28 µg/mL DE | ||
aerial parts, diethyl ether fraction |
CHEL | IC50 = 25.51 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, diethyl ether fraction |
DPPH | IC50 = 51.42 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, diethyl ether fraction |
ABTS | IC50 = 24.82 µg/mL DE | ||
roots, diethyl ether fraction |
CHEL | IC50 = 44.12 µg/mL DE | ||
A. alpina | aerial parts, methanol |
DPPH | % Inhibition = 45.4–94.4% | [47] |
A. arvensis | leaves, methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 97.72 µg/mL | [48] |
leaves, hexane |
IC50 = 11.22 µg/mL | |||
leaves, acetone |
IC50 = 4.86 µg/mL | |||
A. barbatiflora | aerial parts, methanol |
DPPH | % Inhibition = 83.44–95.35% | [25] |
aerial parts, hexane fraction |
% Inhibition = 18.6–59.62% | |||
aerial parts, chloroform fraction |
% Inhibition = 67.17–91.11% | |||
aerial parts, water fraction |
% Inhibition = 83.06–97.17% | |||
aerial parts, methanol |
SOD | % Inhibition = 83.34–85.83% | ||
aerial parts, hexane fraction |
% Inhibition = 9.80% | |||
aerial parts, chloroform fraction |
% Inhibition = 12.84–42.73% | |||
aerial parts, water fraction |
% Inhibition = 81.07% | |||
aerial parts, methanol |
PRA | Absorbance 0.932–1.280 | ||
aerial parts, hexane fraction |
Absorbance 0.355–0.612 | |||
aerial parts, chloroform fraction |
Absorbance 0.640–0.820 | |||
aerial parts, water fraction |
Absorbance 1.158–1.516 | |||
aerial parts, methanol |
FRAP | 44.32 mg BHAE/g DE | ||
aerial parts, chloroform fraction |
15.76 mg BHAE/g DE | |||
aerial parts, water fraction |
93.46 mg BHAE/g DE | |||
A. bulgarica | aerial parts, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 75.63 µg/mL | [49] |
A. crinita | aerial parts, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 46.03 µg/mL | [49] |
A. ellenbergiana | aerial parts, hexane |
DPPH | IC50 = 7.1 µg/mL | [50] |
A. ellenbergiana | aerial parts, ethanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 243.6 µg/mL | [51] |
aerial parts, methanol |
IC50 = 243.1 µg/mL | |||
A. erythropoda | aerial parts, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 30.67 µg/mL | [50] |
A. glabra | aerial parts, 80% acetone in 0.2% formic acid |
ORAC | IC50 = 1337 μmol TE/g | [32] |
TRAP | IC50 = 1815 μmol TE/g | |||
HORAC | IC50 = 1999 μmol GAE/g | |||
A. glabra | aerial parts, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 34.89 µg/mL | [49] |
A. glaucescens | aerial parts, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 36.10 µg/mL | [49] |
A. jumrukczalica | leaves, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 12.09 µg/mL | [43] |
A. mollis | shoots grown in vitro on different nutrient media | DPPH | IC50 = 18.6–38.1 μg/mL | [52] |
leaves of ex vitro adapted plants in Bulgarian mountains Vitosha | IC50 = 13.1 μg/mL | |||
one year old in vivo plantsgrown in Bulgarian mountains Viotsha | IC50 = 27.5 μg/mL | |||
one year old in vivo plantsgrown in Bulgarian mountains Rhodopes | IC50 = 22.2 μg/mL | |||
A. mollis | leaves, 50% ethanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 42.4 μg/mL | [53] |
ABTS | IC50 = 7.8 μg/mL | |||
A. mollis | aerial parts, water |
DPPH | IC50 = 0.264 mg/mL | [54] |
aerial parts, deodorized water |
IC50 = 0.146 mg/mL | |||
aerial parts, 50% methanol |
IC50 = 0.161 mg/mL | |||
aerial parts, water |
ABTS | 0.90 mmol/L/Trolox | ||
aerial parts,deodorized water | 0.4 mmol/L/Trolox | |||
aerial parts,50% methanol | 0.4 mmol/L/Trolox | |||
A. mollis | aerial parts, 70% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 0.21 mg/mL | [36] |
aerial parts,water | IC50 = 0.24 mg/mL | |||
aerial parts, 70% methanol |
ABTS | TEAC = 0.75 mmol/Trolox | ||
aerial parts,water | TEAC = 0.83 mmol/Trolox | |||
aerial parts,hexane, ethyl acetate, methanol, butanol, 70% methanol, water | Inhibition of β-carotene/linoleic acid co-oxidation | no data | ||
A. mollis | dry stalks, aqueous ethanol |
FRAP | TEAC = 382.78 mmol TE/g DW | [55] |
dry stalks, aqueous ethanol |
CUPRAC | TEAC = 363.79 mmol TE/g DW | ||
dry stalks, aqueous ethanol |
DPPH | TEAC = 247.58 mmol TE/g DW | ||
dry stalks, aqueous ethanol |
ABTS | TEAC = 308.44 mmol TE/g DW | ||
A. mollis | aerial parts, methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 31.7 μg/mL | [27] |
aerial parts, ethyl acetate fraction |
IC50 = 9.8 μg/mL | |||
aerial parts, petroleum fraction |
IC50 = > 200 μg/mL | |||
