Table 1.
Study | Participants (n = ) | Communicative functions | Notes/Comments |
---|---|---|---|
Wolff and Chess (1965) | 14 participants 12 x males 2 x females Aged under 8 years |
Delayed Communicative
repetitions Requests
|
Represented the first study to note that delayed repetitions could serve a communicative function. |
Dyer and Hadden (1981) | (No participants) |
Delayed
Echolalia Negativistic
|
A total of 6 possible functional categories were described in a continuum style. That is, the 4 categories included in this table represent the most communicatively functional echoes. The remaining 2 (stereotypic and egocentric) were believed to serve possible cognitive and self-regulatory purposes. Transferred and mitigated appeared to serve the same function. However, mitigated echolalia is characterised by modifications to the original utterances. |
Prizant and Duchan (1981) | 4 x males Aged 4:8, 5:2, 6:3, 9:3 |
Immediate
Echolalia Turn taking
|
A total of 7 possible functional categories were advanced in the model, however only 4 of these were deemed to serve a communicative function, as seen in the column to the left. The remaining 3 (non-focused, rehearsal and self-regulatory) categories possibly served a cognitive function. |
Prizant and Rydell (1984) | 3 x males Aged 4:8, 12:4, 14:2 |
Delayed
Echolalia Turn taking
|
A total of 14 possible functional categories were advanced in the model, however only 9 of these were deemed to serve a communicative function, as seen in the column to the left. The remaining 5 (non-focused, situation association, rehearsal, self-directive and label (non-interactive)) categories possibly served a cognitive function. |
Sterponi and Shankey (2014) | 1 x male Aged 5:10 |
Immediate
Echolalia After correction
Other echoes
|
A 6-category model was advanced, with other non-communicative immediate repetitions possibly serving a function only known to the child, termed unusual echoes. |
Marom et al. (2018) | 3 participants 2 x male 1 x female Aged: 5:2m, 6:6m, 5:8f |
Echoing to express strong emotional content
|
This study did not separate echoes pertaining to time (i.e., immediate or delayed). As such communicative echoes were heard as both immediate and delayed repetitions. Model was a total of 6-categories, serving a variety of social-emotional, learning and communicative functions. |
Age – respectively (years:months).