Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 27;11:231. doi: 10.1186/s13643-022-02072-6

Table 2.

Characteristics of included studies

First author, year Country, period of data collection Sample type (national/subnational) Sample size UIC median [IQR] or [mean ± sd] Risk of bias: 0–3 low
4–6 intermediate
7–9 high
Before 1995
 Chaouki, 1994 [23] Algeria (1994) Sub-national 982 [17.9 ± 0.1] 2 – low
 Ngo, 1997 [24] DRC (1991–1992) National 306 39.3 [31.1, 52.9] 0 – low
19952005
 Hess, 1999 [25] Cote de'Ivore Sub-national 72 351 [74 - 2241] 2 – low
 Hess, 1999 [25] Cote de'Ivore Sub-national 66 136 [12 - 915] 1 – low
 Ojule 1998 [26] Nigeria, 1998 Sub-national 90 [213.4 ± 9.9] 3 – low
 Ojule 1998 [26] Nigeria, 1998 Sub-national 105 [149 ± 14.7] 3 – low
 Dillon, 2000 [27] Senegal 1996–1997 Sub-national 462 [60 ± 39] 1 – low
 Eltom, 2000 [28] Sudan 1998–1999 Sub-national 47 38 [12.7, 50.8] 3 – low
 Lwenje, 2000 [29] Swaziland National 165 295 [95% CI 265.5–425.6] 1 – low
20062020
 Akdader-Oudahmane, 2020 [30] Algeria 2016–2017 Sub-national 173 233 [157, 326] 4 – intermediate
 Garnier et al., 2016 [31] Burkina Faso National 946 74 [NA, NA] 1 – low
 Kavishe et al., 2020 [32] Burundi 2018 National 87 86.7 [NA, NA] 1 – low
 Habimana et al., 2013 [33] DRC, 2009–2011 Sub-national 225 138 [105, 172] 1– low
 IGN, 2017 [14, 34] Djibouti, 2015 (NS) National 230 265 [170, 445] 0 – low
 MOHP, 2017 [35] Egypt, 2014–2015 National 1498 135 [NA, NA] 0 – low
 Hamza, 2007 [36] Egypt, 2006 Sub-national 113 [102.9 ± 31.1] 2 – low
 Elsayed, 2016 [37] Egypt,2016 Sub-national 400 170 [NA, NA] 1 – low
 Mohammed, 2020 [38] Ethiopia, 2013–2014 Sub-national 562 120.6 [68.9, 216.4] 1 – low
 Fereja, 2018 [39] Ethiopia Sub-national 354 85.7 [45.7, 136] 1 – low
 Kedir, 2014 [40] Ethiopia, 2012 Sub-national 435 58.1[21.4, 111.1] 1 – low
 Ersino, 2013 [41] Ethiopia, 2009 Sub-national 172 15 [2.5, 33] 2 – low
 Takele, 2017 [42] Ethiopia, 2017 Sub-national 403 137 [97, 177] 1 – low
 Keno, 2017 [43] Ethiopia, 2014 Sub-national 40 88.6 [66.9, 133.5] 3 – low
 Negeri, 2014 [44] Ethiopia, 2011 Sub-national 423 48 [NA, NA] 2 – low
 NaNA, 2019 [45] Gambia 2018 National 118 113.5 [50.1, 205.9] 0 – low
 GHS, 2017 [46] Ghana, 2015 National 102 183.5 [NA, NA] 0 – low
 Gyamfi, 2018 [47] Ghana, 2016 (ss) Sub-national 239 159 [NA, NA] 3 – low
 Adu-Afarwuah, 2018 [48] Ghana, 2009–2011 Sub-national 295 137 [78, 221] 2 – low
 Farebrother et al., 2018 [49] Kenya Sub-national 162 337 [198, 505] 4 – intermediate
 Randremanana, 2019 [50] Madagascar, 2014 National 170 53 [9, 89] 0 – low
 Stinca, 2017 [51, 52] Morocco 2013–2014 Sub-national 245 32 [17, 58] 3 – low
 Sadou 2013 [53] Niger 2012 Sub-national 240 119 [NA, NA] 2 – low
 Hess, 2016 [54] Niger, 2014–2015 Sub-national 662 69 [38.1, 114.3] 1 – low
 Jibril, 2016 [55] Nigeria, 2014 Sub-national 300 193 [NA, NA] 2 – low
 Kayode, 2019 [56] Nigeria, 2012 Sub-national 133 135 [NA, NA] 1 – low
 Ujowundu, 2010 [57] Nigeria, 2009 Sub-national 302 [152.09 ± 41.65 ] 2 – low
 Rohner, 2016 [58] Sierra Leone, 2013 National 154 175.8 [NA, NA] 0 – low
 MOH-FGS, 2020 [34] Somalia, 2018–2019 National 236 369 [142.9, 752] 0 – low
 Mabasa, 2019 [59] South Africa, 2012–2013 Sub-national 565 164 [92, 291] 3 – low
 Stinca, 2017 [51, 52] South Africa Sub-national 207 174 [95.3, 297.6] 3 – low
 Mtumwa, 2017 [60] Tanzania, 2009–2010 National 947 136.8 [58.8, 258] 1 – low
 Ba, 2020 [61] Tanzania, 2015–2016 National 266 156.1 [64.6, 260.4] 0 – low
 Stinca, 2017 [51, 52] Tanzania, 2016 Sub-national 330 422 [270, 609] 3 – low
 Chinyanga, 2006 [62] Zimbabwe, 2006 Sub-national 94 115.5 [43, 225] 4 – intermediate