aerial parts, chloroform fraction |
IC50 = > 200 μg/mL | |||
aerial parts, water residue fraction |
IC50 = 42.5 μg/mL | |||
A. persica | aerial parts, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 0.055 M | [3] |
roots, 80% methanol |
IC50 = 0.151 M | |||
aerial parts, 80% methanol |
TBARS | MDA = 5.9 nmol/mL | ||
roots, 80% methanol |
MDA = 19.08 nmol/mL | |||
A. monticola | aerial parts, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 32.72 μg/mL | [49] |
A. obtusa | aerial parts, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 26.35 μg/mL | [49] |
A. sericata | aerial parts, hexane |
DPPH | IC50 = 185 μg/mL | [56] |
A. vulgaris | leaves, 50% ethanol |
DPPH | % Inhibition = 71.8% | [57] |
A. vulgaris | aerial parts, methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 5.40 µg/mL | [58] |
ABTS | IC50 = 60.10 µg/mL | |||
A. vulgaris | aerial parts, methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 5.96 µg/mL | [11] |
roots, methanol |
IC50 = 11.86 µg/mL | |||
aerial parts, methanol |
ABTS | IC50 = 14.80 µg/mL | ||
roots, methanol |
IC50 = 32.49 µg/mL | |||
aerial parts, methanol |
Hydroxyl radical scavenging activity | IC50 = 13.06 µg/mL | ||
roots, methanol |
IC50 = 18.44 µg/mL | |||
aerial parts, methanol |
Inhibition of lipid peroxidation | IC50 = 31.91 µg/mL | ||
roots, methanol |
IC50 = 475.13 µg/mL | |||
aerial parts, methanol |
Reducing power | IC50 = 632.99 mg TE/g DE | ||
roots, methanol |
IC50 = 607.52 mg TE/g DE | |||
aerial parts, methanol |
Total antioxidant activity | IC50 = 265.62 mg AA/g DE | ||
roots, methanol |
IC50 = 316.47 mg AA/g DE | |||
A. vulgaris | leaves, 80% ethanol |
DPPH | % inhibition = 131.74% | [37] |
A. vulgaris | roots, 50% ethanol |
TEAC | 68.21 mmol TE/g DW | [59] |
FRAP | 40.12 mmol TE/g DW | |||
A. vulgaris | aerial parts, cyclohexane |
DPPH | IC50 = 23.12 µg/mL | [44] |
A. vulgaris | aerial parts, 80% methanol |
DPPH | 153.30 mg TE/g DE | [39] |
ABTS | 143.55 mg TE/g DE | |||
CUPRAC | 216.14 mg TE/g DE | |||
PRAP | 1.77 mmol TE/g DE | |||
CHEL | 42.58 mg EDTAE/g DE | |||
FRAP | 7899.45 mg AAE/g DE | |||
aerial parts, 70% ethanol |
DPPH | 95.99 mg TE/g DE | ||
ABTS | 119.62 mg TE/g DE | |||
CUPRAC | 203.53 mg TE/g DE | |||
PRAP | 1.57 mmol TE/g of DE | |||
CHEL | 42.32 mg EDTAE/g DE | |||
FRAP | 6405.75 mg AAE/g DE | |||
aerial parts, 70% ethyl-acetate |
DPPH | 502.56 mg TE/g DE | ||
ABTS | 174.05 mg TE/g DE | |||
CUPRAC | 283.16 mg TE/g DE | |||
PRAP | 2.22 mmol TE/g DE | |||
CHEL | 37.96 mg EDTAE/g DE | |||
FRAP | 8745.31 AAE/g DE | |||
aerial parts, water |
DPPH | 89.25 mg TE/g DE | ||
ABTS | 37.50 mg TE/g DE | |||
CUPRAC | 78.56 mg TE/g DE | |||
PRAP | 0.53 mmol TE/g DE | |||
CHEL | 39.23 mg EDTAE/g DE | |||
FRAP | 3240.09 mg AAE/g DE | |||
A. vulgaris | aerial parts, ethanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 0.11 μg/mL | [38] |
aerial parts, water |
IC50 = 27.22 μg/mL | |||
aerial parts, propylene glycolic |
IC50 = 2.88 μL/mL | |||
A. vulgaris | aerial parts, 70% ethanol |
DPPH | 87.95% (at 3 mg/mL) and 80.71% (at 1.5 mg/mL) | [31] |
A. vulgaris | leaves, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 19.62 µg/mL | [43] |
A. xanthochlora | aerial parts, 80% methanol |
DPPH | IC50 = 41.78 µg/mL | [49] |
A. xanthochlora | leaves,hexane | TLC-DPPH analysis, DPPH | no data | [13] |
leaves, chloroform |
no data | |||
leaves, ethylacetate |
no data | |||
leaves, methanol |
no data | |||
leaves, water |
no data |
DPPH, 2.2-diphenyl-1-picryl-hydrazyl free radical scavenging activity; ABTS, 2,2′-azinobis [3-ethylbenzthiazoline]-6-sulfonic acid decolorization assay; CHEL, metal chelating activity; DE, dry extract; SOD, superoxide radical scavenging; PRAP, phosphomolibdenum-reducing antioxidant power; FRAP, ferric-reducing antioxidant power; BHAE, butylated hydroxyanisole equivalents; ORAC, oxygen radical absorbance capacity; TE, Trolox equivalents; TRAP, total peroxyl-radical antioxidant parameter; HORAC, hydroxyl radical averting capacity; GAE, gallic acid equivalents; CUPRAC, cupric reducing antioxidant capacity; DW, dry weight; TBARS, thiobarbituric acid reactive substances assay; MDA, malondialdehyde level; TEAC, Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity; EDTAE, ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid equivalent; AAE, ascorbic acid equivalents; no data—results on the figures, without values.